跳到正文
原文
Medical Xpress·· 16 天前AI 评分46

营养评分或警告标签?新研究为欧洲营养标签辩论提供线索

Food scores or warning labels? New study offers clues for Europe's nutrition labeling debate

AI 导读

一项德国-以色列研究使用眼动追踪技术对比了Nutri-Score和以色列警告标签系统,发现以色列标签系统更容易被理解且更有助于健康选择。研究为欧洲和美国的标签政策提供了新证据。

正文
Food scores or warning labels? New study offers clues for Europe's nutrition labeling debate
German and Israeli FOPL design. Credit: Frontiers in Nutrition (2026). DOI: 10.3389/fnut.2026.1826542

A German–Israeli eye-tracking study found that both the design and familiarity of front-of-package nutrition labels shape what consumers notice and how they interpret food products. Participants in both countries found Israel's warning-label system easier to understand and more helpful for making healthy choices than Nutri-Score, offering timely evidence as Europe and the United States reconsider how nutrition information should appear on packaged foods.

Shoppers walking through supermarkets in Germany and Israel encounter two very different approaches to nutrition labeling.

Germany uses Nutri-Score, which summarizes a food's nutritional profile on a five-level scale from a green A to a red E. Israel instead requires red warning labels on foods high in sugar, sodium or saturated fat, alongside a voluntary green label for certain healthier foods.

A new study led by Dr. Gerrit Hummel and professor Nanette Stroebele-Benschop of the University of Hohenheim, and professor Eyal Ert and professor Aron M. Troen of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem directly compared the two systems using eye-tracking technology, measuring not only what consumers said about the labels, but what they actually looked at and how healthy they perceived the products to be.

Published in Frontiers in Nutrition, the study included 223 participants, 112 in Germany and 111 in Israel. Participants viewed food packages displaying either Nutri-Score or Israeli warning and green labels while researchers tracked their eye movements. They then rated the products for healthfulness, expected taste and likelihood of purchase.

The results showed that both label design and familiarity matter. Participants spent more time examining unfamiliar labels, while familiar labels were noticed more quickly. Germans looked longer at the Israeli labels, while Israelis spent more time looking at Nutri-Score, but in both countries participants detected their familiar national label faster.

The two labeling systems also appeared to communicate differently about less-healthy foods.

Perhaps most notably, products carrying explicit red warnings tended to receive more critical evaluations than the same products presented with Nutri-Score, which generally produced more moderate judgments. In addition, participants in both countries rated the Israeli warning-label system as easier to understand and more helpful for choosing healthy foods than Nutri-Score, despite their very different levels of familiarity with the systems.

"Food labels are not just graphics on a package. They are public health interventions," said the researchers. "Whether a system gives a food an overall score or explicitly warns that it is high in sugar, sodium or saturated fat can change what consumers notice and what they understand. Decisions about these systems should therefore be based on evidence about how people actually respond to them."

The findings come at a particularly important moment internationally.

The European Union has been considering a harmonized mandatory front-of-package nutrition label, but disagreement remains over what form such a system should take. The debate reflects a broader question: Should labels provide consumers with an overall nutritional score, or clearly warn them when specific nutrients exceed recommended levels?

The same discussion is taking place in the United States, where the Food and Drug Administration has proposed a front-of-package "Nutrition Info" box that would classify saturated fat, sodium and added sugars as "Low," "Med" or "High."

The researchers stress that the study does not establish one universal "best" label. Nutri-Score can help consumers compare products along a nutritional scale, while nutrient-specific warnings serve a different purpose by drawing attention to potentially problematic ingredients. The current findings show that the way nutrition information is communicated is not neutral.

"Different systems are designed to achieve different things," Troen said. "The question policymakers need to ask is not simply which label people prefer, but which system best achieves the public health goal they are trying to accomplish."

The researchers also caution that the study used controlled, fictional food packages and nonrepresentative samples, meaning larger and more diverse studies will be needed. Still, the international comparison offers new evidence that effective labels must not only contain the right information, but also attract attention and be easily understood.

As Europe and the United States consider changes to food labeling, the study highlights a simple but important point: What governments put on the front of a food package can shape what consumers actually see.

Publication details

Gerrit Hummel et al., Warning and green labels versus Nutri-Score: visual attention and product evaluation in a binational eye-tracking study, Frontiers in Nutrition (2026). DOI: 10.3389/fnut.2026.1826542

Journal information: Frontiers in Nutrition

Key medical concepts

Eye Tracking

Who's behind this story?

Gaby Clark

Gaby Clark

MA in English, copy editor since 2021 with experience in higher education and health content. Dedicated to trustworthy science news. Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Andrew Zinin

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

Citation: Food scores or warning labels? New study offers clues for Europe's nutrition labeling debate (2026, November 3) retrieved 3 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-food-scores-clues-europe-nutrition.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com