关于水基泡沫用于牲畜去群的动物福利问题
Animal welfare concerns regarding water-based foam used for depopulation of livestock
一项发表在《科学报告》的研究建议水基泡沫(WBF)作为小反刍动物去群的候选方法,但忽视了其根本的动物福利影响,低估了动物的痛苦时间。动物福利评估应准确反映其使用条件的伦理合理性极为罕见。去群方法需减少动物的痛苦、恐惧等负面体验,并迅速推广使用。
arising from: J. Y. Park et al.; Scientific Reports https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-10881-7 (2025).
Introduction
Farm animal depopulation, i.e., mass killing in response to urgent circumstances, is an increasingly common occurrence in animal agriculture. Water-based foam (WBF) is one such method that kills by smothering animals with a wet foam that results in airway occlusion (obstructive asphyxia). Used in the United States as a method of poultry depopulation, the severely negative subjective experience associated with dying from airway occlusion has led numerous expert panels to reject WBF as a depopulation method1,2,3. However, a recent study published in Scientific Reports that evaluated WBF’s utility in sheep and goats recommends it as “a strong candidate for small ruminant depopulation”4. Despite including the term “welfare” among the article’s keywords, Park et al. neglect to examine fundamental welfare harms associated with WBF and downplay the duration of animals’ suffering. Accurately characterizing WBF’s animal welfare impacts would demonstrate that the circumstances in which its use would be ethically justified are exceedingly rare.
Ethical considerations in animal depopulation
Because of the negative impacts of depopulation on producers, workers, animals, and the environment, the primary ethical imperative in depopulation decision-making is to reduce the instances in which depopulation is deemed necessary. In an imperfect world of communicable disease and natural (and anthropogenic) disasters, the risk remains of situations requiring the rapid killing of animals out of consideration for animal welfare. However, the same ethical concern for animal welfare underlying support for depopulation demands the development and deployment of higher-welfare methods that minimize or eliminate animals’ pain, fear, and other negative experiences. These higher-welfare means must then be made rapidly accessible and also used preferentially.
As Park et al. note, the American Veterinary Medical Association accepts a lower standard of animal welfare for depopulation methods than for euthanasia or slaughter methods5. This ethically controversial position is not universally accepted. Regardless, the animal welfare impact of each depopulation method must be accurately assessed and reported to enable decision-makers to include—and prioritize—animal welfare in disaster planning, preparedness, and response.
Assessing animal welfare through rigorous metrics is essential
Animal welfare at the time of killing can be assessed by considering the time to loss of consciousness (LOC) and the animals’ experiences until this point6. These experiences are often described in terms of affective states, which may be positive (e.g., comfort, pleasure) or negative (e.g., pain, fear)7. Affective states can often be inferred by behavioral observations and the pathophysiology of the killing methods.
Considering animals’ likely affective states when foam enters, irritates, and occludes their airways is essential. Airway occlusion stops the respiratory system from exchanging both oxygen and carbon dioxide (CO2)8. Bloodstream accumulation of CO2 strongly stimulates the drive to breathe9, but airway occlusion prevents lung expansion. This combination—a strongly stimulated ventilatory drive combined with an inability to expand the lungs—results in severe “air hunger,” the type of respiratory distress humans report as the most unpleasant and potentially worse than pain10,11. In a 2021 study on humans with experimentally induced air hunger, participants reported anxiety, fear, panic, and frustration, and functional brain imaging showed activation of corresponding limbic structures11. The researchers noted that the “strong negative emotional response that accompanies air hunger has evolutionary adaptive value in motivating avoidance or escape behaviors in situations in which respiratory needs cannot be met.”
Veterinary patients with partial airway obstruction require sedatives and anxiolytics to reduce the accompanying fear and anxiety12. Elevated blood CO2 levels directly stimulate the amygdala, triggering fearful and anxious behaviors13. Veterinary forensics researchers note that animals dying of obstructive asphyxia often have injuries from struggling before LOC14.
Expert panels have likened WBF to drowning1,2,3, a widely condemned killing method15,16. Drowning is an imperfect analogy, as animals subjected to WBF are not submerged in water alone. However, “drowning” describes more than one mechanism of death (filling of the airways with fluid versus submersion-induced laryngeal spasm resulting in airway obstruction), and the drowning process is complex17,18, so the experience of animals submerged in WBF and their resulting pathology is likely similar to that of some drowning victims. Using anesthetized research animals, proponents of WBF have attempted to prove that WBF is dissimilar to drowning by demonstrating that its postmortem imaging and histopathological findings differ from those associated with water submersion19. This conclusion is problematic because anesthesia prevents the struggling that occurs in real-world application, and the research fails to demonstrate that death via WBF differs from the World Health Organization’s definition of drowning: “the process of experiencing respiratory impairment from submersion/immersion in liquid”20.
Specific concerns with data reporting
Park et al. clearly recognize that the time to LOC is central to assessing welfare impact. They investigated time to cessation of movement (COM), time to last audible movement, and time to cortical death; appropriately, all were measured from the start of foam application4. However, even accounting for the post-publication corrections made to the article, problems with data reporting and analysis challenge the correct interpretation of this research.
First, although the study reports average times to COM for conscious animals, the range is as important as the mean because welfare risk is concentrated in the tail of the distribution curve. The authors do report a maximum time to COM of 09:00 (mm: ss), yet the welfare implications of such a long period of consciousness are not discussed. Animals at the tail end experience the longest period before LOC, and that interval should be explicitly presented and discussed.
In addition, in Trial 2, cough was associated with a significantly shorter time from foam start to transitional electroencephalogram (EEG) (60.9 s versus 112.4 s, P = 0.04). Worse nasal discharge scores also trended toward shorter transitional EEG times, with score 3 (range: 0–4) showing a large, near-significant reduction. These patterns suggest that healthy animals may take longer to reach LOC. Subgroup reporting excluding compromised animals would provide a clearer picture of typical welfare outcomes.
Park et al. also discuss time to COM and other markers of LOC in research performed on other species. Comparing WBF studies, most of which involved the authors of the present study, presents challenges because they differ in Time Zero (T0), i.e., when the clock starts to measure time to LOC. Animals likely experience severe distress when they begin struggling to keep foam out of their nose and mouth. Yet some studies set T0 to the moment at which the container is completely filled, and the animals are already submerged under multiple feet of foam21,22,23,24.
Park et al. compare the mean time to COM for sheep and goats with that of other species, but the cited times (1) mix small plastic-tote studies with rendering trailer studies, (2) use different T0 points, and (3) sometimes conflict with mean times reported elsewhere in the cited reference. Park et al.’s discussion section lists times of 01:45 for finisher pigs, 01:20 for suckling pigs, and 02:30 for adult cattle. The suckling-pig time of 01:20 appears in the abstract of a study by Kieffer et al., but differs from what is reported in that paper’s results section24. Indeed, Kieffer’s discussion section states “mean times to COM in…suckling pigs [were] 145.5 s [02:26] and 52.5 s [0:53] for both individual and age-group-level activity thresholds.” The authors themselves cast doubt on the validity of their age-group values, as they “could be biased toward extreme EA [external acceleration] from highly active animals”24. The more reliable individual thresholds are much higher than the times reported in Park et al.
Not included among the times reported in the Park et al. discussion section is a study by Campler et al. on depopulation of finisher pigs in a trailer filled with WBF, which found that even when the trailer was filled as rapidly as possible, the average time to COM was 03:1125. For cattle, Capria reported the average time to COM was 02:30 for one trial but 03:00 for another, measures that fail to include the time required to fill the trailer with foam, which averaged an additional 01:23 to 01:30. Including fill time, Capria’s results indicate that some cattle did not stop moving for nearly 9 min after the start of foaming22.
WBF must be rejected due to its negative welfare impacts
WBF results in an intensely negative state of welfare before animals lose consciousness. Yet, the AVMA’s 2026 depopulation guidelines place WBF for pigs in a category that “optimize[s] animal welfare outcomes.” The guidelines assert this category should be used preferentially, including when developing emergency response plans5. (The guidelines categorize WBF as a second-line method for other farm animal species.) Classifying WBF as a first- or even second-line depopulation method clearly contradicts the available evidence, even as presented in the Park et al. paper. The available evidence suggests that use of WBF is justified only in the most extreme circumstances, when better methods are unavailable and doing nothing will likely result in significantly more animal suffering.
When killed using WBF, animals experience severe air hunger, fear, anxiety, frustration, distress, and—given necropsy findings such as pulmonary hemorrhage—possibly pain19. These negative mental states cannot be mitigated unless animals are deeply anesthetized. While the average time to LOC under ideal research conditions may be relatively short for some birds (64–76 s for turkeys, 41 s for chickens), it is significantly longer for ducks and mammals22,25,26,27,28. The broad range of times to LOC means that, for all species, some individuals killed by this method suffer intensely for a prolonged period.
Much has been made of WBF’s acceptability to observers29. However, a lack of appreciation of the experience of the animals, hidden from view by foam during the period of most intense suffering, likely influences these assessments.
The United States approved WBF for poultry depopulation nearly 20 years ago. Canada, the United Kingdom, the European Union, and the World Organization for Animal Health all reject its use based on welfare considerations. The Park et al. study cannot support the conclusion that the animals’ experience is acceptable from a welfare perspective. Practical, higher-welfare depopulation methods are available for sheep, goats, and other species30,31. Through careful research, investment, planning, and preparedness for the use of these methods, we can avoid circumstances in which an inhumane tool like WBF is ever the sole viable option.
Data Availability
No datasets were generated during the current study.
References
EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare. Killing for purposes other than slaughter: Poultry. EFSA J. 17, e05850. https://doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2019.5850 (2019). https://doi.org:.
EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare et al. The use of high expansion foam for stunning and killing pigs and poultry. EFSA J. 22, e8855. https://doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2024.8855 (2024).
Animal Welfare Committee. AWC Opinion on the use of high expansion nitrogen foam for culling poultry, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/awc-opinion-on-high-expansion-nitrogen-foam-for-culling-poultry/awc-opinion-on-the-use-of-high-expansion-nitrogen-foam-for-culling-poultry (2024).
Park, J. Y. et al. Medium-expansion water-based foam depopulation of sheep and goats. Sci. Rep. 15, 25037. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-10881-7 (2025).
Leary, S. et al. AVMA Guidelines for the Depopulation of Animals: 2026 Edition. https://www.avma.org/sites/default/files/2026-01/Depopulation_Guidelines_2026Complete.pdf (American Veterinary Medical Association, 2026).
Reyes-Illg, G., Martin, J. E., Mani, I., Reynolds, J. & Kipperman, B. The rise of heatstroke as a method of depopulating pigs and poultry: Implications for the US veterinary profession. Animals 13, 140. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani13010140 (2023).
Mellor, D. J. Updating animal welfare thinking: Moving beyond the five freedoms towards a life worth living. Animals 6, 21. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani6030021 (2016).
Murray, A. G. & Murison, P. J. Complete tracheal obstruction during anaesthesia for ventral slot decompression surgery in a dog. Vet. Rec. Case Rep. 10, e461. https://doi.org/10.1002/vrc2.461 (2022).
Farrell, K. S. Control of breathing. In Small Animal Critical Care Medicine (Third Edition) (eds Silverstein, D. C. & Hopper, K.) 80–84 (W.B. Saunders, 2023).
Beausoleil, N. J. & Mellor, D. J. Introducing breathlessness as a significant animal welfare issue. N Z. Vet. J. 63, 44–51. https://doi.org/10.1080/00480169.2014.940410 (2015).
Banzett, R. B., Lansing, R. W. & Binks, A. P. Air hunger: A primal sensation and a primary element of dyspnea. Compr. Physiol. 11, 1449–1483. https://doi.org/10.1002/cphy.c200001 (2021).
Clarke, D. L. Upper airway disease. In Small Animal Critical Care Medicine (Third Edition) (eds Silverstein, D. C. & Hopper, K.) 101–112 (W.B. Saunders, 2023).
Ziemann, A. E. et al. The amygdala is a chemosensor that detects carbon dioxide and acidosis to elicit fear behavior. Cell 139, 1012–1021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2009.10.029 (2009).
McEwen, B. J. Strangulation, suffocation, and asphyxia. In Veterinary Forensic Pathology, Vol. 1 (ed Brooks, J. W.) 129–148 (Springer International Publishing, (2018).
Leary, S. et al. AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2020 Edition (American Veterinary Medical Association, 2020).
Ludders, J. W., Schmidt, R. H., Dein, F. J. & Klein, P. N. Drowning is not euthanasia. Wildl. Soc. Bull. 27 (Autumn), 666–670 (1999). http://www.jstor.org/stable/3784087
McEwen, B. J. & Gerdin, J. Veterinary forensic pathology: Drowning and bodies recovered from water. Vet. Pathol. 53, 1049–1056. https://doi.org/10.1177/0300985815625757 (2016).
Byard, R. W. Immersion deaths and drowning: Issues arising in the investigation of bodies recovered from water. Forensic Sci. Med. Pathol. 11, 323–325. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12024-014-9564-5 (2015).
Park, J. Y. et al. Foam-based depopulation methods of swine differ from water submersion based on computed tomography findings and postmortem lesions. Am. J. Vet. Res. 86 https://doi.org/10.2460/ajvr.25.01.0035 (2025).
World Health Organization. Drowning, https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/drowning (2024).
Arruda, A. G. et al. Reliability of water-based medium-expansion foam as a depopulation method for nursery pigs and cull sows. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 69, e2719–e2730. https://doi.org/10.1111/tbed.14622 (2022).
Capria, V. M. et al. Water-based medium-expansion foam depopulation of adult cattle. Transl. Anim. Sci. 7 https://doi.org/10.1093/tas/txad065 (2023).
Korenyi-Both, J. et al. Description of electroencephalographic data gathered using water-based medium-expansion foam as a depopulation method for nursery pigs. Sci. Rep. 12, 16798. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21353-7 (2022).
Kieffer, J. D. et al. Evaluation of a water-based medium-expansion foam depopulation method in suckling and finisher pigs. Animals 12, 1041 (2022).
Campler, M. R. et al. Refinement of water-based foam depopulation procedures for finisher pigs during field conditions: Welfare implications and logistical aspects. Prev. Vet. Med. 217, 105974. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2023.105974 (2023).
Rankin, M. K. et al. Comparison of water-based foam and carbon dioxide gas emergency depopulation methods of turkeys. Poult. Sci. 92, 3144–3148. https://doi.org/10.3382/ps.2013-03341 (2013).
Benson, E. R. et al. Mass emergency water-based foam depopulation of poultry. Avian Dis. 56, 891–896. https://doi.org/10.1637/10160-040912-Reg.1 (2012).
Benson, E. R., Alphin, R. L., Dawson, M. D. & Malone, G. W. Use of water-based foam to depopulate ducks and other species. Poult. Sci. 88, 904–910. https://doi.org/10.3382/ps.2008-00268 (2009).
Park, J. Y. et al. Perceptions of swine industry stakeholders on the use of water-based foam, high-expansion nitrogen foam, and carbon dioxide gas as methods of swine depopulation. Prev. Vet. Med. 233, 106356. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prevetmed.2024.106356 (2024).
Animal Welfare Institute. Higher-Welfare Farmed Animal Depopulation Methods: Information and Sources. https://awionline.org/sites/default/files/uploads/documents/awi-higher-welfare-farmed-animal-depopulation-methods.pdf (Animal Welfare Institute, 2025).
Nielsen, S. S. et al. Welfare of sheep and goats during killing for purposes other than slaughter. EFSA J. 22, e8835. https://doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2024.8835 (2024).
Funding
The authors received no external funding for this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Veterinary Association for Farm Animal Welfare (VAFAW), 333 West Brown Deer Rd. Unit G #481, Milwaukee, WI, 53217, USA
Gwendolen Reyes-Illg, Cheryl Kolus, Ellen P. Carlin, Katherine Brelje & Heather Mitchell
Philosophy Department, St. Bonaventure University, 3261 West State Street, St. Bonaventure, NY, 14778, USA
Katherine Brelje
Authors
- Gwendolen Reyes-Illg
- Cheryl Kolus
- Ellen P. Carlin
- Katherine Brelje
- Heather Mitchell
Contributions
GRI conceived the article; HM, CK, and GRI conducted analysis; GRI, CK, HM, and EPC wrote and edited the manuscript; KB contributed to article structure and editing.
Corresponding author
Correspondence to Gwendolen Reyes-Illg.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Reyes-Illg, G., Kolus, C., Carlin, E.P. et al. Animal welfare concerns regarding water-based foam used for depopulation of livestock. Sci Rep 16, 38944 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-80309-3
Received: 25 November 2025
Accepted: 05 November 2026
Published: 20 November 2026
Version of record: 20 November 2026
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-80309-3
来源:Nature 健康护理主题 · nature.com