跳到正文
原文
MedPage Today·· 2026-10-01AI 评分26

阿拉巴马等三州最高法院诉讼:挑战民主党州堕胎“盾牌法”

GOP States Challenge Democratic-Led States' Abortion 'Shield' Laws at Supreme Court

AI 导读

阿拉巴马、阿肯色和路易斯安那州总检察长向最高法院提起诉讼,挑战加州等三州保护堕胎提供者的“盾牌法”。该诉讼旨在阻止通过远程医疗和邮寄方式获取堕胎药丸,并追究异地提供者责任。若最高法院受理,可能绕过现有诉讼并影响州间堕胎法律执行。

正文

Three Republican states went to the Supreme Court on Wednesday to challenge abortion "shield laws" protecting providers in three Democratic states, escalating the legal conflict over pills that account for a majority of abortions.

The attorneys general of Alabama, Arkansas, and Louisiana contend that the laws in California, Massachusetts, and New York undermine their abortion bans and their states' sovereignty. Federal regulations allow prescriptions for abortion pills to be made by telehealth and filled by mail, and the three GOP states want to keep the pills out and punish out-of-state providers for sending them.

"This is the first time we've seen a state or group of states suing other states to challenge the validity of shield laws," said Mary Ziegler, a University of California Davis law professor and author of seven books on abortion law and history.

The Supreme Court can hear disputes between states directly, though it rarely does. If the top court weighs in, it could short-circuit existing lawsuits.

Louisiana and anti-abortion activists have been frustrated with a lack of federal action by President Donald Trump's administration against medication abortion. Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill sued the FDA over its rules allowing mail-order prescriptions. The Supreme Court in May preserved access to abortion medications as that case plays out.

"We need and deserve the opportunity to be able to enforce our laws against those who have chosen, despite their knowledge of the illegality, to continue to foster abortion in our state," Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall said during a news conference with Murrill and Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin.

Thirteen states ban abortion in all stages of pregnancy, which the Supreme Court allowed in its 2022 decision overturning Roe v. Wade. Most Democratic-controlled states adopted abortion protections, including eight with laws intended to protect providers who prescribe abortion pills for patients in states with bans.

Louisiana and Texas have pursued criminal charges and civil claims against doctors based in New York and California. Officials in California and New York have refused to cooperate, citing their shield laws.

"Louisiana, Alabama, and Arkansas are asking the Supreme Court to let them impose their abortion bans on New York and punish our doctors for providing legal healthcare," New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement Wednesday.

Ziegler said Alabama, Arkansas, and Louisiana would have a stronger case if they had first tried to get the highest court in one of the three other states to force its officials to cooperate. She also said the lawsuit's timing is odd -- 6 weeks before November congressional midterm elections that could prove difficult for the GOP.

"This may be an example of the political incentives not being the same for state-level Republicans versus federal Republicans," she said. "If you're running in a contested race, calling attention to abortion is not a great idea, but if you're Louisiana attorney general, you're not really in that position."

But Rachel Rebouche, a University of Texas law professor, said suing other states has been a potential legal strategy for GOP states since the first shield laws were enacted.

"That it's taken this long is kind of remarkable," she said.

Even before Roe was overturned, abortion pills were the most common means of ending pregnancies in the U.S., and telehealth makes abortion available even where it's banned. The three GOP attorneys general said hundreds of patients in their states use pills to end pregnancies each month.

Also on Wednesday, Alabama, Arkansas, and Louisiana filed a lawsuit against 30 out-of-state abortion pill providers and their officers, accusing them of false advertising and other misconduct harming patients in states with abortion bans.

FDA scientists have repeatedly found the regimen safe and effective, though the agency is now reviewing its rules.

来源:MedPage Today · medpagetoday.com