跳到正文
原文
Medical Xpress·· 6 天前AI 评分35

研究揭示疫情压力对枪支暴力的影响

Study measures impact of pandemic stress on gun violence spike

AI 导读

疫情期间,美国枪支凶杀案激增,但随后迅速回落。芝加哥大学的 Jens Ludwig 通过分析行为经济学原理,认为疫情带来的压力增加了人们的自动认知负担,导致原本的争端升级为暴力事件。研究发现,疫情期间枪支携带量显著增加,尤其是年轻人涉及的暴力事件增多。

正文
anti gun
Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain

The COVID-19 pandemic coincided with one of the most dramatic swings in homicide in modern American history.

According to the CDC, the U.S. homicide rate spiked 34% after 2019 but by 2024 had fallen nearly back to prepandemic levels. The sharp rise and fall were driven largely by gun homicides and occurred far more quickly than other major shifts in the nation's murder rate over the past century.

Jens Ludwig at the University of Chicago argues behavioral economics may help explain how that happened.

In a new working paper, Ludwig, the Edwin A. and Betty L. Bergman Distinguished Service Professor, analyzed the impact of the pandemic's many stressors on the public's automatic cognition and cognitive "bandwidth tax."

With wide access to firearms, Ludwig argues, this underlying state helped escalate heated personal disputes into bursts of "expressive" violence.

"Most shootings don't further some larger goal like robbery or gang wars over drug turf," Ludwig wrote. "They're arguments settled with guns."

Ludwig—who also serves as the Pritzker director of the UChicago Crime Lab, co-director of the Education Lab and director of the Bike Shop @UChicago—examined several potential explanations for the increase in crime during the pandemic that follow from that framework.

These included changes to economic conditions and the broader criminal justice system. But he found these other factors do not appear sufficient to explain the magnitude of the recent changes in homicide rates.

Arguments, judgment and violence

As Ludwig explained in his 2025 book, Unforgiving Places, criminologists distinguish between "instrumental" violence committed in pursuit of some other objective, such as robbery, and "expressive" violence intended to harm another person.

Ludwig says most U.S. homicides are expressive, citing historical data suggesting this type of violence accounts for roughly three-quarters of murders in cases where motive is known.

That matters because the decisions made during an escalating argument may look very different from the deliberate cost-benefit calculation at the center of traditional economic models of crime.

Drawing on research in psychology and behavioral economics, Ludwig focuses instead on the role of automatic cognition: the fast mental processes people rely on to navigate everyday life.

Those processes are essential but produce mistakes: misreading someone else's intentions, interpreting an action as a deliberate insult when it may not be, or seeing a negative situation as more catastrophic than it truly is.

Ludwig points to randomized controlled trials of behavioral interventions that help participants recognize and reconsider their automatic reactions in high-stakes situations. Several have produced substantial reductions in violent-crime or weapons arrests.

The results are difficult to explain solely through the traditional economic model, Ludwig argues, because the interventions do not primarily change participants' economic opportunities or the penalties they face for committing crimes.

Stress and the 'bandwidth tax'

That behavioral framework also suggests one possible explanation for the homicide surge. Research has found that stress can impose a cognitive "bandwidth tax," increasing people's reliance on automatic decision-making.

The COVID-19 pandemic brought extraordinary levels of illness, grief, social isolation, uncertainty and disruption, while measures of anxiety and depression rose sharply, with the effects especially pronounced among young adults.

A CDC survey cited by Ludwig found that in the summer of 2020, 75% of Americans ages 18 to 24 reported anxiety, depression, trauma, increased substance use or suicidal ideation. Drug and alcohol use also increased during the period. Young adults are also the group most disproportionately involved in serious violence.

Ludwig argues that these developments are consistent with a behavioral explanation in which greater distress, substance use and reliance on automatic cognition made interpersonal encounters more susceptible to misunderstanding and escalation—and gun violence.

Ludwig finds that much of the volatility in homicide was concentrated in expressive rather than instrumental violence. Murder rose sharply, but most other serious crimes did not. Aggravated assault, the other major violent crime most closely associated with interpersonal conflicts, also increased.

Another unusual source of evidence for heightened stress and interpersonal conflict: unruly passenger incidents reported by the Federal Aviation Administration. Those incidents rose dramatically during the pandemic and later declined, including when mask-related incidents are excluded.

The role of guns

There is no direct national measure of how many people carry guns in public, so Ludwig instead examined several available proxies from individual jurisdictions.

These measures, such as the share of police stops that result in the recovery of a firearm, suggest gun carrying increased sharply during the pandemic and later declined. In Chicago, for example, the share of stops yielding a gun more than doubled between 2019 and 2020.

Large changes are also evident in available data from California and New York City. Handgun sales surged, the paper reports—with sales increasing from about 8 million in 2019 to 14 million in 2020.

The evidence is not sufficient to attribute the homicide surge to gun sales or gun carrying alone. Gun homicides increased both inside and outside the home, and the increase was substantially larger outside the home. Ludwig argues the patterns suggest both the prevalence of guns and the conditions surrounding interpersonal conflict mattered.

Put more simply, Ludwig writes, murder in America is historically "mostly about arguments and guns." His interpretation of the period since 2019 is that both became more common during the pandemic and then less common as the pandemic receded.

In 2021, as pandemic restrictions eased and many aspects of normal life resumed, homicides began declining, the paper reports.

Measures of some forms of mental distress and substance use also began to level off or decline, the paper said, while use of behavioral health treatment increased—particularly among younger adults.

What this means for gun violence policy

If a substantial share of shootings grows out of interpersonal conflicts in which people make consequential mistakes under stress, Ludwig argues, preventing violence requires more attention to the moments in which those conflicts develop and escalate.

One approach is behavioral interventions that help people question their immediate interpretations and responses in high-stakes situations. He cites experimental studies that suggest such programs can reduce violent offending.

Ludwig also points to interventions that increase the likelihood that someone will be present to interrupt a conflict before it escalates. That could include police presence, but also changes to the built environment that create more of what urbanist Jane Jacobs called "eyes on the street."

Ludwig argues the pandemic-era rise in homicides looks very different once gun violence is understood less as the product of calculated criminal behavior and more often as the result of interpersonal conflicts, automatic reactions and the presence of firearms.

That shift in perspective, he suggests, could also change how policymakers think about preventing the next shooting.

More information

Jens Ludwig, Crime in COVID Times, NBER Working Paper Series (2026). DOI: 10.3386/w35827

Who's behind this story?

Gaby Clark

Gaby Clark

MA in English, copy editor since 2021 with experience in higher education and health content. Dedicated to trustworthy science news. Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Andrew Zinin

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

Citation: Study measures impact of pandemic stress on gun violence spike (2026, November 13) retrieved 13 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-impact-pandemic-stress-gun-violence.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com