UK食品和饮料监管系统仅识别出约一半加工/超加工食品为不健康食品
UK regulatory systems for food and drink identify only around half of processed/ultraprocessed products as unhealthy
研究发现,当前英国食品和饮料监管系统仅识别出约一半加工和超加工食品为不健康食品,这些食品含有过多的脂肪、盐、糖和能量密度。基于官方膳食指导的新营养评分模型则将超过90%的这些食品分类为不健康食品。研究人员建议采用统一的监管系统,以更好地符合官方膳食指导。
Current U.K. regulatory systems for food and drink identify only around half of processed and ultraprocessed products as unhealthy—in other words, those that contain excess fat, salt, sugar and energy density—finds research published in BMJ Medicine. But new nutrient profiling, based on official U.K. dietary guidance, classifies more than 90% of these products as unhealthy. A single unified regulatory system, using agreed definitions, that is aligned with this guidance may offer the best way forward, say the researchers.
The three systems used to identify unhealthy food and drink products in the U.K. and inform regulation and policy are The Eatwell Guide (official dietary guidance), the Food Standards Agency nutrient profiling model (FSA NPM) (regulation), and front-of-pack traffic lights labeling (regulation), explain the researchers.
But there are gaps and misalignments in the classification criteria of these systems, so that products rated as unhealthy by one aren't rated as unhealthy by another. But to date, no study has directly tested these inconsistencies, the researchers point out.
They therefore compared the nutrient content classifications of 262 processed items and 1,636 ultraprocessed items consumed by the general public from the nationally representative National Diet and Nutrition Survey database for Year 12 (2019–20).
Based on the official dietary Eatwell guidance, they constructed three new nutrient profiles to identify excess saturated fat, free sugar, salt (sodium), total fat and energy density in these processed and ultraprocessed products.
NPM1 identified excess saturated fat, free sugar and sodium; NPM2 identified excess saturated fat, free sugar, sodium and total fat; and NPM3 included all the components.
These were compared with each other and with the FSA and traffic light labeling systems.
U.K. dietary guidance includes recommendations for no more than 35%, 10%, 2% and 5% of total energy intake from total fat, saturated fat, trans fat and free sugars, respectively, and no more than 6 g/day of salt.
Analysis of the results revealed that the proportion of ultraprocessed and processed products identified as unhealthy differed significantly between the various nutrient profile systems.
The FSA model identified nearly 58% of ultraprocessed products and 50% of processed products as unhealthy, whereas the traffic lights labeling system identified less than half (just over 48%) of ultraprocessed products and processed products (46%) as unhealthy.
The new NPMs identified nearly twice as many ultraprocessed products as unhealthy: for NPM1, this figure was 91.5%; for NPM2, it was almost 95%; and for NPM3, it was almost 98%.
The researchers acknowledge that they didn't include minimally processed products in their analysis, and did capture foods in the traffic light labeling system that aren't labeled in the real world, because this system is voluntary.
Nevertheless, they conclude, "Food and drink products with excess content of harmful nutrients, according to U.K. government dietary guidance, were not identified by current systems for regulating U.K. food and drink products.
"Our new NPMs, based on current U.K. government dietary guidance, identified as unhealthy significantly greater proportions of processed and ultraprocessed products than the FSA NPM and the front-of-pack traffic lights labeling system."
In a linked editorial, Professor Franco Sassi and Dr. Shashika Rathnayaka of Imperial College, London, point out that product classification is only part of the policy problem.
"Policies mostly target products, but their goal is to improve diets overall. A greater dietary share of ultraprocessed foods is associated not only with poorer nutrient profiles but also with lower consumption of fruits, vegetables and legumes," they write.
"Policies may trigger substitution between foods, so their effects cannot be inferred from the number of products crossing a classification threshold. Evaluation should therefore consider purchasing and consumption, reformulation and substitution, and ultimately overall dietary patterns."
They continue, "The key question that governments must answer is whether nutrient-based, processing-based or combined approaches should be used to target food policies because each may result in different policy effects.
"Determining when nutrient quality or processing, or both, should guide policy must rely on evidence of the relevance, feasibility and reproducibility of different policy approaches, and on their effects on reformulation, food choices, substitution and dietary patterns."
Publication details
Evaluation of energy density and levels of fat, sugar, and salt in processed and ultra-processed food with existing and novel nutrient profiling models to identify unhealthy food and drink: cross sectional analysis of a nationally representative database of food and drink items, BMJ Medicine (2026). DOI: 10.1136/bmjmed-2025-001750
Journal information: BMJ Medicine
Who's behind this story?
Sadie Harley
BSc Life Sciences & Ecology. Microbiology lab background with pharmaceutical news experience in oil, gas, and renewable industries. Full profile →
Andrew Zinin
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
Citation: UK regulatory systems for food and drink identify only around half of processed/ultraprocessed products as unhealthy (2026, November 10) retrieved 10 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-uk-regulatory-food-processedultraprocessed-products.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com