跳到正文
原文
Nature 健康护理主题·· 2026-10-14AI 评分21

不同局部氟化物应用对患龋幼儿唾液及菌斑氟化物水平的影响

How do different topical fluoride applications affect salivary and plaque fluoride levels for young children with dental caries?

AI 导读

一项针对3-6岁患龋儿童的随机对照试验比较了含氟涂料与氨银等方案,结果显示各组基线龋坏及氟化物水平存在差异。因各组涂布牙齿数量(5颗或20颗)及氟化物交付剂量不同,且未采用意向性分析,限制了结论的适用范围与临床转化性。

正文

This study was a small randomised controlled trial1. It was registered in advance and had a sample size calculation appropriately based on previous research. The age of participants (3–6 years) is relevant to the interventions offered and a suitable group in which to do the research. They were at high risk of caries so likely to be a target population for the interventions, with a high caries rate with a mean of 7.6 decayed, missing or filled teeth.

There were differences in the groups at baseline, in terms of the number of decayed, missing and filled teeth. The authors also report that there were differences in fluoride levels between groups at baseline; this may affect the subsequently collected outcome data, which affects the ability to compare across groups at the later time points.

The decision to compare one arm with silver diamine fluoride treatment for carious teeth with sodium fluoride varnish application for prevention in another arm limits the transferability of the findings in a clinical situation, as these are not different options for the same indication from which a treatment choice would be made. In a clinical situation, they would be used in combination; as such, it is not of clinical relevance which of these two arms led to higher fluoride levels. While the introduction discusses investigating fluoride levels following different topical applications, the authors do not clearly report the rationale for selecting a randomised controlled trial design. Given that the interventions have different clinical indications, a clearer explanation of why randomisation was considered the most appropriate design would have strengthened the interpretation of the findings. Further, owing to the different indications across arms, in one arm an average of only 5 teeth were treated, whereas in the other two arms, twenty were. This also meant different volumes of fluoride were delivered across groups, which has clear consequences for the salivary and plaque fluoride levels. This means that the intervention differed between groups not only in formulation (ie sodium fluoride varnish vs silver diamine fluoride), but also in quantity and dose delivered, in addition to indication. The authors did acknowledge this difference in fluoride delivery in the discussion of the study.

In the sodium fluoride varnish groups, the fluoride procedure was delivered to all teeth. Therefore, it seems more likely that plaque would be taken from sites adjacent to fluoride application. This may mean that across groups, some samples were taken from sites directly adjacent to fluoride application, whereas for the silver diamine fluoride group this would be less likely. This means groups were potentially measured differently for this outcome, which is important for interpretation of this finding.

The ability to collect saliva for 5 minutes at multiple time points would be very challenging to do consistently for three-year-old participants, and 17% were unable to provide this measure. Data were only analysed for those with 48-hour measurements, and by not using intention-to-treat analysis, the generalisability of the findings is reduced. For example, it may be that those who were unable to complete the salivary test were also unable to co-operate fully with the applications, affecting fluoride delivery, so they may have had different results as a cohort.

Participants were given fluoride-free toothpaste, which would not be the context into which these fluoride preventative and treatment procedures would be provided in the UK2. This limits the generalisability of findings to this context.

来源:Nature 健康护理主题 · nature.com