跳到正文
原文
Nature 健康护理主题·· 15 天前AI 评分60

RETURN试验:行为干预能否促使患者返回牙科诊所?

Can we expect patients to RETURN if the problem is structural?

AI 导读

RETURN试验结果显示,行为干预使患者预约常规牙科检查的意愿提高了三倍,但实际到诊率仅略有增加,表明结构障碍限制了行为改变的效果。

正文

Many patients who attend urgent dental services do so only when problems arise, therefore missing opportunities for prevention and early intervention. The RETURN trial1 addresses an important clinical question: can the urgent dental appointment itself be used as an opportune moment to encourage future routine care?

The intervention was attractive because it was brief, pragmatic, and designed to fit within existing dental workflows, using an existing point of contact when patients were already seeking and prioritising dental care. Importantly, the intervention utilised skill-mix effectively, up-skilling dental nurses to deliver the intervention. The intervention was developed using behaviour change theory, in collaboration with people from disadvantaged groups (the target users), increasing its likelihood of effectiveness.

The primary outcomes demonstrate the complexity of changing dental attendance behaviour. At 12 months, those who had undergone the intervention saw a 21% increase in odds of dental attendance (odds ratio [OR]: 1.21; 97.5% confidence interval [CI]: 0.86 to 1.70). They also saw an improvement in oral health-related quality of life (mean difference: −1.12; 97.5% CI: −3.08 to 0.83). Neither of these results were “statistically significant” at the pre-specified α-level of 0.025. Though “significance” is, at best, crudely informative as to whether the effect of interest is truly present or not2.

A more helpful approach is to consider the magnitude and clinical relevance of the observed effects, including whether they met the pre-defined minimally important difference. That is, whether they reached the threshold considered necessary to represent a clinically meaningful change. Taken together, the estimates consistently favoured the intervention, suggesting a small but positive effect, although the estimates were imprecise as indicated by the confidence intervals spanning a range of effects. As a result, future research may change confidence in the estimated effect and alter the magnitude of the observed benefit.

Secondary outcomes show that, at 18 months, those who had undergone intervention saw a more than threefold increase in odds of a self-reported attempt to make a routine dental appointment (OR: 3.39; 97.5% CI: 1.83 to 6.27). There was also evidence of a small reduction in dental anxiety at 18 months.

The substantial increase in attempts to make a routine appointment at 6-, 12-, and 18-months, but only a small increase in realised routine attendance at these time points, probably reflects the substantial difficulties in obtaining a routine appointment for people who were not already patients at dental practices in the area.

This pattern suggests that, even where behavioural interventions such as RETURN increase attempts to make a routine appointment, structural barriers to accessing care may limit the extent to which these translate into realised routine attendance. Therefore, behavioural support is likely to be most effective when accompanied by infrastructure that enables access to routine care. The study authors state that they view “behavioral support at the point of urgent care as a practical complement to, not a substitute for, structural reforms that address availability and affordability”. This interpretation is also consistent with the trial findings: while participants were considerably more likely to attempt to make an appointment, the modest increase in realised attendance is consistent with the possibility that barriers within the wider dental system limited the extent to which increased motivation could be converted into successful access to routine care. It should be noted that the trial itself was not designed to establish the extent to which structural barriers accounted for this discrepancy; rather, the findings are consistent with structural barriers being plausible explanation, particularly given the context of limited access to dental care in the current NHS setting.

Routine care availability fell suddenly in the post-COVID period, which could not have been foreseen when the trial was designed. Accordingly, these findings lead the reader to reflect on what actually constitutes an appropriate outcome measure. From the investigators’ perspective, it is understandable that realised increases in routine dental attendance were chosen a priori as the primary outcome. After all, it is difficult to justify the considerable resources required to conduct a clinical trial if the intervention is not evaluated against a “hard” outcome that reflects meaningful changes in patient behaviour. However, from the perspective of policymakers, routine attendance is not the only outcome of interest. Although it is a meaningful endpoint, it is influenced by many factors beyond patient behaviour alone.

Indeed, one of the most striking findings from the trial is that the intervention produced more than a threefold increase in the odds of participants attempting to make a routine appointment, yet only a modest increase in realised attendance. This discrepancy may indicate that factors beyond individual motivation, including barriers to accessing routine dental care, constrained the extent to which increased intentions translated into attendance. That is to say, the intervention may have changed behaviour up to the point at which participants encountered barriers that were outside their control. Since over half of trial participants lived in the most deprived decile areas of England, this tells us something about how amenable people’s attitudes to dental care can be, even in the face of multiple socio-economic challenges.

Interestingly then, a trial evaluating an individual-level behavioural intervention has served to highlight population-level and structural barriers to accessing dental care.

For dental practitioners, the urgent dental appointment remains an opportunity to discuss future preventive care. While the RETURN intervention on its own may not yet be sufficient to produce substantial increases in routine attendance, it highlights that incorporating brief conversations about barriers, patient goals, and future care planning may help support engagement, particularly when combined with wider initiatives to improve access.

来源:Nature 健康护理主题 · nature.com