跳到正文
原文
Medical Xpress·· 10 天前精选AI 评分65

政府指导表明95%的加工食品不健康

Government guidance indicates 95% of processed foods are unhealthy

AI 导读

一项新研究发现,超过95%的加工和超加工食品在英国政府的营养标准下被视为不健康,而现有的交通灯标签系统仅识别出其中不到一半的不健康食品。研究指出现有食品标签和监管系统存在不足,强调了统一分类系统的必要性。

推荐理由

研究揭示了现有食品标签和监管系统在识别不健康食品方面的不足,强调了统一分类系统的必要性。

正文 · 原文
food shopping
Credit: Helena Lopes from Pexels

More than 95% of processed or ultra-processed food products would be classified as unhealthy under UK government dietary guidance, according to new UCL-led research. The study, published in BMJ Medicine, found that the official public health definitions used to identify and regulate food and drink products in the U.K. varied widely in what proportion of processed and ultraprocessed products they classed as unhealthy, while systems such as traffic light labels failed to identify more than half of these unhealthy packaged foods.

When the Eatwell Guide—a set of government recommendations for nutrient, food and drink intake—was used to define unhealthy food, it classified over 98% of ultraprocessed products and 95% of processed products sold in the U.K. as unhealthy.

By contrast, the voluntary green, amber and red traffic light labeling on the front of packaging identified fewer than half (48.2%) of those foods as unhealthy.

The high fat, salt and sugar (HFSS) definition used by the Food Standards Agency Nutrient Profiling Model (FSA-NPM) to restrict the advertising and promotion of unhealthy foods identified just over half (57.6%) of the same foods as unhealthy.

As a result, the researchers suggest that inconsistencies in labeling and regulation may lead consumers to buy food and drink products which have high levels of saturated fat, salt and sugar without realizing they are unhealthy.

The authors conducted a cross-sectional analysis of a representative database of 262 processed and 1,636 ultraprocessed food and drink items available across the U.K.

They then compared the proportions of processed and ultraprocessed products identified as unhealthy by FSA-NPM, the traffic light system and new nutrient profiling models aligned with the Eatwell Guide.

Professor Chris van Tulleken (UCL Infection, Immunity and Transplantation), the study's senior author, said, "This study shows that the U.K. food environment is saturated with products that make it hard for consumers to eat a diet in line with U.K. government advice. The reason such products are so dominant may be because existing labeling and regulation systems fail to identify them as unhealthy.

"If these products make up the majority of a person's diet, as they do in the U.K., there is a significant risk of consuming more sugar, salt and saturated fat than the Eatwell Guide recommends, even if someone fastidiously avoids red traffic lights and HFSS products.

"This itself would be difficult as traffic lights are voluntary and the HFSS definition is hidden from consumers."

Lead author Sam Dicken (UCL Epidemiology and Health Care) said, "Our analysis shows that tools for regulating healthy and unhealthy foods in the U.K. are inconsistent.

"For example, traffic light labeling showed that 48% of ultraprocessed products surveyed are unhealthy, and the FSA-NPM showed that 57% of ultraprocessed products surveyed are unhealthy. But nutrient profiling models based on U.K. government guidance, the Eatwell Guide, indicated that between 91% and 98% of ultraprocessed products surveyed are unhealthy.

"Current food and drink regulatory tools do not capture products with an excess content of harmful nutrients, but U.K. dietary guidance does."

Some of the food products which would be classified as having high levels of fat, salt and sugar under the Eatwell Guide include canned pasta in tomato sauce, macaroni and cheese made from packaged mix and fat-free probiotic yogurts. These products are not identified as being unhealthy under traffic light labels or the HFSS definition.

Conversely, foods such as nuts or whole fruit may be flagged as being high in sugars or fats by traffic light labeling, despite being encouraged as part of a healthy diet by the Eatwell Guide.

Co-author Dr. Dolly van Tulleken, visiting researcher from the University of Cambridge, said, "This study reveals how confusing and incoherent the U.K. government's definitions of unhealthy food are.

"Products classified as unhealthy by one system are healthy under another. A single, unified system for categorizing food and drink products as unhealthy using existing U.K. dietary guidance is much needed, both for consumers and regulation.

"This must be developed independently of food and drink industry influence. This would help to close regulatory loopholes and address the inconsistency of front-of-pack 'traffic light' labels and FSA-NPM."

Co-author Dr. Adrian Brown (UCL Division of Medicine) said, "This study highlights the need for clearer, more consistent food classification systems that better align with the U.K. dietary guidelines to help consumers make informed choices about food and drink."

Study limitations

The authors note that while their study identifies a representative selection of processed items to compare the performance of different models, it does not suggest this would be an exact list of foods which would be subject to regulation, nor the specific regulatory approaches that should be used. These approaches should be developed independently of food industry influence.

Additionally, as the analysis focuses on processed and ultraprocessed products, it does not test minimally processed foods. There may therefore be additional scope for future studies around this food area.

Publication details

How much processed and ultra-processed food is energy dense and high in fat, sugar and salt? An evaluation of existing and novel nutrient profiling models in identifying unhealthy food and drink, BMJ Medicine (2026). DOI: 10.1136/bmjmed-2025-001750

Journal information: BMJ Medicine

Who's behind this story?

Sadie Harley

Sadie Harley

BSc Life Sciences & Ecology. Microbiology lab background with pharmaceutical news experience in oil, gas, and renewable industries. Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Andrew Zinin

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

Citation: Government guidance indicates 95% of processed foods are unhealthy (2026, November 10) retrieved 10 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-guidance-foods-unhealthy.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com