从绿色奶昔到"干细胞"补充剂:网络"提升免疫力"内容可能误导你
From green smoothies to stem‑cell supplements—online 'immune‑boosting' ideas may lead you astray
公共卫生研究人员发现,Instagram 上超过 96% 的"提升免疫力"内容出自销售或推广产品/服务的创作者,28 条样本帖子共标记 62 家公司。研究指出,水疗、静脉输液、"排毒"及"干细胞"补充剂等宣称增强免疫力的产品均无获益证据,目前尚无任何药品、产品或天然疗法获 Health Canada 批准用于提升免疫系统。
We all want a well-functioning immune system to help us fight invasive bacteria and viruses and recover faster from illness. Popular "immune-boosting" ideas, however, might be more of a hindrance than a help.
Immune boosting is an online trend. Content producers share immune-boosting recipes—from smoothies to soups to poke bowls and pumpkin loaves. Nutrition books speak of "super powered immunity" while naturopathic clinics share immune-boosting "tips."
The "boosting" phrase has become so commonplace that it frequently appears in health content from reputable academic institutions.
The COVID-19 pandemic—more so than ever in recent memory—had the public thinking hard about immunity. As interdisciplinary public health researchers studying the influential forces that shape public perceptions, we took notice of the rise of immune-boosting discourse during this time. We researched the trending concept in Google search results and on social media sites like Instagram.
We found it to be problematic in two ways: First, content often presents scientific inaccuracies about how the immune system functions; second, it showcases corporations that push ineffective products or services. At a time when trust in evidence-based interventions like vaccines is on shaky ground, this can lead to negative outcomes for our health.
Balance, don't supercharge
Not all immunity-boosting content is inaccurate or harmful. Information from research or medical organizations often focuses on healthy eating, exercising, getting proper sleep and avoiding the harms of tobacco and alcohol. The idea of boosting or enhancing one's immunity, however, remains fundamentally flawed. The immune system needs maintaining, not enhancing.
That's because each person's immune system is complex, made up of cells, tissues, organs and proteins. This system works innately and nonspecifically to keep harmful invader germs out, using, for example, the skin and mucous membranes as a protective barrier. It also works adaptively, deploying a targeted and specific response for harmful invaders.
The adaptive immune system uses B cells that produce antibodies—special proteins that attach to invader germs and either mark them for destruction or neutralize their effects. There are also T cells, which act as destroyers, hunting and killing cells that have been infected by germs.
Amazingly, the adaptive process of the immune system builds memory cells of the pathogens it battles. When the same invader re-enters the body, it can be quickly recognized and targeted more effectively. A well-functioning immune system also correctly differentiates between your own cells and invader cells.
An underperforming immune system increases the possibility and severity of infection. But an overactive immune system can lead to a host of autoimmune diseases like rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis. Maintaining the immune system therefore involves balance—not supercharging its functions and abilities.
Corporations boost profits
Those who promote the concept of "immune boosting" are often simply trying to generate profit. The very idea of "boosting" can create a sentiment of lacking—that one's health could (always) be better. This frames health status as a deficit requiring people to continually pursue restorative or optimization efforts—a commonly used health and wellness marketing strategy.
The first step is to establish a void, accompanied by anxiety or fear. The second step is to offer purchasable actions that address the void.
Our research on Instagram during the pandemic, for example, found that more than 96% of the immune-boosting content we reviewed came from creators that sold or advertised products or services. We found 62 different companies tagged in a sample of 28 posts.
We also reflected on how the social media hashtag #immunebooster itself functioned as a rhetorical product used to "generate activity in the online attention economy."
Other companies may promote immunity-enhancing products or services with immunity-enhancing claims, such as hydrotherapy, IV drips, cleanses and detoxes. Cereal companies in the past have also marketed their products as "supporting" immunity. There is no good evidence that any of these activities have benefits for immune function.
Stem-cell supplements
Dietary supplements in the form of vitamins, minerals or herbs also offer limited benefit to those without diagnosed deficiencies.
As noted in an immune-boosting article by a Canadian pharmaceutical chain, "to date, no drug, product or natural remedy has been officially approved by Health Canada to boost the immune system." Yet corporations market them as either explicitly boosting or generally offering benefit to the immune system.
Recent research from our team, for example, assessed the marketing of "stem cell" supplements on the e-commerce marketplace Amazon. We found more than 40% of the products claimed immunity-related benefits.
Supplements are now big business, with a market valuation in the hundreds of billions. It is not surprising to find a broad, all-encompassing marketing approach to products such as "stem cell" supplements that have no clear evidence of efficacy for any health ailment.
Trust in medicine
The commercialization of immunity is a concern for all of us. Commercialized health spaces can damage trust in health care systems and cause confusion around who and what we trust.
If our perceptions are shaped by companies and influencers, this might negatively influence vital evidence-based health activities, such as vaccination. Rampant vaccine misinformation during the pandemic dissuaded vaccine uptake and helped promote inaccurate ideas of personal immunity.
Vaccine hesitancy is highly complex, with multiple factors at play. Politics and polarization are increasingly influential forces. Inaccurate immunity discourse only further clouds information landscapes and, in turn, vaccination decision-making.
Health and wellness marketing is savvy and alluring, carefully crafted to pique our interest and provide solutions. In today's media environments, we all need to be cautious and critical of companies marketing products and services for our health and well-being. It matters when assessing preparedness for any future pandemic, and how our health care systems can build and maintain public trust.
Accurate understandings of immunity help us maintain well-functioning immune systems and a well-functioning society.
Who's behind this story?
Gaby Clark
MA in English, copy editor since 2021 with experience in higher education and health content. Dedicated to trustworthy science news. Full profile →
Andrew Zinin
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Citation: From green smoothies to stem‑cell supplements—online 'immune‑boosting' ideas may lead you astray (2026, November 4) retrieved 4 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-green-smoothies-stemcell-supplements-online.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com