跳到正文
原文
Healthcare Dive· Rebecca Pifer Parduhn·· 14 天前精选AI 评分65

CMS 取消两家争议解决仲裁机构认证

CMS ousts 2 No Surprises arbiters as critics question impartiality

AI 导读

CMS 取消了 Island Peer Review Organization 和 Network Medical Review Company 两家争议解决仲裁机构的认证。这两家机构在过去五年中处理了大量医疗费用争议,但因其高胜诉率和高额赔偿引发争议。CMS 表示这些机构未能达到认证标准,但未详细说明原因。

推荐理由

CMS 取消了两家争议解决仲裁机构的认证,反映了对当前争议解决机制的质疑。

正文 · AI 翻译

译文尚不完整,完整内容请切换到原文。

这段音频是自动生成的。如有意见,请告知我们。反馈。

特朗普政府已将两名仲裁人从用于解决医生和保险公司之间关于非网络服务账单争议的联邦程序中剔除,此举得到了该法律批评者的赞赏,认为这是对被认为有偏见的仲裁人的长期打击。

美国医疗保险和医疗服务中心于周三宣布,已拒绝了岛岸同行评审组织和网络医疗评审公司的重新认证申请。这两家组织在过去五年中一直担任独立争议解决,或IDR,程序的仲裁人,解决了数以十万计的医疗计划与医生之间的账单争议。

IDR 是由《无意外医疗法案》创建的,该法案于2020年通过,旨在保护患者免受意外医疗账单的冲击,当他们不知情地接受非网络服务提供者的服务时。在IDR程序中,保险公司和提供者各自提交他们认为合理的赔偿金额给仲裁人,仲裁人从中选择一个。

The process was meant to be a backstop, used in rare cases when providers and payers can’t figure out reimbursement themselves. But medical groups and physicians have flooded IDR with significantly more disputes than regulators expected. And providers are overwhelmingly prevailing, winning more than 85% of cases last year, according to government data.

Meanwhile, doctors are often awarded three or four times above comparable in-network rates when they win. In one instance, a plastic surgeon was paid $440,000 for a breast reduction that normally costs around $20,000, according to New York Times reporting earlier this year. 

提供者认为其不相称的胜诉率反映了保险公司的不合理低报价。但保险公司和其他批评者则认为赔偿金额过高,一小部分医疗团体——许多由私人股本公司支持——正将不合格的争议塞满IDR程序以获取巨额赔偿。

责任也越来越被归咎于与政府签订合同解决NSA纠纷的17个仲裁机构。

That’s because arbiters are paid by dispute, earning between $425 and $800 for each case they decide. They’re not paid if a dispute is deemed ineligible. As a result, arbiters are incentivized to find cases eligible — and rule in favor of providers so they keep filing them, researchers say.

Island Peer Review Organization, one of the arbiters that lost its certification this week, has one of the highest provider win rates at almost 97%, according to data from price transparency firm Turquoise Health. The company has benefited heavily from its work in IDR, almost tripling its revenues during its tenure in the process, according to an investigation by Stat News.

IPRO是提供方友好的仲裁机构之首

按提供方胜诉率和平均赔偿额排名的IDREs,2025年

另一家被开除的仲裁机构Network Medical Review Company,大约有70%的时间站在提供方一边,这一比率低于许多同行。然而,该公司在纽约时报的报道中因极端的提供方赔偿而受到关注,授予了本文早先提到的44万美元乳房缩小手术赔偿的一半。

目前还不清楚这些组织为何被解雇。CMS的通知称,这两名仲裁者未能达到绩效标准,而该机构的一名发言人在被要求发表评论时没有回应。

被解雇的可能原因包括未能及时作出决定、不准确的资格和支付认定以及与争议方的利益冲突,根据 7月份的常见问题解答。

“要保持认证,IDR实体必须继续满足NSA和规定中规定的认证标准,包括与及时性、准确性以及在作出支付认定时的独立性和公正性相关的规定要求,”CMS在周三的通知中写道。”

IPRO和NMRC都拒绝就其被取消认证的原因发表评论。

但IPRO的一名发言人在声明中表示:“我们对这一决定感到失望,我们的公司一直在努力为该计划提供公平和公正的决定。”

“我们相信网络医疗审查是一个高质量的独立争议解决实体,并以全面、平衡和高效的方式审查索赔,”NMRC的一名发言人在声明中说。”

两家仲裁者表示,他们正在考虑上诉。CMS给被取消认证的实体30天的时间来质疑这一决定。”

但在那段时间内,IPRO和NMRC不能接受任何新的争议。CMS表示,它将联系与这些仲裁者有未决案件的公司,告知下一步行动。”

由保险公司和雇主组成的反意外医疗账单联盟对此表示欢迎,该联盟倡导IDR改革,称仲裁者允许提供者将IDR变成了一场‘淘金热’。”

“The Departments’ actions reinforce the clear need for greater accountability, transparency, and oversight of IDR entities,” the CASMB said in a statement Thursday. The group reiterated its plea for the CMS to pause recertifications until it creates more rigorous standards for arbiters.

该机构目前正在审查另外八名仲裁者的重新认证申请。”

Citing concerns that IDR is spiraling out of control, some insurers have turned to the courts or stopped paying out awards they disagree with. Lawmakers have also expressed interest in closing alleged loopholes in IDR, with Rep. Frank Pallone Jr., D-NJ, introducing a bill last month that would throw out the arbitration process altogether.

帕洛内,NSA的设计师之一,还向仲裁者发送了监督信,要求他们提供更多关于他们如何作出决定的信息,。

来源:Healthcare Dive · healthcaredive.com