跨国fMRI分析显示前额叶活动无法反映个体情绪调节能力
Brain scans challenge link between prefrontal activity and ability to regulate emotions
一项发表于 Nature 的国际 fMRI 分析汇总 40 个数据集、2175 名参与者,未发现前额叶活动强度能反映个体情绪调节能力的证据。研究由德国中央精神卫生研究所(CIMH)的 Maurizio Sicorello 与因斯布鲁克大学的 Carmen Morawetz 牵头,32 个团队按预注册的标准化方案分析数据,其中 9 个数据集此前未发表。
汇总40个数据集、2175名参与者的分析显示,前额叶活动无法区分个体情绪调节能力,对临床影像标记的解读提出方法学质疑。
A person's capacity to regulate their emotions apparently cannot be determined by the activity of the prefrontal brain regions typically associated with this process. This is shown by an international fMRI analysis conducted by Dr. Maurizio Sicorello of the Central Institute for Mental Health (CIMH) and Prof. Dr. Carmen Morawetz of the University of Innsbruck, using data from 2,175 people across 40 studies. The study, published in Nature, challenges widespread assumptions about the neural basis of emotion regulation and highlights where task-based imaging reaches its limits when it comes to differences between individuals.
A supervisor criticizes a report in front of the entire team—you feel exposed and hurt. But if you tell yourself, "She takes my work seriously and wants the project to succeed," the same situation can lose some of its intensity. In psychology, this deliberate reinterpretation is called cognitive reappraisal. In the lab, it is usually studied by asking participants to reinterpret distressing images in a way that makes them seem less upsetting.
Cognitive reappraisal is one of the most extensively studied forms of emotion regulation. The capacity to regulate emotions appropriately in a given situation is crucial for mental health, and reappraisal itself is a core element of cognitive behavioral therapy. For years, brain imaging studies have shown that regions of the prefrontal cortex are particularly active during reappraisal. It was concluded from this that the strength of this activation also reveals how well an individual can regulate their emotions. It is precisely this conclusion that the new study calls into question.
32 research teams led by the CIMH
To provide a reliable answer to this question, 32 research teams, led by Dr. Maurizio Sicorello of the Central Institute for Mental Health (CIMH), joined forces to form the international consortium NIDER (Neurobiology of Individual Differences in Emotion Regulation). Together with Dr. Carmen Morawetz from the University of Innsbruck and Jenny Zähringer from the CIMH, Sicorello designed the study and compiled 40 fMRI datasets involving up to 2,175 participants. Nine of these datasets had not been published previously.
The sample size is thus approximately 20 times larger than the largest sample reported in a recent review article on this topic. The participating teams analyzed their data according to a preregistered, standardized protocol. Sicorello then synthesized the results in the main analyses.
Prefrontal activity does not allow for conclusions about the individual
The key finding: The level of activity in the prefrontal regions during the reevaluation did not indicate how well individual participants were able to regulate their emotions.
"Changing our own feelings by looking at a situation in a new light is more than just flexing a mental 'muscle' that some people simply have better trained," says Sicorello, lead author of the study and director of the NIDER Consortium at the CIMH. "What may be more decisive is which interpretations of a situation come naturally to us given our life history, whether we even look for alternatives in everyday life, and whether we consider them credible."
"That doesn't mean the prefrontal cortex isn't important for emotion regulation," emphasizes Morawetz, professor of affective neuroscience at the University of Innsbruck and the study's last author. "Within a single person, brain activity can certainly reveal how emotions change. But when comparing people, we run into limitations—possibly because different people apparently use different neural pathways to arrive at the same result."
Three measurements, no common denominator
The researchers compared three common indicators of a person's emotional regulation: self-report data from a questionnaire; participants' reports of how much their emotional experience changed during the reevaluation while in the scanner; and the resulting decrease in activity in the amygdala—a brain region that processes emotionally significant stimuli.
If all three measures reflect the same capacity, they would have to be closely correlated. That was not the case. A correlation was found only between the reported emotional experience and amygdala activity. However, this correlation was so weak that a single study with more than 1,000 participants would be necessary to reliably demonstrate it. The tendency to reevaluate, as measured by the questionnaire, did not correlate with either of the other two measures or with brain activity.
One possible explanation: Questionnaires measure how people assess their own behavior in everyday life. In the scanner, on the other hand, it is precisely specified when and how they should reassess their behavior. Those who benefit from the strategy in everyday life may not actually be implementing it any better, but rather are better at recognizing when it helps.
Body awareness and motor skills take center stage
Participants who were better able to reduce their negative emotions through reappraisal showed slightly lower activity in sensorimotor brain regions—which are involved, among other things, in body awareness and movement—as well as in attention networks. There was also evidence involving the amygdala and the brainstem—regions that are more commonly associated with the generation of emotions than with their regulation. However, these effects were very small and depended in part on which studies were included in the analysis.
"This is particularly exciting because we've already found similar evidence in a parallel large-scale study on susceptibility to stress," says Sicorello. Further studies will have to show whether there is an overarching principle behind this.
Why it is difficult to compare brain activity across people
The study also reveals a fundamental methodological problem: People differ significantly in how strongly their brains respond overall to a task—for example, due to differences in blood flow, measurement noise or head movements inside the scanner. If a person's brain responds more strongly in one region than in others, the rest of the brain also shows stronger activation. Thus, an increased amygdala response during reevaluation was not accompanied by weaker activity in prefrontal regions, but rather by stronger activity—contrary to what standard models predict. The same pattern was observed in another dataset for tasks involving pain and cognitive control.
"This is an uncomfortable but important insight for our field," says Morawetz. "Interpreting individual brain regions in isolation as markers of a person's capacity to regulate emotions falls short, especially in clinical research, where reduced prefrontal activity is often considered a sign of impaired emotional regulation. We need more realistic, personally relevant tasks and evaluation methods that take such global differences into account."
Publication details
Emotion regulation capacity lacks a shared neural signature, Nature (2026). DOI: 10.1038/s41586-026-11203-1
Journal information: Nature
Who's behind this story?
Gaby Clark
MA in English, copy editor since 2021 with experience in higher education and health content. Dedicated to trustworthy science news. Full profile →
Robert Egan
Bachelor's in mathematical biology, Master's in creative writing. Well-traveled with unique perspectives on science and language. Full profile →
Citation: Brain scans challenge link between prefrontal activity and ability to regulate emotions (2026, October 28) retrieved 28 October 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-10-brain-scans-link-prefrontal-ability.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com