跳到正文
原文
Nature Biotechnology· Gaoyang Li·· 2026-10-15精选AI 评分65

基于HitSV方法在多种测序技术下进行结构变异检测研究

Structural variant detection across sequencing technologies

AI 导读

研究人员开发了一种名为HitSV的序列无关结构变异(SV)检测算法,通过建模局部基因组背景对对齐信号的影响,结合渐进式聚类与单倍型解析的局部组装,实现了在长读长、短读长及混合测序数据中的稳健SV重建,并在大规模中国队列中发现由串联重复和移动元件阵列构成的复合重复结构。

推荐理由

该研究通过HitSV算法在不同测序技术下实现结构变异的精准检测,并为群体遗传学研究提供新的数据资源与解读视角。

正文 · AI 翻译

译文尚不完整,完整内容请切换到原文。

主文

结构变异(SVs),通常定义为大于50 bp的基因组改变,源于不同的全基因组突变过程1,2,并对遗传和表观遗传变异有重要贡献3,4,5,6。在表型层面,SVs与疾病易感性密切相关7,8,9。群体规模分析进一步表明,SVs占了个体间基因组差异的很大一部分,并常富集于重复序列或结构不稳定的基因组区域3,5,10。因此,全面的SV检测对于群体基因组学和医学遗传学均至关重要;然而,这一过程仍具挑战性。短读长测序(SRS)因其低成本和高通量,仍然是大规模队列研究的主流方法,但受限于较短的读长,尤其对于嵌入重复序列或涉及插入的SVs11,12。长读长测序(LRS)能更完整地发现SVs10,13,14,但受到测序成本和数据量需求的制约。

目前最先进的 SV calling 方法大多从读段比对特征推断 SV15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,例如断裂比对、不一致读段对(DRPs)、大片段剪接(CLP)和局部读段深度26,27,28。许多工具依赖特征聚类与统计模型来推断 SV 事件20,21,22,而另一些则结合局部组装以改进等位基因重建15,24。这些方法已被广泛应用于大规模基因组学研究29,30,31,并进一步扩展用于处理特定 SV 类型或基因组区域32,33,34,以及集成到多个工具流程中35,36。基于组装的方法也得到了一定发展37,38,通过长读段连续性来解决大型和复杂的重排。然而,其应用仍受到高测序覆盖度需求39,40,41、易受错误组装影响42,43,44以及单倍型解析不完整45的限制。因此,基于比对的信息继续为跨测序策略的可扩展 SV 发现提供不可或缺的基础。尽管如此,此类方法受到比对复杂性的显著影响,尤其在重复区域和复杂 SV 中,SV 相关信号变得微弱、异质且系统性地失真。

在此,我们提出了HitSV,这是一种与读长无关的结构变异(SV)检测方案,该方案显式建模局部基因组背景对比对特征的影响,并整合了渐进式聚类与单倍型分辨的局部组装,以实现稳健的SV重建。该方法在各种测序技术中均取得了较高的检出率,显著降低了对长读长(LRS)数据量的要求,同时最大化了短读长(SRS)数据的SV发现能力。通过提高在富含重复序列和结构模糊区域的SV重建精度,HitSV显著增强了对复杂形式SV的解析度。我们将HitSV应用于大规模中国队列扫描,识别出具有串联-转座子阵列特征的复合重复结构,突显了复合重复组织作为人类基因组中一种普遍存在且此前未被充分重视的结构特征。

结果

HitSV概述

HitSV是一种基于比对的SV检测方案,支持长读长、短读长和混合测序数据。它解决了一个长期存在的局限性——比对信号在重复和复杂区域会系统地失真,导致变异被遗漏、碎片化或表征错误。HitSV通过显式建模基因组重复性与信号强度之间的相互作用,重新设计了核心阶段——SV位点识别、SV特征聚类和SV重建及基因分型(图 1;方法)。

图1:HitSV的示意图。

a,HitSV的概念概览。HitSV统一处理长读长、短读长和混合读长数据,在不同局部重复性背景(低重复、中重复和高重复区域)下识别比对来源的SV特征,并通过基于dBG的局部组装重建SV单倍型。b,按局部重复性分层的基因组窗口中SV信号强度的分布。比对信号包括SDA(针对长读长和短读长)、CLP(针对长读长和短读长)和DRP(仅针对短读长)。对于每个面板,x轴代表局部窗口内支持SV的信号数量,y轴代表具有相应信号强度的窗口比例。分布图示表明SV信号特征随局部重复复杂性而变化,从而推动了HitSV使用的重复感知信号识别策略。c,渐进式SV特征聚类。HitSV构建概率模型,利用聚类读长的比对信号推断虚拟SV断点,然后连接不同断点周围的各种聚类,这些聚类基于基因组位置或读长对或拆分比对的长程信息。图中以倒位为例。d,单倍型分辨的局部组装。HitSV使用基于unitig的dBG进行单倍型分辨的局部组装,该dBG整合了含有变异的读长和不含有变异的读长。对于短读长,覆盖度引导的遍历生成超出读长限制的contig。对于长读长,候选contig通过聚类unitig-dBG路径并通过基于SDP的重比对迭代优化来推导。对于混合数据,长读长contig作为骨架,并用短读长共识进行抛光。

SV位点识别

HitSV采用一种对重复性和特征密度敏感的断点识别策略,利用群体规模的参考LRS和SRS数据(HPRC46和1KGP6中的40个共享样本)对不同局部重复程度下的SV特征密度进行建模。它针对序列差异、剪切和DRP等信号类型,在重复背景下构建经验分布。这些分布为基于规则、特定于数据类型的判据提供信息,从而在信号减弱或被掩盖的重复富集区域实现灵敏检测(扩展数据图1和补充说明1)。

SV特征聚类

跨越SV的读段经常表现出混杂的断点信号,尤其是在大型、杂合或重复相关的重排中。HitSV通过一种渐进式聚类策略应对这些挑战,该策略将断点视为从SV特征推断出的潜在变量(补充图1)。通过迭代优化断点概率分布并整合兼容的聚类,HitSV聚合来自分散信号的碎片化证据,并解缠来自不同等位基因的重叠特征,从而准确恢复复杂事件。

SV重建与基因分型

HitSV使用以unitig为中心的de Bruijn图(unitig-dBG)进行单倍型分辨的局部组装,该图整合了SV影响区域内支持变异的读段和非变异读段(补充图2)。对于短读段数据,基于覆盖度信息的图遍历可生成超出固有读长限制的候选contig。对于长读段数据,HitSV通过对源自读段的unitig-dBG路径进行聚类来构建候选contig。对于混合数据,HitSV以长读段contig为骨架,并用短读段共有序列对其进行抛光。候选等位基因基于k-mer统计建模进行评估,该建模重新比对组成读段,以识别用于SV检测和基因分型的最可能的contig对。这种方法缓解了保守但截短的等位基因推断与激进但易错的重建之间的权衡,从而实现对复杂SV的高保真和单倍型感知的表征。

跨平台、人类队列和物种的基准测试展示了HitSV的高产出和多功能性

我们使用102个人类数据集和6个非人物种(即Macaca fascicularis47、Mus musculus48、Drosophila melanogaster49、Danio rerio50、Arabidopsis thaliana51和Glycine max52)评估了HitSV在长读长测序(LRS)、短读长测序(SRS)和混合设置下的表现。我们比较了总共13个具有代表性的最先进结构变异(SV)检测工具,包括5个LRS检测工具(Sniffles2(参考文献53)、cuteSV2(参考文献22)、SVDSS2(参考文献24)、Sawfish54和SVision-pro55)、4个SRS检测工具(Manta15、LUMPY16、DELLY17和GATK-SV3)、1个混合检测工具(blend-seq56)以及3个泛基因组信息或基于图的方法(DRAGEN35、PanGenie57、VG58;补充表1和2)。

LRS基准测试

在采用NIST-Q100真实数据(v1.1(参考文献59))的基因组瓶计划(GIAB)HG002基准测试中,HitSV在30× PacBio HiFi和ONT数据上的基因型F1分数(F1-GTs)分别达到85.00%和88.48%,比最先进(SOTA)检测工具高15.34–71.68%(图2a和补充表3和4),且随着Truvari参数变得更加严格,优势变得更大(扩展数据图2a)。我们将该基准进一步扩展到HGSVC13样本中涵盖所有五个千人基因组计划(1KGP)超级人群的35个样本,共70个LRS数据集。HitSV的平均F1-GTs比最佳次优检测工具高12.82%(PacBio)和12.93%(ONT)(图2b和补充表5)。HG002的F1-GT落在根据HGSVC估算的95%预测区间内,表明其在人类数据集上的一致性表现。此外,HitSV展示了跨物种的可迁移性。在动物和植物基因组中,相对于评估的LRS检测工具,HitSV在使用相同的经验性特征分布模型的情况下,实现了平均4.83–14.54%(PacBio)和3.25–21.71%(ONT)的F1分数优势(图2a和补充表6)。

图 2:不同物种和平台上的基准测试。

a,基于F1分数对多种SV检测器在人类(含基因分型,F1-GTs)和另外六个物种(无基因分型)中、在不同测序策略和平台上的评估——LRS-PacBio(第一行)、LRS-ONT(第二行)、混合模式(第三行)和SRS(第四行)。ASM5/ASM10/ASM20 指 Dipcall 中用于 T2T 组装与参考基因组之间基因组比对所使用的参数,这些参数生成不同大小的真实调用集(补充表 6)。混合模式面板中的红色实线和紫色虚线分别表示 Sniffles2 在 30× PacBio 和 ONT LRS 数据上的 F1 分数。由于该数据集中缺乏短读长数据,未评估 D. rerio 的混合模式和 SRS 模式。b,来自 35 个 HGSVC 样本的 PacBio(左)和 ONT(右)数据集的 F1-GT 分数的小提琴图。嵌入式箱线图中,中位线表示中位数,箱体边界表示第 25 和第 75 百分位数,须线表示 1.5× IQR 内的极端值。未显示异常值。所有数据集在评估前均先降采样至 30×。Sawfish 和 SVDSS2 在大多数 ONT 数据集上崩溃,因此其分布未纳入比较(右图)。值得注意的是,所有工具在 HGSVC 和物种 ONT 数据集上的检出率均有所降低(部分甚至失败)。我们发现其读长质量明显较低,可能源于较旧的化学试剂和超长测序,这影响了 SV 等位基因的重组。相反,使用最新化学试剂的 HG002-ONT 数据集具有更高的质量(Q26),支持获得比 PacBio 更高的检出率。c,DRAGEN、VG 和 PanGenie 的 HitSV 真实阳性调用与假阴性调用之间的 UpSet 图,展示了 HitSV 救回的被泛参考覆盖的 SV 数量。IQR,四分位距;PB,PacBio。

混合模式基准测试

混合模式旨在适用于群体规模队列或非模式生物项目中深度 LRS 变得不切实际的情况。在 HG002 中,HitSV 使用 4× LRS 加上 30× SRS 数据所达到的性能与或高于仅使用 30× LRS 的 Sniffles,并在匹配 4× PacBio 加 30× SRS 的设置下,比 blend-seq 高出 11.92%(图 2a 和补充表 7)。在六个非人类物种中也观察到类似趋势,特别是基于 HiFi 的数据集(图 2a 和补充表 6)。因此,混合测序提供了具有成本效益的选择,而非高深度 LRS 在 SV 发现中的替代方案。

SRS 基准测试

在 HG002 中,HitSV 的 F1-GT 显著高于单参考 SRS 检测器 Manta 和 DELLY(分别高出 10.47% 和 20.28%),并且优于 GATK-SV 等整合流水线(图 2a 及补充表 6 和 8)。该优势在 GIAB hard 和 easy 区域中均持续存在60(扩展数据图 2b)。在多物种基准测试中,HitSV 的 F1 得分比单参考检测器高出 10.76–24.52%。我们还比较了 HitSV 与三种基于泛基因组的 SOTA 检测器。HitSV 的精确率显著更高。除了有助于新结构变异(SV)的发现(补充表 9)外,它还在泛参考覆盖区域中挽救了大量基于泛基因组的检测器的假阴性(FN)(方法;图 2c,补充注释 2 和补充表 10)。

总体而言,HitSV 在长读长、短读长以及经过基准测试的混合测序数据中均表现出高性能,同时大幅降低了可靠结构变异发现所需的长读长覆盖率。结合在跨物种基因组和 3,202 样本 1KGP 基准测试中可负担的时间成本和内存使用(补充注释 3 及补充表 11 和 12),这些结果支持其在大规模研究中的实际应用。

HitSV 在不同情境下的表征

我们进一步研究了 HitSV 在 HG002 基准中在基因组变异(即结构变异类型、大小和局部参考序列)及测序深度等情境下的表现。观察到三个优势。

首先,HitSV 在结构变异重建方面具有卓越的精确率。在 Truvari ‘refine’ 模式下,在所有严格度阈值下,HitSV 在序列级重建准确性方面优于 Sawfish(图 3a 及补充表 13)。具体而言,在 95% 相似度(-p 0.95)下,HitSV 的 F1-GT 为 96.70%,而 Sawfish 为 91.44%;在完美重建(-p 1)下,HitSV 为 83.61%,Sawfish 为 72.58%。这源于在组装和等位基因选择中使用了所有跨越结构变异的 reads,而不仅仅是靠近比对推断断裂点的 read 片段。

图 3:HitSV 在 GIAB HG002 样本不同情境下的表征。

a,使用 Truvari 的“refine”模式,在不同严格度(-p,0.7、0.9、0.95、0.98、1)和读长类型(PacBio 和 ONT 读长)下,HitSV 和 Sawfish 对 SV 重建的基于基础水平的精确度。b,各 SV 调用工具在各类基因组区域(根据 RepeatMasker 和 CMRG 的注释)的 GT-F1 分数。c,不同 SV 类型和大小的长读长 F1-GT 分数。DEL(上)和 INS(下)按 SV 长度分箱,如 x 轴所示。d,HitSV 使用 SRS 数据调用大型插入的一个示例。IGV 快照显示了 chr21: 39,908,212 处的大型插入事件,这是一类典型的 Retroposon/SVA 插入,仅通过 HitSV 定制的读长聚类和本地组装方法检测到。e,不同读长覆盖率(1–30 dBG)下长读长 SV 调用工具的 F1-GT 分数。虚线表示 HitSV 的混合模块,结合相应的长读长和不同量的短读长(粉色,60×;黄色,30×)。f,使用混合测序数据与仅用长读长的 HitSV 调用结果的比较。成对比较了有无 60× 短读长的不同长读长覆盖率(1×、2×、4×、10×)的 SV 调用结果。红色(左)和青色(右)柱分别表示两种数据配置均产生的真阳性调用数,以及仅通过混合测序数据产生的调用数。g,按 SV 类型和大小分层的 HitSV 产生的 FNs 和 FPs 数量。缺失(DEL,左)和插入(INS,右)按 SV 长度分箱(x 轴)。颜色代表测序策略;深色和浅色分别代表 FPs 和 FNs。DEL,缺失;INS,插入;FPs,假阳性;CMRG,挑战性医学相关基因。

其次,HitSV 的优势在挑战性基因组区域和 SV 类型中更为明显。SV 在包括简单重复、SINE 和卫星富集区域等高度重复类别中,以及在 GIAB 挑战性医学基因(Challenging Medical Relevant Genes61;图 3b 和补充表 14)中均被稳健检测。此外,对于其他调用工具性能下降的长(>1 kb)和超长(>5 kb)INS 事件,HitSV 产生了高产量,使 NIST-Q100 调用集中 DEL 和 INS 的产量更加平衡(图 3c,d、扩展数据图 2c,d 和补充表 15)。在不使用泛基因组的情况下,HitSV 以高精确度从短读长中回收了大量 >1 kb 的插入(169/183,92.35%),而其他 *de novo* 调用工具的召回率较低(Manta = 14/57,24.56%;LUMPY = 33/190,17.37%;DELLY = 28/176,15.91%)。在不同程度的局部重复性和比对性水平下,精确度始终保持较高(补充表 16),且回收的插入主要是移动元件插入(MEI)相关(补充表 17)。

第三,HitSV 在有限的 LRS 深度下具有鲁棒性。我们将 HG002 LRS 数据集下采样,发现 HitSV 在 6× 数据上的表现超过了主要调用器在 30× 数据上的表现;在 10× 数据下,HitSV 达到了 Sawfish 的饱和产量(图 3e 和补充表 18)。将低覆盖度 LRS(2–4×)与标准深度 SRS 相结合的混合配置实现了与单独使用高覆盖度 LRS 相当、甚至在某些情况下更优的性能(图 3e)。通常,仅一条跨越结构变异(SV)的长 Reads 就足以让 HitSV 指导 SV 等位基因选择(补充图 3),而相反,SRS 数据为长 Reads 覆盖不足的断点识别区域提供了密集的局部证据。此外,在极端 LRS 覆盖度(1–2×)下,SRS 数据贡献了相当一部分(27.25–42.76%)的产量(图 3f 和补充表 19)。这些结果强调了 HitSV 在处理低深度 LRS 数据方面的有效性以及联合建模的优势。

最后,我们表征了 HitSV 的假阴性(FN)和假阳性谱(图 3g)。错误集中在极端重复或低映射能力背景下——假阴性主要反映了缺乏跨越证据而导致的插入(INS)漏检,而假阳性则源于模糊的等位基因表示、重复拷贝数估计或稀疏的长 Reads 支持。在 HGSVC 样本中观察到类似的模式(补充说明 4)。

HitSV 在大规模基因组学数据集中的应用

为了评估 HitSV 在群体规模 SRS 设置下的表现,我们重新分析了 1KGP 第 4 阶段队列(n = 3,202;补充表 12)。所得的 HitSV-SRS 调用集与由 GATK-SV、svtools 和 Absinthe6 联合流程生成的官方 1KGP-SRS 调用集进行了比较。在整个队列中,HitSV 识别出 228,025 个 SV,比官方 1KGP-SRS 调用集增加了 31.5%。共有 93,242 个 SV 未在 1KGP-SRS 调用集中报告。平均而言,每个基因组识别出的 SV 数量多 18.3%(11,405 对比 9,639),这一结果在各超种群中保持一致(图 4a)。

图 4:HitSV 对 1KGP 数据集的重新分析。

a,HitSV-SRS-callset 和 1KGP-SRS-callset 中按人群划分的每样本结构变异(SV)数量的小提琴图。超级人群包括 AFR(n = 893)、AMR(n = 490)、EAS(n = 585)、EUR(n = 633)和 SAS(n = 601)。b,HitSV 特有和 1KGP 特有 SV 在 40 个 HPRC 和 35 个 HGSVC 样本(生物学独立个体)中样本匹配精度的小提琴图。嵌入的箱线图中,中心线表示中位数,箱体界限表示第 25 和第 75 百分位数,须表示 1.5× IQR 范围内的极端值。未显示离群值。c,人群特有和共享 SV 等位基因分布。共享代表在 1KGP-callset(左)和 HitSV-callset(右)中至少被两个但不是所有超级人群共享的等位基因。d,跨超级人群的 SV 等位基因分布偏移。箭头表明,被 1KGP-callset 视为源自特定超级人群特有(unique)的等位基因,在 HitSV-callset 中被视为在目标超级人群中常见(频率 > 0.05)。圆圈大小与 HitSV-callset 中每个超级人群特有的等位基因数量成正比。箭头宽度及箭头上标注的数字表示在目标超级人群中重新发现为常见的等位基因数量。e,1KGP-callset 中 AFR 特有 SV 的等位基因计数(ACs),与 HitSV-callset 中同一超级人群或另一个超级人群中相同 SV 的 ACs 对比,如各面板所示。第一个面板中的红色虚线显示 1:1 比例。f,1KGP-callset 中 SV(深色)和 HitSV-callset 中明确识别出的 SV(浅色)的功能/基因组区域注释。AFR,非洲;AMR,美洲;EAS,东亚;EUR,欧洲;SAS,南亚。

我们使用各种外部支持对 HitSV 特有 SV 进行了评估。首先,使用基于组装的 HPRC(匹配 n = 40)和 HGSVC(匹配 n = 35)作为独立验证资源,对匹配样本进行了评估。在匹配样本中,平均有 84.90% 和 85.26% 的 HitSV 特有 SV 得到了基于组装的证据证实,分别比 1KGP-SRS 特有 SV 高 26.01% 和 23.95%(图 4b 和补充表 20)。其次,在 callset 层面,与 1KGP-SRS 特有 SV 相比,HitSV 特有 SV 显示出与独立的 1KGP-LRS-callset 有更大的重叠(39,784 对 7,170;扩展数据图 3a 和补充表 21)。在 gnomAD-SV 中也观察到了类似的趋势(60,022 对 40,584)。由于 1KGP-LRS-callset 未能完全恢复 HGSVC 基于组装的 callset,因此该资源中的缺失并非假阳性的决定性证据(扩展数据图 3b 和补充表 22)。按等位基因频率(AF)分层的分析进一步显示,无论是非常罕见的次要等位基因频率(MAF)≤ 0.2%)还是相对常见的类别,HitSV 特有 SV 的外部支持均多于官方的 1KGP-SRS 特有 SV,但未经支持的罕见或单倍型候选者应谨慎解读(补充说明 5 和补充表 23)。

我们研究了 SV 的 AF 分布特征,因为这为群体遗传学研究奠定了基础。与 1KGP-SRS-callset 相比,HitSV-SRS-callset 产生的等位基因计数 (AC) 分布更加平滑且衰减更快,稀有变异和常见变异之间呈现出更清晰的双峰分布(图 4c)。在 1KGP-SRS-callset 中被归类为群体特异性或超稀有的 SV 子集,在 HitSV-SRS-callset 中被重新归类为超级群体间的共享变异(图 4d)。例如,1KGP-SRS-callset 中 0.29% 的非洲特有 SV 在至少另一个超级群体中被观察到为常见变异(AF \(\ge\) 0.05),且有 0.17% 被发现为所有超级群体共享。此外,1.52–2.84% 的群体特异性 SV 的频率显著升高(图 4e 和补充图 4),而 36.6% 的 HitSV 特有 SV 为群体特异性,使每个超级群体的群体特异性 SV 增加了 23.5–36.4%(扩展数据图 3c)。

按基因组背景分层显示,HitSV 获得的最大增益发生在重复区域,特别是串联重复(TRs;图 4f)。虽然短 TR 可以从 SRS 数据中可靠地检测32,62,但 HitSV 发现了多千碱基的 TR 扩增,将 TR 单元变异相对于参考基因组的拷贝数延伸至 > \(\pm\) 500 拷贝,并揭示了群体特有 TR 等位基因的稳定比例(补充图 5)。最后,许多 HitSV 特有 SV 被发现位于编码区和调控区(图 4f)。为了评估其功能相关性,我们使用七个公开开放资源对 HitSV 特有变异进行了注释6,63(补充图 6)。超过 7,300 个 HitSV 特有 SV 被预测会导致功能丧失效应;三个 EUR 和 AFR 特有的 10–40 kb 缺失分别与视网膜营养不良64、痉挛性截瘫和先天性甲状腺功能减退症65有关;并且一个 50 bp 的常见插入被 AnnotSV66 关联到原发性纤毛运动障碍(补充表 24)。

总之,通过恢复现有流程遗漏的 SV 并重塑群体水平的 AF 分布,HitSV 强调了现有短读长资源在群体遗传学和疾病相关研究中的持续价值。

HitSV 解析基因组复杂 SV (CSVs)

CSVs 以聚集的断裂点和多事件结构为特征,是基于比对的对 SV 检测工具面临的重大挑战。为了评估 HitSV 解析此类变异的能力,我们使用经过整理的 HG002 CSV 基准以及两个 GIAB 三人组数据集对其性能进行了评估。

HG002 CSV基准包含NIST-Q100真值集中具有多个SV事件且在500 bp邻近区域内的区域5。在使用LRS数据时,HitSV在CSV检测方面优于其他SV调用工具(图5a,b和补充表25)。值得注意的是,随着CSV复杂度的增加,其优势变得更为明显。在极其复杂的区域(局部重复性,R > 120 和 >6个SV)中,HitSV达到了71.83%的F1-GT,而其他工具则始终低于40%。此外,当通过序列准确性(‘refine’模式,-p 0.95)进行评估时,HitSV实现了69.12–100%的F1,而Sawfish在CSV区域中落后6.8–34.93%(图5c和补充表26)。

图5:HitSV在ONT数据集上解决复杂SV的能力。

a,各种SV调用工具在不同场景和难度下的事件级F1-GT得分。这些区域根据其复杂性(由所包含的SV事件数量表示,分为三档:=2,3–5,≥6)和局部参考序列重复性(由R值表示,分为三档:1–39,40–119,≥120)进一步分类。值得注意的是,HitSV仅在(≥6, 0 R <40)范围内完全恢复了一个CSV,但受到contig重新比对(星号标记;详细说明见补充图24)的阻碍。b,各种场景和难度下的CSV事件计数。c,在95%序列相似性(通过Truvari refine,-p,0.95)下,HitSV与Sawfish在不同场景和难度下SV相关序列的精确度比较。d,HitSV与Sniffles在不同KLD范围之间的比较。KLD通过SV断点和真值的分布计算,用于衡量局部读长对齐的异质性,并用于根据不同KLD范围重新分类HG002 CSV区域。e,在12号染色体(chr12: 132,239,289–132,246,050 bp)GALNT9基因内含子区域的一个CSV检测示例,HitSV在检测变异的基因组分布和长度方面均与真值高度一致。f,CSV和非CSV区域间隙压缩序列身份度的分布。身份度衡量的是诸如错配和插入/缺失等一系列小序列分歧的发生频率,而非整个大事件,这是由读长对齐的评分偏差和侧翼参考序列的相似性引起的。g,在19号染色体(chr19: 15,677,010–15,678,477 bp)包含CYP4F12位点的局部基因组区域的一个CSV检测示例,HitSV在总变异长度方面以近乎完全的一致性准确解析了SV。h,HitSV、Sniffles2和cuteSV2在两个GIAB三人组样本(HG002/HG003/HG004和HG005/HG006/HG007)LRS数据集上的孟德尔一致性。i,一个包含富INS父本和INS–DEL混合母本等位基因的典型GSE1基因示例,HitSV在家系基于分析中准确解析了复杂的SV结构及其传递模式。

为了更好地理解CSV检测中的困难来源,我们定义了以下三个对齐特征:(1) 异质SV特征,通过比对衍生断点分布与真实断点分布之间的累积Kullback–Leibler散度(KLD)来量化断点异质性(方法)。特征异质性的增加导致了HitSV与基于特征聚类的算法(如Sniffles2)之间更大的性能差距(图 5d 和补充表 27),表明HitSV对断点拥挤和信号干扰具有更强的鲁棒性。例如,在GALNT9的内含子中,HitSV正确地定相并解析了聚集的SV信号,而其他方法显示出显著的差异(图 5e 和补充图 7)。(2) 对齐扭曲——CSV区域经常显示降低的gap压缩一致性(图 5f 和补充表 28),其中一致的小核苷酸变异掩盖了单个大事件。在CYP4F12的外显子中,HitSV恢复了具有近乎完整变异长度的完整插入,而其他方法则漏检了这些变异(图 5g 和补充图 8)。(3) 异常局部对齐——CSV位点通常显示低覆盖度或广泛的修剪,缺乏可靠的分裂对齐;然而,HitSV保持了敏感性,并能够从这些有限证据中重构SV。

随后,我们将HitSV应用于两个GIAB三人数据集的LRS数据,以评估其普适性。在两个三人组中,HitSV实现了更高的孟德尔一致性率,表明在家庭背景下准确率有所提高(图 5h 和补充表 29)。其优势在表现为多等位杂合性的CSV中最为显著。在这些情况下,HitSV根据read衍生路径在unitig-dBG中的差异进行聚类,并独立重构等位基因序列,而基于特征聚类的算法通常通过将由信号合并为单一错误的SV表示而失败。一个代表GSE1基因包含富插入父本等位基因和插入-缺失混合母本等位基因的典型案例,如图 5i 和扩展数据图 4 所示。HitSV在HG002中独特重构了这两个等位基因,并一致地重构了亲本单倍型(HG003和HG004),而其他工具主要漏检SV或产生粗糙的合并预测。

综上所述,这些结果表明HitSV将准确的SV检测从简单事件扩展到了高度复杂的重排。更多示例可在扩展数据图 5 和补充图 9–14 中找到。

557名中国个体中CSV的全面图谱

To interrogate the CSV landscape in human populations, we applied HitSV on the large-scale ONT sequencing resource from the China 100K Genomes Project (CHN100K67; Methods), generating a comprehensive callset of CSVs in 557 Chinese individuals. This callset enabled systematic characterization of CSVs across a large and relatively under-represented population.

Across the cohort, HitSV identified 2,990 high-confidence CSV loci (Fig. 6a and Supplementary Table 30). A total of 95.58% CSV loci were associated with genomic TRs, where canonical alignment-based callers fail to resolve (Supplementary Fig. 15). To evaluate the added diversity and generalizability of the identified CSVs, we compared the CHN100K-CSV callset (the AF > 1% subset) with 94 haplotype-resolved contigs from 47 HPRC individuals, after strictly accounting for cohort size and technical differences (Supplementary Note 6 and Supplementary Fig. 16). This conservative comparison revealed that 10.50% compared CHN100K-CSV loci remained unsupported by HPRC (Supplementary Fig. 17).

Fig. 6: Comprehensive analysis of CSVs in 557 Chinese samples.

a, Chromosome-level classification of CSV regions across 557 Chinese samples’ ONT datasets. CSV regions are classified based on the genomic context and composition of detected insertions, distinguishing TR-derived events from non-TR SVs. b, Scatterplots compare the number of clusters derived from ONT data (x axis) with the number of clusters inferred from HPRC data (y axis) for TR with non-TR SVs CSV regions. Each point represents one CSV region. Dashed lines indicate the reference threshold of a single cluster (x = 1 or y = 1). c, The relative length contributions of major TE families within TR-MEI regions and across the whole genome based on the GRCh38 reference background. Bars indicate the proportion of total TE length contributed by each TE family, including LINE/L1, SINE, LTR/ERV1, LTR/ERVL, DNA transposons and Retroposon/SVA elements. d, The distribution of TR-MEI intervals across different genomic annotation categories, including intergenic, intronic, exonic, promoter and enhancer regions. e, An example of haplotype-resolved structural variation at a TR-MEI-associated locus on FAM230G gene of human chromosome 22 (chr22: 20,337,500–20,340,000 bp) associated transcriptional regulation. Top, the genomic context based on RefSeq annotation, highlighting the position of the locus relative to gene structure, including exon, promoter and enhancer elements. TRF annotations are shown below, indicating repeat-enriched regions overlapping the TR-MEI array. Bottom, representative haplotypes stratified by AC across the ONT cohort, with each track corresponding to a distinct MEI copy-number state (2× to 24×). Colored segments denote different repeat classes, including TR, simple repeats, satellite repeats and SINE/Alu elements. Percentages on the left indicate haplotype frequencies in the population, while numbers on the right denote total MEI copy numbers. f, The canonical structure of the AluY mobile element. The red triangle marks the position on the AluY consensus sequence corresponding to the most frequent midpoint (97.3%) observed among repeated AluY copies within TR-MEI regions. g, A Sankey-style diagram summarizing the haplotype-level distribution of SVs within a CSV region on chromosome 2 (chr2:64,375,000–64,377,000 bp) across 557 Chinese samples. A total of 13 variants are observed in this region, including 12 INS and 1 DEL. The top track indicates the genomic positions and lengths of individual variants. The leftmost column represents the AC of each variant across the cohort, while flows illustrate how variants co-occur and segregate across different haplotypes. Gray blocks and flows denote the wild-type state. TE, transposable element; TRF, tandem-repeat finder.

Experimental validation of select CSV loci in six CHN100K samples provided orthogonal support for the CSV calls and the reconstructed SV contigs (Extended Data Fig. 6, Supplementary Fig. 18 and Supplementary Table 31). Based on the CHN100K–HPRC comparison, allele-level enrichment analysis further identified a smaller subset of candidates likely representing population-enriched or population-specific CSVs (Supplementary Note 6). Among shared loci, CHN100K samples also showed broader allele distributions and more extensive structural diversity than HPRC (Fig. 6b, Supplementary Fig. 19 and Supplementary Tables 32 and 33).

TR-rich CSV loci showed remarkable accumulation of mobile-element-associated sequences (54.4%, 1,554/2,857), consistent with previous observations that mobile elements frequently retrotranspose within or near TRs68. However, our analysis further revealed the widespread occurrence of coordinated expansion or contraction of TRs and MEIs, forming TR-MEI composite arrays at 70 loci (Methods; Extended Data Fig. 7a). A total of 94.3% of such arrays were common (AF > 5%) within the cohort, rather than rare or singleton events, suggesting that these structures represent recurrent and multi-allelic forms of human CSV (Extended Data Fig. 7b and Supplementary Table 34).

Accurate resolution of TR-MEI composite arrays requires reconstruction of long, multi-allelic structures. By signal aggregation and graph-based reconstruction, HitSV captured both repeat-length variation and embedded MEI sequences (Supplementary Figs. 20 and 21). Although multiple MEI families were frequently observed (Extended Data Fig. 7c), copy number and length contribution were decoupled. While ERV1-derived and SVA-derived sequences were over-represented relative to genomic background, DNA transposons were depleted (Fig. 6c and Supplementary Table 35). This decoupling underscores the structural heterogeneity of TR-MEI arrays. Although Alu and L1 showed higher copy numbers within TR-MEI arrays, they are typically present as short internal fragments. In contrast, SVA elements, despite being less frequent, contributed disproportionately to array length due to their closer-to-full-length sizes (Extended Data Fig. 7d–f). Given the nonautonomous nature of SVA retrotransposition, their insertions more likely persisted as extended structural segments once captured within TR contexts, rather than being repeatedly fragmented and amplified. Finally, despite their modest copy numbers, TR-MEI composite arrays generate genomic length variations similar to canonical VNTR (Supplementary Fig. 22 and Supplementary Table 36), highlighting their potential contribution to structural polymorphism and phenotypic effects. Supporting this regulatory potential, TR-MEI composite arrays were frequently located in gene or gene-proximal regions (Fig. 6d and Supplementary Table 37). Representative loci illustrate that segments within composite arrays span putative exonic and promoter-associated regions or contain Alu-derived sequences overlapping predicted enhancer elements. At these loci, moderate expansion leads to ~3 copies at high ACs (19.7%), with extreme expansions reaching ~24 copies in rare cases (~0.5%), substantially amplifying regulatory sequence dosage (Fig. 6e,f and Supplementary Fig. 23).

In addition to repeat-associated CSVs, 4.41% CHN100K-CSV loci were not anchored in repetitive contexts. These loci feature compact breakpoint clusters interleaved with successive insertions and deletions within short genomic intervals (~2 kb), forming highly structured multi-allelic configurations (Fig. 6g). Extending recent long-read population studies of long-range complex structural polymorphism at functional loci10,13, these findings capture microscale compound rearrangements, characterized by high allelic diversity and moderate-to-high ACs across the cohort, suggestive of repeated remodeling of the same genomic interval yet of much shorter spans.

Collectively, the CHN100K-based analysis using HitSV provides a population-scale view of CSV at a resolution previously inaccessible. These results reveal TR-MEI composite arrays and microscale compound rearrangements as prevalent and previously underappreciated modes of human genome variation.

Discussion

Comprehensive characterization of SVs has long been a cornerstone of genomic research, yet continues to be constrained by the interplay among read length, the intrinsic complexity of the genome, and sequencing cost. The high sensitivity of HitSV can be primarily attributed to the improved signal aggregation by repetitiveness and signature density-aware site recognition and probabilistic breakpoint clustering. By reconciling weak or conflicting evidence into coherent SV hypotheses, HitSV achieved a 10.47–24.52% improvement over commonly used de novo short-read callers on both human and nonhuman datasets (F1 score/F1-GT score), demonstrating that effective modeling of alignment uncertainty can partially compensate for limited read length.

Accurate SV-allele reconstruction is critical for genotyping and downstream interpretation. HitSV used heuristic dBG path searching, clustering and merging to fully reconstruct allele-specific sequences, and outperformed SOTA long-read callers by 15.34–71.68% in F1-GT scores (HG002 benchmark). Moreover, its refined F1-GT scores reached 96.70% at 95% similarity (-p 0.95), highlighting the capability of near-complete SV reconstruction for an individual genome.

A distinctive strength of HitSV lies in its unified modeling of long-read and short-read data. Low-coverage (2–4×) long-read data ensure contig continuity and haplotype separation, whereas short-read data (30–60×) provide refined alleles and statistical evidence, resulting in a 11.92% F1-GT improvement over blend-seq and equal or higher performance than SOTA long-read callers on deep LRS data, offering a cost-effective alternative for scaling up population studies.

Application to the 1KGP cohort suggested that improved sensitivity also enables meaningful reanalysis of large cohorts, that is, a number of missed SVs can be rediscovered to reshape AF distributions across populations. Notably, variants previously regarded as population specific or ultrarare were frequently reassigned as shared at appreciable frequencies, indicating that earlier technical limitations contributed to biases in population stratification. Although the limitations of SRS remain, these results highlight that methodological advances can extend the value of legacy datasets.

Beyond generic SV discovery, HitSV enables systematic exploration of complex SVs when sufficient long reads are available. Benchmark and trio-based evaluations show improved resolution of clustered, multi-allelic and haplotype-specific rearrangements. Extending to a large Chinese cohort reveals thousands of CSV loci and uncovers structural patterns beyond canonical SV categories, including TR-MEI composite arrays and microscale compound rearrangements. The prevalence, allelic diversity and moderate-to-high population frequencies of these structures suggest that coordinated repeat instability, retrotransposition and localized sequence remodeling represent stable modes of genomic variation rather than rare mutational events.

Several limitations are noteworthy. First, extremely large or highly entangled rearrangements continue to pose challenges for local assembly-based reconstruction, while the ambiguous representation of complex alleles remains a hurdle for downstream annotation. Second, the performance of hybrid sequencing across large-scale, real-world cohorts remains to be established as such datasets emerge. Finally, the recovery of large insertions from SRS data should also be interpreted in a variant-class-specific manner because the truly new sequences remain intrinsically difficult to reconstruct from short reads. LRS or hybrid sequencing is therefore preferable for detecting large non-MEI insertions and complex insertions in highly repetitive regions. Collectively, HitSV expands the observable spectrum of structural variation, providing a valuable foundation for population genomics and the characterization of complex genetic architectures.

Methods

SV site recognition

Local repetitiveness and genome windows

The reference was divided into 600-bp-size windows with 300 bp overlaps. For each window, a measure of local repetitiveness (termed as \(R\)) was defined as:

$$\begin{array}{l}R=f\left(s,\left(l,r\right)\right)=\max \left(K{\rm{\,| \,}}\exists i,j\in \left(l,r\right),i\ne j,{s}_{i}{s}_{i+1}\ldots {s}_{i+K-1}\right.\\\left.\qquad\qquad\quad={s}_{j}{s}_{j+1}\ldots {s}_{j+K-1}\right)\end{array}$$

(1)

where \(\left(l,r\right)\) denotes the window coordinates of the reference \(s\). \(R\) rises with local sequence repetitiveness.

SV signature collection

Multiple kinds of SV-associated signatures were collected in each window, including sequence divergence in alignments (SDAs), CLPs and DRPs (SRS only). HitSV extracts SDA, that is, significant divergences in CIGARs (single long insertions/deletions ≥ min_SV_length or dense small divergences defined as more than n (10 for LRS and 3 for SRS) mismatch/indel events occurring within a 200-bp region) and split alignments, and CLP signatures by traversing the input alignment file. DRP signatures are derived from the abnormal placements of pair-end reads implied by the alignments. All the signatures are represented as a quadruple:

$$\mathrm{Sig}=\left(R,{n}_{\mathrm{SDA}},{n}_{\mathrm{CLP}},{n}_{\mathrm{DRP}}\right)$$

(2)

where \({n}_{\mathrm{SDA}}\), \({n}_{\mathrm{CLP}}\) and \({n}_{\mathrm{DRP}}\) represent the numbers of SDA, CLP and DRP signatures within the window, respectively.

Signature distributions

SV signals manifest heterogeneously across sequencing technologies and genomic contexts, particularly under varying levels of local repetitiveness. Through extensive empirical inspection of long-read and short-read alignments, we observed several recurring yet poorly quantified phenomena—(1) different SV signatures dominate in long-read versus short-read data; (2) the strength of these signatures varies systematically with local repeat complexity and (3) SV-like signals occasionally appear in regions without SV events, especially within highly repetitive sequences. Furthermore, HitSV designs a model to describe the correlation between SV signatures and local repetitiveness, to distinguish true SV-supporting patterns from background noise in a principled manner.

HitSV identifies candidate SV loci using prebuilt signature distributions that quantify local signature intensity across repetitiveness levels. Separate distributions were constructed for long-read and short-read data using sequencing datasets from 40 samples shared in HPRC and 1KGP, respectively. Assembly-based ground-truth SV callsets from HPRC were used to label SV windows. Two-dimensional (repetitiveness/signature intensity) empirical distributions were then constructed for SV windows, alongside matched background distributions from non-SV windows (Extended Data Fig. 1). Also refer to Supplementary Note 1 for more detailed characterizations and discussions on the signature distributions.

SV candidate site recognition

Guided by the signature distributions, HitSV adopts a rule-based model to identify candidate SV windows. For long-read data, SV signals are dominated by SDAs and CLPs. A genome window is therefore classified as an SV candidate site if more than \({T}_{\mathrm{LR}}\) reads within it show either indels longer than 30 bp or clipped segments exceeding 300 bp. For short-read data, where SDAs, CLPs and DRPs jointly contribute and signal attenuation is prominent in repetitive regions, a window is recognized as candidate if any of the following conditions is satisfied: (1) \(R\) is higher than 40; (2) the number of SDA reads is higher than \(\mathrm{MAX}\left({T}_{\mathrm{SDA}},2\right)\); (3) the number of CLP reads is higher than \(\mathrm{MAX}\left({T}_{\mathrm{CLP}},2\right)\); and (4) the number of DRP reads is higher than \(\mathrm{MAX}\left({T}_{\mathrm{DRP}},2\right)\). Here the default values of \({T}_{\mathrm{LR}}\), \({T}_{\mathrm{SDA}}\), \({T}_{\mathrm{CLP}}\) and \({T}_{\mathrm{DRP}}\) are set to 10% local read depth, ensuring robustness across variable coverage while suppressing spurious signals from individual outlier reads. Using these distribution-informed rules, HitSV recovered 98.1% (LRS) and 89.2% (SRS) of HG002 SV sites (19,234 in total), demonstrating effective recall of true SV loci for downstream refinement. Moreover, it also shows generalizability by comparing the SV calls of the distribution-modeling samples with those of other 1KGP samples (Supplementary Note 7).

SV signature clustering

It is difficult to comprehensively collect all SV-associated windows and obtain a purified read set for downstream assembly, which arises because SVs may span multiple windows owing to multiple breakpoints or dispersed repeats, and signals from distinct SV events may become entangled due to heterozygosity or complex rearrangements. HitSV uses a progressive approach with two phases for refined SV signature clustering and candidate event inference.

Phase 1

HitSV infers SV breakpoints by modeling them as latent variables and constructing probability distributions from SV signatures, enabling the removal of unlikely signals and yielding purified clusters (Supplementary Fig. 1a). For SDA clustering, individual signals are assigned inferred breakpoint probability distributions—dense small-variant signals are uniformly distributed across their affected intervals, while isolated large signals are uniformly distributed within predefined length windows (default = 600 bp) centered on their indicated start and end positions. These signal distributions are then aggregated to identify a global probability peak, which defines the final inferred breakpoint. Subsequently, HitSV filters signatures by assessing whether their centroids are sufficiently close to this inferred breakpoint to ensure clustering accuracy. For CLP clustering, individual signals are assigned a uniform breakpoint probability distribution centered around their clipping bases. For DRP clustering, the breakpoint probability distribution of each signal is calculated by integrating the precomputed insert-size distribution with the orientation and distance of the corresponding paired read-ends. For CLP and DRP clusters, the final inferred breakpoint is obtained through a process similar to that of SDA clustering.

Phase 2

HitSV scans and links all the clusters by nearby regions or large signals (SDA/DRP) through a greedy approach (Supplementary Fig. 1b), enabling comprehensive window collection. This strategy handles SVs with multiple or ambiguous breakpoints and integrates windows affected by the same event. For example, inversions—typically involving two breakpoints and four windows—are grouped in a single step (Fig. 1c). This benefit is especially pronounced for dispersed repeats like MEIs (Supplementary Fig. 1). In such cases, reads align ambiguously and are hard to collect; however, proximal or linked candidate windows allow the greedy strategy to aggregate them transitively.

Haplotype-resolved local assembly for high-fidelity SV reconstruction

Read collection for local assembly

After clustering all signals of the same SV, HitSV rescans the event-affected region—extended upstream and downstream by a fixed length (default = 500 bp)—to collect all the reads, regardless of whether they contain SV signatures or not, enabling optimal local assembly.

Unitig-dBG construction

HitSV builds a unitig-dBG69 based on k-mers from the collected reads and local reference. Each unitig records average read coverage and is classified as high depth or low depth using a threshold depending on pre-estimated sequencing depth (default ≥20% of expected depth, minimum 2). Each unitig is labeled as cyclic or acyclic after detecting cycles in the unitig-dBG. Acyclic unitigs shared with the reference are treated as anchors. Finally, all reads are decomposed into paths through the unitig-dBG for subsequent read-to-path realignment.

SRS-based SV calling

HitSV constructs candidate SV alleles through graph walking under coverage constraints (Supplementary Fig. 2).

Exhaustive (‘blind’) contig generation

The upstream and downstream anchor nodes closest to the SV are selected as the source and sink. HitSV performs depth-first search on high-depth nodes in the dBG, assigning each node a maximum visit count (default = 9). A path is accepted only if it connects source to sink and the visit counts of all traversed nodes remain below the threshold. This operation enables exhaustive contig enumeration at affordable cost through implicit coverage control.

Contig filtering

HitSV realigns all reads to the generated contigs and rejects contigs without sufficient supporting reads.

Haplotype pairing and allele inference

Remaining contigs are treated as candidate haplotypes, and, assuming diploidy, all \({n}_{\mathrm{HAP}}\times \left({n}_{\mathrm{HAP}}+1\right)/2\) haplotype pairs are evaluated. For each pair \(\left({H}_{1},|,{H}_{2}\right)\), HitSV computes a likelihood:

$${\rm{L}}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)=-\frac{\left(2X\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)+{\rm{Y}}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\right)}{{D}_{R}}$$

(3)

where \({D}_{R}\) is pre-estimated depth, \(X\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\) is the number of unmapped reads and \(Y\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\) represents the concordance between read and haplotype k-mer counts:

$$\begin{array}{l}{\rm{Y}}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)=\sum _{k\hbox{-}\mathrm{mer}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)}\left|R\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right),{RS}\right)-\overline{R}\left(\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right),{RS}\right)\right|,\\\qquad\qquad\qquad\forall k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i}\in k\hbox{-}\mathrm{mer}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\end{array}$$

(4)

$$R\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right),{RS}\right)=\frac{\mathrm{Count}\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\right)}{\mathrm{Count}\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},{RS}\right)}$$

(5)

where \(k\hbox{-}\mathrm{mer}\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\) indicates the k-mer set of \(\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\), \({RS}\) indicates the read set and \(\mathrm{Count}\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\right)\) and \(\mathrm{Count}\left(k\hbox{-}{\mathrm{mer}}_{i},{RS}\right)\) indicate the counts of a specific k-mer (\({kme}{r}_{i}\)) on \(\left({H}_{1},{H}_{2}\right)\) and \({RS}\), respectively. The haplotype pair having highest likelihood is selected and re-aligned to reference using KSW2 to infer SVs.

LRS-based SV detection

Each long read is represented as a path through the constructed unitig-dBG. HitSV selects the read traversing highest number of high-depth nodes as initial path, and iteratively assigns remaining reads to existing paths or builds new ones.

SDP-based read realignment

For each read, its unitig-dBG path is aligned against those of all current paths by SDP. A read supports a contig if no structural discrepancy is detected, defined as follows: if, at any SDP-anchored node (that is, flanked by SDP-matched nodes), either the gap length in two adjacent match nodes is more than 20 bp, or both allele nodes are high depth but differ in sequence.

Path updating

Reads aligned successfully refine the corresponding path by replacing low-depth nodes at SDP-anchored positions with read-derived high-depth nodes, whereas reads being rejected by all existing contigs initiate new paths. After all reads are processed, each path is converted into a contig.

Hybrid-based SV calling and polishing

When both short-read and long-read data are available, HitSV generates candidate contigs using unitig-dBG built from long and short reads, respectively. If long-read-based contigs exist, HitSV prioritizes them as backbones and uses high-accuracy short reads to improve the base-level accuracy of backbones. In detail, (1) HitSV builds an empirical 9-mer error profile by calculating the accuracy probability of all genomic 9-mers from alignments of HG002-ONT data (using the in-house script error_profile_analysis.py), using only primary alignments, and all the k-mers harboring known variants from GIAB (v4.2.1) were filtered out. (2) HitSV first identifies the positions of all low-fidelity 9-mers (error rate > 0.2) based on sequencing error profiles and homopolymer contexts in the backbone sequence, and then extracts all short reads overlapping these positions to construct multiple local consensus sequences. A representative consensus is selected based on majority short-read support. Homopolymer lengths and 9-mer sequences are subsequently corrected by comparing the selected consensus with the backbone sequence, thereby refining local sequence accuracy for downstream analysis.

Then, HitSV reassigns all short reads to polished contigs to augment support estimation by realignment. When long-read contigs are unavailable, short-read-based contigs are used as the final assemblies, and long reads are subsequently incorporated to refine genotype accuracy see ‘SV genotyping and quality control’.

SV genotyping and quality control

HitSV genotypes SVs with a probabilistic model, in which the probability is computed through an \(M\times N\) support matrix derived from read evidence, where \(M\) is the number of reads and \(N\) is the number of contigs (2 for a diploid assumption). Each element represents the probability of observing a specific read given a particular contig. For short-read data, each read is aligned to both contigs in the candidate pair, and the resulting alignment scores are transformed to construct a likelihood-based support matrix using an exponential function. For long-read data, a binary support matrix is generated by determining whether each read supports a given contig in the pair (1 indicating support and 0 indicating no support). The support matrix is used to estimate the probability for each genotype of the contig pair, and all SVs called from the contig pair are genotyped with the highest probability correspondingly. A Phred-scaled quality score is computed from the probability. Homozygous-reference calls are discarded, variants having quality lower than a predefined threshold (default = 10) are labeled LOW, and the remaining calls are marked PASS. See Supplementary Note 8 for more details.

Complex structural variation

Definition of CSV

CSVs are defined as groups of SVs that occur on the same haplotype and whose breakpoint positions lie within 500 bp of each other. Under this definition, any pair of SVs with breakpoint proximity <500 bp is merged into a larger CSV event.

HG002 CSVs benchmark

All variants in the NIST HG002 Q100 (v1.1) truth set were first partitioned into two haplotype-specific SV sets based on their genotypes. Within each set, SVs were clustered using a maximum breakpoint distance of 500 bp and a minimum SV length of 50 bp, yielding breakpoint groups corresponding to candidate CSVs. To ensure robust downstream evaluation, each breakpoint was padded by ±500 bp to account for potential uncertainty in the reported variant boundaries, and all resulting intervals were stored in BED format. These preliminary CSV intervals were then sorted and merged using bedtools, and intersected with the high-confidence benchmark regions (GRCh38_HG2-T2TQ100-V1.1_stvar.benchmark.bed) to retain only regions suitable for reliable assessment.

In total, 2,274 nonoverlapping CSV intervals were obtained for HG002, spanning approximately 3.77 Mb. Each CSV interval was classified along two dimensions, yielding nine mutually exclusive categories for evaluating the ability for CSV identification—(1) CSV complexity, defined by the number of constituent haplotype-resolved SVs (1–2, 3–6 or >6 events), and (2) local repeat complexity, measured by the local repetitiveness, \(R\) (\(R\) < 40, 40 ≤ \(R\) < 119 or \(R\) ≥ 120).

KLD

For the HG002 sample, we computed the KLD within each CSV interval to quantify the discrepancy between the observed read-alignment pattern and the expected genotype-derived breakpoint distribution. KLD was calculated in a sliding-window manner using 10 bp windows across each CSV region. For a given window, the local KLD is defined as \(p\times \mathrm{log}\left(\frac{p}{{p}_{a}}\right)+q\times \mathrm{log}\left(\frac{q}{{q}_{a}}\right)\), where \(p\) denotes the fraction of reads in the window that support the true breakpoint, and \(q\) = 1 − \(P\). The expected probabilities \({p}_{a}\) and \({q}_{a}\) are determined from the ground-truth genotype—(1) homozygous SV, \({p}_{a}=1\), \({q}_{a}=0\); (2) heterozygous SV, \({p}_{a}=0.5\), \({q}_{a}=0.5\); and (3) homozygous reference, \({p}_{a}=0\), \({q}_{a}=1\). To avoid zero terms, a smoothing constant of 0.01 was added to \(p\), \(q\), \({p}_{a}\), \({q}_{a}\) computation. The regional KLD was obtained by summing the local KLD values across all windows in the CSV interval.

Panel of CSVs in population

Population-level CSV interval from 557 ONT samples

HitSV was applied to 557 ONT samples to generate per-sample VCFs, retaining variants supported by at least two reads. For each sample, adjacent SVs with breakpoint distance <500 bp were grouped as CSVs, and the reference was partitioned into nonoverlapping 500 bp windows to record sample-specific CSV intervals and allele counts (Supplementary Note 6). Population-level ACs were computed across samples, and windows with AF ≥ 0.1% were retained. Finally, 7,939 population CSV intervals were retained by merging adjacent intervals and excluding telomeric and centromeric regions, of which 2,857 had an AC of at least 5% (refer to https://github.com/hitbc/HitSV/blob/main/cohort_csv_analysis.md).

CSV-region contigs generation and annotation

For each sample, local contigs within CSV intervals were assembled directly from BAM files. Contigs supported by at least two reads were retained. For comparison, haplotype-resolved contigs from the 47 HPRC samples (94 haplotypes) were obtained using the same approach. All contigs and corresponding reference sequences were annotated using RepeatMasker (default parameters) and tandem-repeat finder (trf input.fa 2 7 7 80 10 10 500 -h -d -ngs 1). Based on the RepeatMasker annotations, MEI categories (‘SINE’, ‘LINE’, ‘Retroposon’, ‘DNA’, ‘RC’ or ‘LTR’) were parsed for each contig (Supplementary Note 6).

MEI-array identification and annotation

For each contig, elements belonging to the dominant MEI type were sorted by genomic order, and DBSCAN clustering was performed based on MEI length and the distances across adjacent MEIs. A contig was classified as containing an MEI array if it met all the following criteria: (1) ≥3 MEI elements in the dominant cluster; (2) the s.d. of element lengths ≤20% of their mean; and (3) the s.d. of the distances ≤20% mean or ≤ 15 bp. If a CSV interval contains at least one MEI-array contig, the interval is defined as an MEI-array interval. Using this criterion, we identified a total of 89 CSV intervals containing MEI arrays. These CSV intervals were annotated with GENCODE (v44), and regulatory elements were annotated using the Ensembl regulatory feature database (GRCh38; v115; Supplementary Note 6).

Contig clustering within CSV intervals

Each CSV interval was stratified into TR-enriched and non-TR subregions based on reference sequence annotations. After splitting, the subregions of the 2,857 population CSV intervals collectively contained 4,807 CSV loci. Tandem-repeat finder-annotated repeats and RepeatMasker categories ‘simple_repeat’ and ‘satellite’ were considered as TR enriched, whereas all other annotated segments (including MEIs) were treated as non-TR. Contigs and the corresponding reference sequences were partitioned along these boundaries to generate region-specific contig sets. Within each contig set, all contigs were compared pairwisely using KSW2 (ksw_extd2_sse function) to identify structural differences ≥50 bp.

Variants were classified as TR derived (insertions attributable to TR expansion within TR-enriched regions) or non-TR (insertions involving non-TR sequence or occurring outside TR regions). Two contigs were assigned to the same cluster if no structural differences were detected or if differences were limited to TR-derived events; otherwise, they were assigned to distinct clusters. For each CSV interval, the cluster number was defined as the total number of distinct contig clusters observed.

Classification of CSV interval

Based on the aggregated variant profiles above, each subregion was assigned to one of the following categories: (1) no SV—no structural differences detected among contigs; (2) pure TR—all differences attributable solely to TR-derived insertions; (3) TR with non-TR SVs—non-TR insertions detected within TR-enriched subregions; (4) non-TR with TR SVs—TR-type insertions detected within non-TR subregions; (5) pure non-TR—only non-TR insertions present within non-TR subregions; and (6) non-TR with both types—both TR and non-TR insertions observed within non-TR subregions. These classifications were used to quantify the structural complexity of contigs within each CSV interval.

CHN100K–HPRC comparison workflow and analysis

The analytical workflow built for the SV comparison in CHN100K and HPRC callsets, including SV region filtration, downsampling analysis of SV regions and recognition of CHN100K-specific SV regions, is detailed in Supplementary Note 6.

CSV selection and experimental validation

Candidate CSV alleles for experimental validation were selected from the CHN100K population CSV callset. Candidate loci were required to be detected by HitSV in ≥1 of six CHN100K individuals whose genomic DNA samples are available, and prioritized if they were CHN100K specific, showed genotype differences between CHN100K and HPRC, or the HitSV-assembled contigs showed intersample length or sequence differences discriminable by PCR amplicon size or Sanger alignment.

Experimental feasibility assessment

Candidate loci were required to contain nonrepetitive flanking sequences on both sides of the target interval, to have an expected amplicon length compatible with PCR amplification, and to avoid extreme GC content, highly repetitive internal sequence and long homopolymer tracts. Homozygous variant loci were preferentially selected to improve target-contig amplification specificity.

Qualified loci were then validated by PCR amplification of the target intervals. PRC primers were designed for each contig using Primer3Web (v4.1.1) and are listed in Supplementary Table 38. Sample DNA was amplified using LongAmp Taq 2× Master Mix (M0287S, NEB) and the products were subjected to 1% agarose gel electrophoresis. Products were purified from the predicted bands by TIANgel Purification Kit (DP219, TIANGEN) and Sanger sequenced at Sangon Biotech. Sanger reads were aligned to the HitSV-inferred contigs and the corresponding reference sequence to confirm the amplified locus and the local CSV allele structure where technically possible.

Benchmarking methodology

Datasets and downsampling

The datasets of human and nonhuman genomes were obtained from previous studies (Supplementary Table 1). All reads were pre-aligned to the corresponding references using minimap2 (ONT), pbmm2 (PacBio) or BWA-MEM (short reads), and converted to sorted BAM files using SAMtools (Supplementary Table 2). For downsampling benchmark, the long-read datasets were downsampled to 1–10×, 15×, 20× and 25×, and the 60× short-read dataset to 15× and 30× using SAMtools.

Multispecies assembly-based benchmark sets

Recently published telomere-to-telomere (T2T) assemblies of M. fascicularis, M. musculus, D. melanogaster, D. rerio, A. thaliana and G. max, and their corresponding official reference genomes, were collected from public resources (Supplementary Table 1). For each species, we generated an assembly-based SV benchmark following the general strategy used by DeFrABB (https://github.com/usnistgov/defrabb) and the GIAB HG002 NIST-Q100 benchmark. In detail, each T2T assembly was aligned to the corresponding reference genome using minimap2, and Dipcall was used to generate SV calls and callable regions. Because only primary assembly sequences were available for the nonhuman T2T assemblies, Dipcall was run by converting such assemblies to two identical haplotypes as inputs (for example, ‘run-dipcall prefix reference.fa hap1.fa hap1.fa > prefix.mak & & make -f prefix.mak’, according to the suggestion of the pipeline). The resulting Dipcall SV VCFs and high-confidence BED files were used as the benchmark callsets and callable regions, respectively. To account for the larger divergences between species-specific assemblies and their reference genomes, minimap2 assembly-alignment presets -x ‘asm10’ or -x ‘asm20’ were evaluated when generating benchmark callsets. These presets produced benchmark sets of different sizes and stringencies, as summarized in Supplementary Table 39. The comparisons under the different ASM presets are shown in Fig. 2 and Supplementary Table 6.

HG002, HPRC and HGSVC ground truth

For HG002, the NIST-Q100 (v1.1) callset (Supplementary Table 1) from the GIAB Consortium was used as ground truth. For each of HPRC samples, the official callset composed by a DipCall-based pipeline was used as the ground truth (Supplementary Table 1). For each of the HGSVC samples, the ground truth was composed by following the same approach as for the species genomes, while the ‘-x asm5’ parameter was applied for genome alignment.

Generation pan-reference-covered SVs and HG002-specific SVs

We first collected the HPRC pangenome resources (VCF format; Supplementary Table 1) generated by the Minigraph-Cactus pipeline, and selected only insertions and deletions with a length ≥40 bp. For each selected SV, the genomic region was extended by 1,000 bp upstream and downstream to generate a raw BED file. Overlapping or adjacent intervals were then merged using bedtools ‘merge’. HG002 NIST-Q100 truth-set SVs overlapping these intervals were classified as pan-reference-covered SVs, whereas others were classified as pan-reference-uncovered, or HG002-specific, SVs. This classification was used only for stratified comparison with PanGenie, VG and DRAGEN, and not during HitSV calling.

Benchmarking configuration

For all tools, ten threads were used whenever multithreading was applicable, and default parameters were applied unless otherwise specified. On downsampled ONT and PacBio datasets, HitSV was compared with SVision-pro, Sawfish, Sniffles2, cuteSV2 and SVDSS2. cuteSV2 was run with the ‘--genotype’ option and SVision-pro with ‘--detect_mode germline’. On downsampled Illumina datasets, HitSV, Manta, DELLY and LUMPY were evaluated at 15×, 30× and 60× coverage. To match previous DRAGEN benchmarks, HitSV was additionally run on the 35× dataset used in that study. Hybrid datasets only for HitSV are generated by combining 1–10× long reads (ONT and PacBio) with 30× or 60× short reads, respectively. The metrics of blend-seq under 4× long reads (ONT and PacBio) and 30× short reads56 were used directly for comparison. For the HG002 pangenome-informed comparison, PanGenie and VG were evaluated using the HPRC-based pangenome resources described above, and DRAGEN (v4.4) was evaluated according to its recommended short-read SV calling workflow.

Performance evaluation

For benchmarking HG002, HGSVC and HPRC samples, F1 score, sensitivity, precision and genotype concordance (GT-F1 was calculated as the product of F1 score and genotype concordance) were computed with Truvari in ‘single’ mode, considering only PASS variants, treating duplications as insertions (--dup-to-ins), and setting --sizemax to 50,000. In nonrefined mode, pctseq (-p) was set to 0 and pctsize (-P) to 0.7, 0.9 or 1.0 for benchmarking; in Truvari’s refined mode, pctseq was set to 0.7, 0.9 or 1.0 to assess the accuracy of SV-allele reconstruction. For diploid human benchmarks, F1-GT was reported when genotype information was available. For assembly-derived nonhuman species benchmarks where genotype comparison was not applicable, F1 score was reported. HG002 evaluations were restricted to the NIST high-confidence regions, whereas HGSVC, HPRC and multispecies evaluations were restricted to the corresponding callable regions of their assembly-based benchmark sets. Furthermore, for HG002, all SVs in those regions are classified by SV type (insertions and deletions), SV size and repeat context using RepeatMasker and Challenging Medical Relevant Genes annotations. For short reads, HARD and EASY regions from GIAB were also evaluated60. For the multi‑species benchmark, Truvari’s ‘multi’ mode was used, and evaluations were restricted to the high‑confidence regions generated by the Dipcall pipeline. Before benchmarking, all VCF files were sorted, compressed and indexed using BCFtools.

Mendelian consistency evaluation

Mendelian consistency was assessed in two trios (HG002/HG003/HG004 and HG005/HG006/HG007; Supplementary Table 29) using ONT data. HitSV, Sniffles2 and cuteSV2 were evaluated. For each tool, trio callsets in a family were merged with SURVIVOR (parameters = 10 1 1 1 0 50), ignoring BND events and converting missing genotypes to homozygous reference. After sorting and indexing the resulting VCF files, Mendelian inheritance was examined using the BCFtools mendelian2 plugin.

1000 Genomes phase 4 dataset reanalysis

We ran HitSV on a computing cluster to call SVs for the 3,202 samples (Supplementary Table 1) to obtain individual VCF files. These VCFs were merged using SURVIVOR (parameters = 500 1 1 1 0 50), retaining only non-BND PASS variants. SV quality scores were re-estimated by summing across supporting samples, and variants below a size threshold (<50 bp) were removed. For each SV, AC and AF were computed using BCFtools and annotated with AnnotSV. The merged VCF was compared with the official 1000 Genomes high-coverage release using Truvari to identify new SVs.

External evaluation of HitSV-specific SVs in the 1KGP cohort

Four external high-quality SV resources, that is, HPRC (assembly-based callset for 40 samples), HGSVC (assembly-based callset for 35 samples), the official 1KGP-callset from LRS data (1KGP-LRS-callset, long-read-alignment-based callset for 975 samples) and gnomAD-SV (short-read-alignment-based callset for 63,046 samples), were used for implementing a two-level comparison to evaluate the SV specifically discovered by HitSV from 1KGP-SRS data. At the matched-sample level, we separately extracted the HitSV-specific SVs from the individual callsets of the 75 1KGP samples shared with HPRC/HGSVC. For each sample, we then directly compared the HitSV-specific SVs to the corresponding assembly-based callset to assess precision. The same processing was done for the official SRS callset of 1KGP as well.

At the population level, the four population callsets, that is, HitSV-SRS-callset, 1KGP-SRS-callset, 1KGP-LRS-callset and gnomAD-SV callset, were merged by SURVIVOR (parameters = 500 1 1 0 0 50) first. A Venn diagram was then plotted based on the merging results to compute the numbers and proportions of HitSV-specific SVs as well as 1GKP-specific SVs overlapping 1KGP-LRS-callset and gnomAD-SV. To assess the external support of SVs in various frequencies, SVs in the complete HitSV-SRS-callset and 1KGP-SRS-callset were first stratified into rare and common subsets according to their recorded MAF values, with rare SVs defined as MAF ≤ 0.2%, and common SVs defined as MAF > 0.2%. This stratification was performed before sample extraction to ensure that the frequency categories reflected the full SRS callsets. For each frequency-specific subset, SVs carried out by the 975 samples shared with the 1KGP-LRS-callset were then extracted, generating sample-matched rare and common SV callsets for both HitSV-SRS and 1KGP-SRS. The SV subsets belonging to the same MAF range were then compared with 1KGP-LRS-callset by SURVIVOR (parameters = 500 1 1 0 0 50) similarly. The same processing was also done with the 75 HPRC/HGSVC samples.

Command lines and detailed parameter settings are provided in the Supplementary Note 3.

Reporting summary

Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.

Data availability

All datasets used in this study are listed in Supplementary Table 1. The versions and downloaded URLs of all tools used are provided in Supplementary Table 2. Ten randomly selected individual VCF files across samples, together with the population VCF generated by re-analyzing the 1KGP4 (ref. 6) high-coverage cohort (3,202 samples) using HitSV, as well as HitSV callsets produced from the HG002-ONT (30×), PacBio (30×), Illumina (60× and 35×) and hybrid datasets (4× ONT/PacBio plus 30× Illumina), and the results obtained for HG002/HG003/HG004/HG005/HG006/HG007 and the multispecies variant calling results (including M. fascicularis47, M. musculus48, D. melanogaster49, D. rerio50, A. thaliana51 and G. max52) are publicly available at https://github.com/hitbc/HitSV_call_results and permanently archived on Zenodo (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22106614)70. The CHN100K cohort data can be accessed upon request through the CHN100K project67 (https://ngdc.cncb.ac.cn/gsa-human/browse/HRA010869), with consent from the data submitter or the corresponding author of the associated study. Source data are provided with this paper.

Code availability

The HitSV program is implemented in C++, and its source code (v2.0.4), auxiliary scripts and precomputed resources for commonly used genomes and datasets (such as local sequence repetitiveness file for GRCh38 and 9-mer error profile files derived from ONT datasets) used to generate all results in this study are available on GitHub (https://github.com/hitbc/HitSV) under the GNU General Public License (v3.0). The version used to generate the results reported in this study is permanently archived on Zenodo (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22230307)71.

References

  1. Middlebrooks, C. D. et al. Association of germline variants in the APOBEC3 region with cancer risk and enrichment with APOBEC-signature mutations in tumors. Nat. Genet. 48, 1330–1338 (2016).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  2. Hardwick, R. J. et al. Haptoglobin (HP) and haptoglobin-related protein (HPR) copy number variation, natural selection, and trypanosomiasis. Hum. Genet. 133, 69–83 (2014).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  3. Collins, R. L. et al. A structural variation reference for medical and population genetics. Nature 581, 444–451 (2020).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  4. Sudmant, P. H. et al. Global diversity, population stratification, and selection of human copy-number variation. Science 349, aab3761 (2015).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  5. Sudmant, P. H. et al. An integrated map of structural variation in 2,504 human genomes. Nature 526, 75–81 (2015).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  6. Byrska-Bishop, M. et al. High-coverage whole-genome sequencing of the expanded 1000 Genomes Project cohort including 602 trios. Cell 185, 3426–3440 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  7. Weischenfeldt, J., Symmons, O., Spitz, F. & Korbel, J. O. Phenotypic impact of genomic structural variation: insights from and for human disease. Nat. Rev. Genet. 14, 125–138 (2013).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  8. Chiang, C. et al. The impact of structural variation on human gene expression. Nat. Genet. 49, 692–699 (2017).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  9. Li, Y. et al. Pan-cancer proteogenomics connects oncogenic drivers to functional states. Cell 186, 3921–3944 (2023).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  10. Schloissnig, S. et al. Structural variation in 1,019 diverse humans based on long-read sequencing. Nature 644, 442–452 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  11. Ho, S. S., Urban, A. E. & Mills, R. E. Structural variation in the sequencing era. Nat. Rev. Genet. 21, 171–189 (2020).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  12. Kosugi, S. & Terao, C. Comparative evaluation of SNVs, indels, and structural variations detected with short- and long-read sequencing data. Hum. Genome Var. 11, 18 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  13. Logsdon, G. A. et al. Complex genetic variation in nearly complete human genomes. Nature 644, 430–441 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  14. Rausch, T., Marschall, T. & Korbel, J. O. The impact of long-read sequencing on human population-scale genomics. Genome Res. 35, 593–598 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  15. Chen, X. et al. Manta: rapid detection of structural variants and indels for germline and cancer sequencing applications. Bioinformatics 32, 1220–1222 (2016).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  16. Layer, R. M., Chiang, C., Quinlan, A. R. & Hall, I. M. LUMPY: a probabilistic framework for structural variant discovery. Genome Biol. 15, R84 (2014).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  17. Rausch, T. et al. DELLY: structural variant discovery by integrated paired-end and split-read analysis. Bioinformatics 28, i333–i339 (2012).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  18. Ye, K., Schulz, M. H., Long, Q., Apweiler, R. & Ning, Z. Pindel: a pattern growth approach to detect break points of large deletions and medium sized insertions from paired-end short reads. Bioinformatics 25, 2865–2871 (2009).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  19. Fan, X., Abbott, T.E., Larson, D. & Chen, K. Breakdancer: identification of genomic structural variation from paired-end read mapping. Curr. Protoc. Bioinform. 45, 15.6.1–15.6.11 (2014).

    Article  Google Scholar 

  20. Sedlazeck, F. J. et al. Accurate detection of complex structural variations using single-molecule sequencing. Nat. Methods 15, 461–468 (2018).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  21. Heller, D. & Vingron, M. SVIM: structural variant identification using mapped long reads. Bioinformatics 35, 2907–2915 (2019).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  22. Jiang, T. et al. Long-read-based human genomic structural variation detection with cuteSV. Genome Biol. 21, 189 (2020).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  23. Chen, Y. et al. Deciphering the exact breakpoints of structural variations using long sequencing reads with DeBreak. Na. Commun. 14, 283 (2023).

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  24. Denti, L., Khorsand, P., Bonizzoni, P., Hormozdiari, F. & Chikhi, R. SVDSS: structural variation discovery in hard-to-call genomic regions using sample-specific strings from accurate long reads. Nat. Methods 20, 550–558 (2023).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  25. Lin, J. et al. SVision: a deep learning approach to resolve complex structural variants. Nat. Methods 19, 1230–1233 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  26. Quenez, O. et al. Detection of copy-number variations from NGS data using read depth information: a diagnostic performance evaluation. Eur. J. Hum. Genet. 29, 99–109 (2021).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  27. Helal, A. A., Saad, B. T., Saad, M. T., Mosaad, G. S. & Aboshanab, K. M. Benchmarking long-read aligners and SV callers for structural variation detection in Oxford Nanopore sequencing data. Sci. Rep. 14, 6160 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  28. Ahsan, M. U., Liu, Q., Perdomo, J. E., Fang, L. & Wang, K. A survey of algorithms for the detection of genomic structural variants from long-read sequencing data. Nat. Methods 20, 1143–1158 (2023).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  29. Wu, D. et al. Large-scale whole-genome sequencing of three diverse Asian populations in Singapore. Cell 179, 736–749 (2019).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  30. Walter, K. et al. The UK10K project identifies rare variants in health and disease. Nature 526, 82–90 (2015).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  31. Gudbjartsson, D. F. et al. Large-scale whole-genome sequencing of the Icelandic population. Nat. Genet. 47, 435–444 (2015).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  32. Zhang, S. et al. Genome-wide investigation of VNTR motif polymorphisms in 8,222 genomes: implications for biological regulation and human traits. Cell Genom. 4, 100699 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  33. Kidd, J. M. Mobile element insertions affect human pigmentation and skin cancer risk. Nat. Genet. 56, 1546–1547 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  34. Tanudisastro, H. A., Deveson, I. W., Dashnow, H. & MacArthur, D. G. Sequencing and characterizing short tandem repeats in the human genome. Nat. Rev. Genet. 25, 460–475 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  35. Behera, S. et al. Comprehensive genome analysis and variant detection at scale using DRAGEN. Nat. Biotechnol. 43, 1177–1191 (2024).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  36. Larson, D. E. et al. svtools: population-scale analysis of structural variation. Bioinformatics 35, 4782–4787 (2019).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  37. Li, H. et al. A synthetic-diploid benchmark for accurate variant-calling evaluation. Nat. Methods 15, 595–597 (2018).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  38. Heller, D. & Vingron, M. SVIM-asm: structural variant detection from haploid and diploid genome assemblies. Bioinformatics 36, 5519–5521 (2020).

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  39. Nurk, S. et al. The complete sequence of a human genome. Science 376, 44–53 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  40. Bilgrav Saether, K. et al. Leveraging the T2T assembly to resolve rare and pathogenic inversions in reference genome gaps. Genome Res. 34, 1785–1797 (2024).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  41. Garg, V. et al. Unlocking plant genetics with telomere-to-telomere genome assemblies. Nat. Genet. 56, 1788–1799 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  42. Phillippy, A. M., Schatz, M. C. & Pop, M. Genome assembly forensics: finding the elusive mis-assembly. Genome Biol. 9, R55 (2008).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  43. Rahman, A. & Medvedev, P. Assembler artifacts include misassembly because of unsafe unitigs and underassembly because of bidirected graphs. Genome Res. 32, 1746–1753 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  44. Lai, S. et al. metaMIC: reference-free misassembly identification and correction of de novo metagenomic assemblies. Genome Biol. 23, 242 (2022).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  45. Chen, Y., Zhang, Y., Wang, A. Y., Gao, M. & Chong, Z. Accurate long-read de novo assembly evaluation with Inspector. Genome Biol. 22, 312 (2021).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  46. Liao, W. W. et al. A draft human pangenome reference. Nature 617, 312–324 (2023).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  47. Zhang, S. et al. Integrated analysis of the complete sequence of a macaque genome. Nature 640, 714–721 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  48. Liu, J. et al. The complete telomere-to-telomere sequence of a mouse genome. Science 386, 1141–1146 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  49. Liu, Y.-N., Gao, J.-J., Zhuang, X.-L., Wu, D.-D. & Sun, Y.-B. Near complete assembly of Drosophila melanogaster Canton S strain genome. Nat. Commun. 17, 329 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  50. Okendo, J. et al. Complete de novo assembly and re-annotation of the zebrafish genome. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.11.17.688901 (2025).

  51. Kang, M. et al. The pan-genome and local adaptation of Arabidopsis thaliana. Nat. Commun. 14, 6259 (2023).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  52. Zhang, A. et al. A telomere-to-telomere genome assembly of Zhonghuang 13, a widely-grown soybean variety from the original center of Glycine max. J. Crop Sci. 12, 142–153 (2024).

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  53. Smolka, M. et al. Detection of mosaic and population-level structural variants with Sniffles2. Nat. Biotechnol. 42, 1571–1580 (2024).

  54. Saunders, C.T. et al. Sawfish: improving long-read structural variant discovery and genotyping with local haplotype modeling. Bioinformatics 41, btaf136 (2025).

  55. Wang, S. et al. De novo and somatic structural variant discovery with SVision-pro. Nat. Biotechnol. 43, 181–185 (2025).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  56. Magner, R. Blended length genome sequencing (blend-seq): combining short reads with low-coverage long reads to maximize variant discovery. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.01.621515 (2025).

  57. Ebler, J. et al. Pangenome-based genome inference allows efficient and accurate genotyping across a wide spectrum of variant classes. Nat. Genet. 54, 518–525 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  58. Hickey, G. et al. Genotyping structural variants in pangenome graphs using the vg toolkit. Genome Biol. 21, 35 (2020).

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  59. Dwarshuis, N. et al. The GIAB genomic stratifications resource for human reference genomes. Nat. Commun. 15, 9029 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  60. Krusche, P. et al. Best practices for benchmarking germline small-variant calls in human genomes. Nat. Biotechnol. 37, 555–560 (2019).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  61. Wagner, J. et al. Curated variation benchmarks for challenging medically relevant autosomal genes. Nat. Biotechnol. 40, 672–680 (2022).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  62. Cui, Y. et al. A genome-wide spectrum of tandem repeat expansions in 338,963 humans. Cell 187, 6411–6412 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  63. Chen, S. et al. A genomic mutational constraint map using variation in 76,156 human genomes. Nature 625, 92–100 (2024).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  64. Bandah-Rozenfeld, D. et al. Mutations in IMPG2, encoding interphotoreceptor matrix proteoglycan 2, cause autosomal-recessive retinitis pigmentosa. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 87, 199–208 (2010).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  65. Heinen, C. A. et al. Mutations in IRS4 are associated with central hypothyroidism. J. Med. Genet. 55, 693–700 (2018).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  66. Geoffroy, V. et al. AnnotSV: an integrated tool for structural variations annotation. Bioinformatics 34, 3572–3574 (2018).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  67. Jiang, T. et al. A comprehensive genetic variant reference for the Chinese population. Sci. Bull. (Beijing) 69, 3820–3825 (2024).

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  68. Cordaux, R. & Batzer, M. A. The impact of retrotransposons on human genome evolution. Nat. Rev. Genet. 10, 691–703 (2009).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  69. Zerbino, D. R. & Birney, E. Velvet: algorithms for de novo short read assembly using de Bruijn graphs. Genome Res. 18, 821–829 (2008).

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  70. Li, G. et al. HitSV call results for ‘Structural variant detection across sequencing technologies’. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22106614 (2026).

  71. Li, G. et al. HitSV v2.0.4: structural variant detection across sequencing technologies. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22230307 (2026).

Download references

Funding

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (62331012, 62572146 and 62402140) and the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (2024YFF1206300, 2024YFF1206200, 2023YFF1205600 and 2017YFC0907500).

Author information

Author notes

  1. These authors contributed equally: Gaoyang Li, Yadong Liu

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Center for Bioinformatics, Faculty of Computing, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, China

    Gaoyang Li  (李高阳), Yadong Liu  (刘亚东), Anqi Zhang  (张安琪), Xiaoyi Lin  (林枭熠), Zheng Hu  (胡铮), Bo Liu  (刘博) & Yadong Wang  (王亚东)

  2. Key Laboratory of Biological Big Data, Ministry of Education, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin, China

    Gaoyang Li  (李高阳), Yadong Liu  (刘亚东), Anqi Zhang  (张安琪), Xiaoyi Lin  (林枭熠), Zheng Hu  (胡铮), Bo Liu  (刘博) & Yadong Wang  (王亚东)

  3. Center for Quantitative Biology, Academy for Advanced Interdisciplinary Studies, Peking University, Beijing, China

    Long Qian  (钱珑)

Authors

  1. Gaoyang Li  (李高阳)
  2. Yadong Liu  (刘亚东)
  3. Anqi Zhang  (张安琪)
  4. Xiaoyi Lin  (林枭熠)
  5. Zheng Hu  (胡铮)
  6. Bo Liu  (刘博)
  7. Long Qian  (钱珑)
  8. Yadong Wang  (王亚东)

Contributions

Y.W. designed and supervised the research. G.L. and B.L. developed the algorithm and software. B.L., L.Q. and Y.L. contributed to data interpretation. G.L., A.Z. and X.L. performed algorithm benchmarking. L.Q., Y.L., G.L. and A.Z. contributed to the 1KGP4 reanalysis and CHN100K analyses. Z.H. conducted the experimental validation. L.Q., B.L. and Y.L. wrote the paper with input from all other authors. All authors read and approved the final paper.

Corresponding authors

Correspondence to Bo Liu  (刘博), Long Qian  (钱珑) or Yadong Wang  (王亚东).

Ethics declarations

Competing interests

All authors declare no competing interests.

Peer review

Peer review information

Nature Biotechnology thanks Ramakrishnan Rajagopalan, who co-reviewed with Tejas Jammihal; Danny Miller; and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work.

Additional information

Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Extended data

Extended Data Fig. 1 The distributions of SV signatures in various repetitiveness contexts.

The distributions of various kinds of signatures exhibited by SRS and LRS (40 samples shared from HPRC and 1000 Genome Project). The five rows indicate the distributions of SDA in dense CIGARs, SDA in single large insertions/deletions, CLP, DRP (only available for SRS) signatures and their sums, respectively, and the four columns indicate the LRS and SRS signatures in SV- and non-SV windows, respectively. Each of the distributions is shown as a histogram (in the form of stacked bar plots). Each bar corresponds to a specific range of local repetitiveness (r, 10 degrees per bar), and the colored blocks indicate the proportions of the windows in the context of R that have specific numbers of signature reads (that is, #SIG in figure, indicating the windows having 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5–9, 10–15 and >15 reads, respectively).

Extended Data Fig. 2 Benchmarking of various SV callers on various conditions for HG002.

a, F1-GT scores on HG002 long-read (PacBio and ONT), hybrid and short-read sequencing data, respectively. The dark, medium and light bars indicate different configurations for the -P parameter of Truvari (-P 1, 0.9 and 0.7 for dark, medium and light bars, respectively). b, The yields of the callers for various (hard, easy) genomic regions using various coverages of short reads (15×, 30×, 60×, 35×). The ‘hard’ and ‘easy’ regions are the regions hard and easy for short reads to be aligned, defined by GIAB. c, The yields of the short read-based callers for various types and sizes of SVs. The dark and light colors indicate the F1-scores with and without genotyping. d, The left and right ones in the Pie charts indicate the proportions of MEIs (blue part) and non-MEIs brown part) in the insertions output by HitSV having ≤1 kb and >1 kb sizes, respectively.

Extended Data Fig. 3 Comparison of HitSV-SRS, 1KGP-SRS, and other publicly available callsets.

a, UpSet plot for the comparison of HitSV-SRS, 1KGP-SRS, 1KGP-LRS and gnomAD-SV callsets. Blue bars are HitSV-related. b, Sample-by-sample evaluations on the 9 samples of 1KGP-LRS-callset shared with HGSVC-callset. The average precision, recall and F1-scores of 1KGP-LRS-callset are shown. c, Number of population unique and shared SVs in 1KGP-SRS-callset (dark blue) and distinctly identified in HitSV-SRS-callset (light blue). Inset shows the allele count distribution of SVs distinctly identified in HitSV-SRS-callset.

Extended Data Fig. 4 An example of CSV detection in a family-based dataset.

The analysis focuses on a local genomic region encompassing the GSE1 locus on chromosome 16 (chr16: 85,402,995–85,413,170 bp), illustrating CSV inheritance patterns across related individuals. The left panel summarizes the SVs detected by different tools across haplotypes and samples. Among the evaluated methods, HitSV produces haplotype-resolved calls and consistently recovers concordant SV patterns across family members, enabling reliable tracking of inherited variants. In contrast, other tools either lack haplotype resolution or show fragmented, inconsistent, or missing calls. This example highlights the advantage of HitSV in accurately resolving complex SV structures and their transmission patterns in pedigree-based analyses. The right panel presents IGV snapshots of the same region for HG002, HG003, and HG004, showing read alignments and supporting signals consistent with complex SV events.

Extended Data Fig. 5 Representative examples of complex structural variant detection.

IGV snapshots (upper panels) show read alignments at an intronic region of SMOC2 on chromosome 6 (left, chr6: 168,613,859–168,616,177 bp) and an intronic region of DIP2C on chromosome 10 (right, chr10: 477,090–478,673 bp), exhibiting concordantly mapped small divergences and heterogeneous SV signatures, respectively. The lower panels summarize SVs detected by different tools, with genomic positions and variant lengths shown. Q100 HAP1 and Q100 HAP2 denote ground-truth SVs on the two haplotypes. HitSV and Sawfish provide haplotype-resolved calls, whereas the other tools report SVs without haplotype assignment. In left, HitSV shows complete concordance with the ground truth in both variant distribution and length and uniquely detects the 196-bp deletion. In right, HitSV also shows high concordance with the ground truth, whereas other tools exhibit substantial discrepancies in variant distribution and/or length.

Extended Data Fig. 6 Experimental validation for one CHN100K CSV allele in chr1: 50,380,198–50,382,677.

The upper panel shows the PCR amplification of the target interval and the lower panel represents the Sanger sequencing of validated CHN100K CSV loci.

Extended Data Fig. 7 Schematic illustration and characteristics of TR-MEI arrays.

a, A conceptual diagram illustrating the structure of a mobile element insertion–tandem repeat (TR-MEI) array and its variation across haplotypes. Yellow rectangles represent MEI sequences, blue rectangles denote tandem repeat (TR) units, and green blocks indicate flanking nonrepetitive genomic sequences surrounding the TR-MEI region. The upper panel depicts the general architecture of a TR-MEI array composed of alternating MEI and TR units. The lower panels show four haplotypes (Hap1–Hap4) with increasing copy numbers of TR-MEI units. Dark gray trapezoids highlight the genomic region undergoing MEI amplification, illustrating how differential expansion of TR-MEI arrays across haplotypes gives rise to complex structural variation. b, Histogram showing the allele frequency (AF) distribution of samples carrying TR-MEI events across different TR-MEI regions. AF is calculated as the proportion of haplotypes harboring a given TR-MEI event, illustrating the spectrum from rare to near-fixed variants. c, Pie chart summarizing the composition of MEI types within TR-MEI intervals, including LINE/L1, SINE/Alu, SINE/MIR, DNA transposons and Retroposon/SVA elements. Percentages indicate the relative contribution of each MEI class to the total set of TR-MEI regions. d–f, Structural characteristics of TR-MEI arrays across MEI classes (LINE/L1, n = 19; LTR/ERV1, n = 15; LTR/ERVL, n = 14; Retroposon/SVA, n = 12; DNA, n = 6; SINE, n = 4). d, Violin plots showing the distribution of the average number of repeat units per TR-MEI region, stratified by MEI class. Each point represents one TR-MEI region, and box plots indicate the median and interquartile range. e, Violin plots of the average MEI length within TR-MEI regions for different MEI classes, illustrating substantial variation in MEI size across element types. f, Scatterplot depicting the relationship between the average number of repeat units and the average MEI length in TR-MEI regions. Each point corresponds to one TR-MEI region and is colored by MEI class.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, which permits any non-commercial use, sharing, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if you modified the licensed material. You do not have permission under this licence to share adapted material derived from this article or parts of it. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Li, G., Liu, Y., Zhang, A. et al. Structural variant detection across sequencing technologies. Nat Biotechnol (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-026-03332-9

Download citation

  • Received: 18 February 2026

  • Accepted: 04 September 2026

  • Published: 15 October 2026

  • Version of record: 15 October 2026

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-026-03332-9

来源:Nature Biotechnology · nature.com