跳到正文
原文
Medical Xpress·· 2026-10-21AI 评分16

“活动陷阱”:害怕失去福利正在阻止部分残疾人运动

The 'activity trap': Fear of losing benefits is stopping some disabled people from exercising

AI 导读

英国残疾人权利组织发布的报告指出,80%受访残疾人担忧身体活跃会导致福利被停发,这一“活动陷阱”现象阻碍了其运动意愿。调查显示,若确信福利不受影响,近3/4人愿意增加活动量;实际受益者中超四分之一曾因运动失去资助。评估过程中对孤立活动表现的过度强调及对波动性病情考虑不足,引发了受试者心理健康负面影响。

正文
disabled exercise
Credit: Kampus Production from Pexels

For some people with disabilities, going swimming or attending an exercise class comes with a worry that many others would never consider: Could being seen to be physically active lead to their disability benefits being stopped?

This fear is known as the activity trap. A new report published by Disability Rights UK draws on research I led at Durham University and developed with disabled people and disability organizations. Of the disabled people we surveyed, 80% worried that being physically active could put their benefits at risk.

Only one in five participants who had applied for or were receiving benefits were happy with how much physical activity they did. Nearly three-quarters said they would be more likely to increase their activity if they knew their benefits would not be affected.

Disabled people already face barriers to physical activity, including high costs and facilities that are difficult to access. Nearly 40% of disabled adults in England do less than 30 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity a week, according to Sport England. This means activity that makes someone breathe faster than usual, such as brisk walking. The proportion is almost twice that of nondisabled adults.

The activity trap was first highlighted in research published in 2018, when almost half of disabled respondents said they feared losing benefits if they were seen being active.

To explore how this fear affects people's lives, we surveyed more than 200 disabled people and held group discussions with more than 30 participants. We also examined relevant laws and legal cases.

Participants described feeling encouraged to exercise to manage their health while worrying that being active could be taken as evidence that they no longer needed financial support. One participant said, "I would love to go to the gym, every day, but I don't dare because I would be seen as being too physically fit."

Others worried about being reported for benefit fraud if someone saw them enjoying an activity in public.

More than one-quarter of participants who had applied for or were receiving benefits reported having benefits or other financial support removed because of physical activity. These findings describe participants' experiences; the survey alone cannot establish why individual benefit decisions were made.

How can physical activity affect benefits?

Much of our research focused on personal independence payment (PIP). This benefit helps with the extra costs of living with a disability or long-term health condition. People can receive it whether they work or not.

To decide who qualifies, officials assess how someone's condition affects everyday activities, such as preparing food, washing and moving around. Going to the gym does not automatically mean someone will lose their benefits. But evidence of physical activity may be considered when deciding what someone can do.

Under existing PIP guidance, assessors must consider whether someone can carry out an activity safely, to a reasonable standard, as often as needed and without taking an unusually long time. They must also consider conditions that vary from day to day.

Yet participants told us that assessors sometimes appeared to place too much emphasis on isolated examples of physical activity, without adequately considering the pain, fatigue or other difficulties they experienced.

Our examination of legal cases revealed similar problems. In one 2024 Upper Tribunal case, a decision about a man's entitlement to PIP had relied partly on observations of his ability to walk. However, the tribunal had failed to establish how far he could walk within a reasonable time, how frequently he needed to rest and whether he could repeat the activity. The Upper Tribunal ruled that the decision was legally flawed and ordered the case to be heard again.

The effects extended beyond physical activity. Of those who answered our survey question about the benefits application process, 84% said it had negatively affected their mental health. Some felt forced to concentrate on everything they could not do, while others said their own accounts or medical evidence were dismissed. The prospect of having to challenge a decision added to their anxiety.

What needs to change?

These findings come as the U.K. government reviews PIP. The Timms review has acknowledged that the current system can discourage physical activity and participation in community life.

Our report calls for better training for assessors, independent advice for people applying for benefits or challenging decisions, and greater involvement of disabled people and organizations led by them in designing the assessment system. These changes could help ensure decisions reflect the realities of living with a disability, including conditions that fluctuate.

A benefits system intended to support the independence of people with disabilities must recognize that occasionally being physically active does not mean someone no longer needs financial support. The challenge now is to ensure that this principle is reflected in how benefits decisions are made.

Who's behind this story?

Lisa Lock

Lisa Lock

BA art history, MA material culture. Former museum editor, paramedic, and transplant coordinator. Editing for Science X since 2021. Full profile →

Andrew Zinin

Andrew Zinin

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: The 'activity trap': Fear of losing benefits is stopping some disabled people from exercising (2026, October 21) retrieved 21 October 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-10-benefits-disabled-people.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com