北卡罗来纳州社区心肺复苏和紧急医疗服务干预项目未显著提高心脏骤停后生存率
Community CPR and EMS intervention program did not increase survival after cardiac arrest
在北卡罗来纳州进行的一项为期五年的全面紧急医疗服务和社区教育干预项目未能显著提高心脏骤停后患者有良好脑功能的生存率。尽管心肺复苏(CPR)和自动体外除颤器(AED)的使用有所增加,但干预组和非干预组的生存率分别为9%和9.4%,差异无统计学意义。研究显示,持续的社区宣传可能有助于改善生存率。
A comprehensive emergency medical services and community-based educational intervention in North Carolina focused on recognizing out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and actions needed quickly to increase bystander CPR and use of an automated external defibrillator (AED) did not significantly improve patient survival with favorable brain function, according to new, independent, preliminary, late-breaking science presented Sunday at the American Heart Association's Scientific Sessions in Chicago.
"Your chance of survival while waiting for emergency medical services during a cardiac arrest decreases by 10% every minute without CPR," said study author Carolina Malta Hansen, M.D., Ph.D., a cardiologist and clinical research associate professor at Herlev and Gentofte Hospital and Copenhagen EMS in Denmark. "The RACE-CARS trial was an ambitious effort to improve cardiac arrest outcomes across entire communities, including rural areas where emergency care often relies on volunteer first responders."
The five-year trial included 60 counties in North Carolina that were randomly assigned to receive the cardiac arrest educational intervention or continue their existing cardiac arrest response practices. Researchers implemented a series of efforts aimed at improving early care and outcomes for people who experienced out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.
The intervention program included community-wide CPR education and training, and an EMS component that included training 911 dispatchers to quickly recognize cardiac arrest and guide callers through CPR, as well as enhanced first-responder efforts, including increased use of defibrillation before EMS arrival. The training was free and incorporated into schools, workplaces, county government and other community organizations.
Study's key findings
Cardiac arrests: Over the five-year study period, 11,615 people experienced out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in communities that received the educational intervention, and 10,844 people had cardiac arrest outside of a hospital in communities that did not receive the intervention.
Survival: About 9% of patients who experienced out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in communities that were part of the intervention program survived to leave the hospital with favorable brain function, compared with 9.4% in communities that were not part of the intervention program.
Bystander CPR: Bystanders performed CPR in 44.8% of cardiac arrests in communities that received the educational intervention, compared with 42.3% of cardiac arrests in communities that did not. Notably, during the last year of the study, people who experienced out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in communities that were part of the program had 33% higher odds of receiving CPR from a bystander than those in communities that were not.
Early defibrillation: Defibrillation occurred before emergency medical services (EMS) arrived in 13.5% of cardiac arrests in communities that received the educational intervention, compared with 15.3% of cardiac arrests in communities in the study that did not. Of the 31 counties that received a total of 405 trial-provided defibrillators, 26 counties (87%) deployed the devices; 19 (63%) placed defibrillators in publicly accessible locations; and 18 (60%) deployed defibrillators with first responders, including fire departments and law enforcement agencies.
Community participation: Community partners conducted 5,724 CPR training events, reaching 201,586 people, or 4.8% of residents in communities that were included in the educational intervention. Participation in the CPR training programs varied considerably, with four counties reaching more than 10% of residents and eight reaching fewer than 3%. Most counties also established systematic training of employees at workplaces such as county government, schools and large businesses.
Christopher Granger, M.D., FAHA, the trial principal investigator and a cardiologist and professor at Duke University in North Carolina, said, "The increase in bystander CPR toward the end of the study shows there was some effect and suggests that a sustained community outreach may be needed to show an improvement in survival. We have established an efficient, high-quality clinical trial network to continue this work."
"Changing how an entire community responds to cardiac arrest takes time, and our findings show just how challenging that can be. In the meantime, the message to the public remains simple: learn CPR, recognize the signs of cardiac arrest, call 911 immediately and follow the dispatcher's instructions. Everyone has the potential to save a life," said Hansen.
According to the American Heart Association's 2026 Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics, approximately 350,000 people in the U.S. experience cardiac arrest outside a hospital each year, and only about 1 in 10 survive. Immediate CPR can double or triple a person's chance of survival.
The association's comprehensive 2025 Guideline for CPR and emergency cardiovascular care emphasizes the importance of quickly recognizing cardiac arrest, calling 911, starting CPR and using an AED, a portable device that can help to restore a normal heart rhythm by delivering an electric shock through the chest, when available.
However, only about 40% of people who experience out-of-hospital cardiac arrest receive bystander CPR, and only 10% have an AED applied by a bystander before emergency medical services (EMS) arrive, according to the Heart Association's AED Fact Sheet.
Study details, background, design and limitations
The study was conducted from July 1, 2021, through June 30, 2026, in 60 counties throughout North Carolina, including urban and rural communities. The counties represented approximately 8.5 million residents, or nearly 80% of the state's population.
Researchers randomly assigned 31 of the counties to receive a comprehensive, community-based cardiac arrest response education program. The other 29 counties continued their own efforts and response to cardiac arrest without the education program from the RACE-CARS team.
The study included 22,459 adults ages 18 and older who experienced cardiac arrest outside of a hospital in all 60 counties over the five-year study period. The median age of cardiac arrest patients was 64 years; 37% were women, 33% were Black adults, and 29% lived in rural areas. Researchers excluded cardiac arrests witnessed by EMS personnel or occurring in hospitals, nursing homes or other health care facilities.
Researchers used the Cardiac Arrest Registry to Enhance Survival (CARES), a national database that includes data from 911, EMS and hospitals, to collect data and to evaluate whether patients survived to leave the hospital with favorable brain function, whether bystanders performed CPR and whether defibrillation occurred before EMS arrived. Local leaders, such as county commissioners and church leaders, were recruited to promote community efforts. Surveys were completed every six months to report on community CPR training, AED deployment and other aspects of how the education program was implemented.
Study limitations included differences in how extensively counties implemented the intervention program and reliance on self-reported information to assess 911 training, CPR training and first responder engagement. Staffing shortages and turnover at 911 centers created challenges for training and data collection. The COVID-19 pandemic and Hurricane Helene, which severely affected western North Carolina, also created operational challenges for the program.
A key strength of the study was its size, inclusiveness of the entire eligible population and the inclusion of both urban and rural communities, allowing researchers to evaluate the program across a broad range of typical emergency response settings. Hansen also emphasized the value of collaboration among local governments, community organizations, 911 centers and first responders.
She stressed that CPR education should be widely accessible through schools, workplaces and other community settings, and that strong first-responder programs are especially important in rural areas where EMS response times may be longer. Researchers suggested that reaching more people with CPR education and sustaining these efforts over time may be necessary to achieve changes in community response that could improve survival.
Who's behind this story?
Lisa Lock
BA art history, MA material culture. Former museum editor, paramedic, and transplant coordinator. Editing for Science X since 2021. Full profile →
Andrew Zinin
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
Citation: Community CPR and EMS intervention program did not increase survival after cardiac arrest (2026, November 9) retrieved 9 November 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-11-community-cpr-ems-intervention-survival.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com