跳到正文
原文
Medical Xpress·· 10 天前AI 评分35

太极与匹配锻炼对老年癌症幸存者睡眠质量的影响

Slow hands, quiet nights? Tai chi and a matched exercise class nudged sleep about equally in older men after cancer

AI 导读

一项由Rutgers癌症研究所领导的随机对照试验发现,太极和气功与匹配锻炼在改善老年癌症幸存者睡眠质量方面效果相似,但未达到统计学显著差异。研究显示,锻炼组在睡眠效率方面优于太极组(p=0.04),但差异可能为偶然。总体而言,两种方式均能轻微改善睡眠,但效果有限。

正文
tai chi
Credit: Vlada Karpovich from Pexels

Sleep disturbances affect up to 60% of people after primary cancer treatment, and they are often waved away as the price of treatment, or of age. For older men in particular, science has had little to offer. Most research on behavioral treatments for insomnia has studied women with breast cancer.

A team led by Evelyn Arana-Chicas of Rutgers Cancer Institute set out to close part of that gap. Their peer-reviewed randomized controlled trial, published in Brain Medicine, asked a plain question with an ancient practice at its center: could tai chi and qigong help older male cancer survivors sleep better? The paper is titled "Effects of Tai Chi Qigong on sleep quality in older male cancer survivors: A randomized controlled clinical trial."

A trial with a disguise

Tai chi and qigong, both meditative movement traditions rooted in Chinese medicine, combine gentle postures, deep breathing, and meditation. They are low in intensity, which makes them well suited to older bodies. But any study of a gentle practice faces an awkward problem. Is it the meditation that helps, or simply the act of getting off the couch twice a week and moving in a room full of other people?

The researchers built their trial to pull those two apart. Men aged 55 and older who had finished primary treatment for cancer, and who were living with clinically significant fatigue, were randomized to one of three groups. One received tai chi qigong, taught by a qigong master or certified instructor: 19 exercises of breathing, flowing movement, and guided relaxation, some of them possible from a chair.

A second group took an exercise class designed by two exercise physiologists to match tai chi qigong in intensity, posture, and muscle activation, built from controlled stretching and repetitive exercises. A third group continued with usual care. Both classes met twice a week, for an hour, for 12 weeks.

Then came the clever part. The words tai chi and qigong never appeared in study materials. One class was called body-mind training; the other, body training. Participants were not told which was the experimental condition. It is a little like a blind wine tasting, where the labels come off so that only the wine can speak.

What the pillow reported

In all, 113 men enrolled at sites in New Brunswick and Albuquerque. Their average age was 69. Most had prostate cancer. Attendance was strong and similar in both classes, 78.4% for tai chi qigong and 76.8% for the matched exercise, and the men rated the two programs as similarly credible.

Sleep was measured with the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, a questionnaire on which lower scores mean better sleep. At the three-month mark after the program ended, the trial's primary endpoint for this analysis, the three groups did not differ significantly. In fact, no pairwise comparison between groups reached significance at any time point.

Within each group, the picture had more texture. The exercise class improved from baseline at six weeks (mean change −1.20; 95% CI, −2.02 to −0.39), one week after the program (−0.82; 95% CI, −1.63 to −0.01), and three months later (−1.04; 95% CI, −1.84 to −0.24). The tai chi qigong group moved in the same direction at each of those points, but its changes did not reach statistical significance.

By 12 months, the gains in both groups had faded. Sleep efficiency, the share of time in bed actually spent asleep, improved more with the exercise class than with tai chi qigong at three months (p = 0.04), though the authors caution that this may be a chance finding.

One number will tempt a headline writer, and it deserves a careful hand. At 12 months, 62% of the tai chi qigong group met the questionnaire threshold for clinical remission of sleep disturbance, compared with 47% in the exercise group and 43% with usual care. Those differences were not statistically significant. They are a pattern worth watching, not a result.

"Sleep disturbance is one of the most common and persistent problems people carry after cancer treatment, and older men have rarely been the focus of this kind of research," said Wadih Arap, co-author, of Rutgers Cancer Institute and the Division of Hematology/Oncology, Department of Medicine, Rutgers New Jersey Medical School, in Newark.

"This trial gave them that attention, with a careful three-arm design and strong attendance in both classes. The answers are modest, and they point clearly to the larger and more diverse studies that should come next."

The honest arithmetic

The authors are direct about the limits. Every change they saw fell below three points on the sleep index, the threshold for a clinically meaningful difference. The study was underpowered to detect differences between groups. The men were mostly white, non-Hispanic, and college-educated, and 87% had prostate cancer; by chance, no men without prostate cancer were randomized to usual care. Few participants were over 80.

Participants were recruited for fatigue rather than for sleep problems, so the results may not apply to survivors whose main complaint is insomnia alone. Sleep was self-reported, and the authors recommend actigraphy or wearable devices in future work. Home practice logs were completed inconsistently, and the trial ran into the COVID-19 pandemic, although classes delivered in person and in hybrid format showed similar patterns.

Movement as medicine, without the mystique

It would be easy to wish for a different story, one in which an old practice of slow hands and measured breath quietly outperforms the gym. This trial does not tell that story. What it says is plainer, and perhaps more useful. For older men after cancer, two very different ways of moving, one meditative and one not, appeared to help sleep a little and about equally, for a while.

In their conclusion, the authors write that both approaches may yield comparable sleep benefits, and that adequately powered, demographically diverse trials are needed before clinical recommendations can follow.

More information

Evelyn Arana-Chicas et al., Effects of Tai Chi Qigong on sleep quality in older male cancer survivors: A randomized controlled clinical trial, Brain Medicine (2026). DOI: 10.61373/bm026a.0063

Provided by Genomic Press

Who's behind this story?

Sadie Harley

Sadie Harley

BSc Life Sciences & Ecology. Microbiology lab background with pharmaceutical news experience in oil, gas, and renewable industries. Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Andrew Zinin

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

Citation: Slow hands, quiet nights? Tai chi and a matched exercise class nudged sleep about equally in older men after cancer (2026, November 9) retrieved 9 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-quiet-nights-tai-chi-class.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com