Pistacia khinjuk油提升玉米-卡诺拉-芝麻煎炸油复配物在反复热处理下6个月储存的氧化稳定性
Pistacia khinjuk oil enhances oxidative stability of a corn-canola-sesame frying oil blend during six months of storage under repeated thermal treatment
Pistacia khinjuk油可提升玉米-卡诺拉-芝麻煎炸油复配物在反复热处理、6个月储存中的
The physicochemical properties of P.khinjuk oil including antioxidant and bioactive composition, GC analysis of fatty acid composition, and the frying oil blends, including acid value (AV), peroxide value (PV), anisidine value (AnV), iodine value (IV), moisture content, density, polar compounds, and oxidative stability (induction period), were evaluated monthly over a six-month storage period under thermal processing conditions. All results are presented as mean ± standard deviation, and statistical analysis (ANOVA, Duncan’s test, P < 0.05) revealed significant differences between treatments and across storage times (Fig. 4).
Antioxidant and bioactive composition of P. khinjuk oil
The antioxidant characteristics of P.khinjuk oil were evaluated prior to blending in order to clarify its contribution to the oxidative stability of the formulated frying oils19. The oil contained a considerable level of total phenolic compounds (117.18 mg GAE/kg oil) and total flavonoid compounds (194.8 mg QE/kg), indicating the presence of hydrogen-donating antioxidants capable of scavenging lipid-derived free radicals and delaying the propagation phase of lipid oxidation20. Consistently, DPPH radical scavenging activity reached 76.13%, while the IC₅₀ value was 14.03(mg/g), confirming a strong capacity for neutralizing reactive species21.
The tocopherol profile further supported the antioxidant potential of the oil. γ-Tocopherol was the predominant homolog (160.2 mg/kg), followed by α-tocopherol (9.6 mg/kg) and δ-tocopherol (1.6 mg/kg). Tocopherols function as chain-breaking antioxidants by donating hydrogen atoms to lipid peroxyl radicals, thereby terminating radical propagation reactions22. In particular, γ-tocopherol is known to exhibit high efficiency in trapping reactive nitrogen and oxygen species and contributes significantly to the oxidative stability of edible oils during thermal stress23.
Fatty acid composition of P.khinjuk oil
The fatty acid composition of P.khinjuk kernel oil was determined by GC–FID analysis, revealing a distinctive fatty acid profile characterized predominantly by monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs). Oleic acid (C18:1) constituted the largest proportion at 45.00%, followed by polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) such as linoleic acid (C18:2, 25.50%) and linolenic acid (C18:3, 5.60%). The saturated fatty acids (SFAs) palmitic (C16:0, 15.00%) and stearic acid (C18:0, 3.10%) accounted for a smaller portion of the profile (Table 2). The total MUFA content was 45.00%, while the total PUFA content was 31.10% and total SFA content was 18.10%. These results provide a comprehensive baseline for interpreting the oxidative behavior of the oil under thermal stress conditions.
Fatty acid structure and its influence on oxidative stability
The intrinsic resistance of edible oils to oxidative degradation is fundamentally governed by the molecular structure and degree of unsaturation of their constituent fatty acids2.
The fatty acid profile of P.khinjuk oil demonstrates a high proportion of monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA), particularly oleic acid, which is known to confer enhanced oxidative stability compared to polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs)26. MUFAs contain only one double bond, reducing the number of sites susceptible to free radical attack and chain propagation during lipid oxidation2. A high MUFA: PUFA ratio (~ 1.45 in P.khinjuk oil) is widely associated with improved resistance to thermal and storage oxidation because fewer bis-allylic methylene positions are available for hydrogen abstraction, the rate-limiting step in lipid peroxidation24.
PUFA balance and nutritional significance
Beyond oxidative considerations, the proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids plays a crucial dual role in determining both the nutritional value and the chemical stability of edible oils2. Although P.khinjuk oil contains a substantial proportion of PUFAs, particularly linoleic and linolenic acids, these fatty acids also contribute nutritional benefits. PUFAs are essential components of the human diet, playing important roles in membrane fluidity and physiological functions25. However, the presence of multiple double bonds inherently increases susceptibility to oxidation2. The observed moderate PUFA level, when juxtaposed with abundant MUFA content, provides a balanced profile that supports both nutritional value and stability.
Role of fatty acid composition in thermal oxidative behavior
Under high-temperature conditions, the susceptibility of lipids to thermal oxidation is strongly dictated by the number and position of double bonds within fatty acid chains2. In thermally processed oils, fatty acid composition significantly influences primary and secondary oxidation kinetics24. Oils enriched in MUFAs such as oleic acid have been reported to exhibit higher induction periods and lower peroxide values under accelerated oxidation conditions compared with oils with higher PUFA content26. Given that radical initiation and propagation rates are influenced by the number of double bonds, the predominance of oleic acid in P.khinjuk oil likely contributes to slower hydroperoxide formation and reduced progression to secondary oxidation products.
Synergistic interaction between fatty acids and endogenous antioxidants
The oxidative stability of complex lipid systems is not solely dependent on fatty acid composition but is markedly enhanced by synergistic interactions with naturally occurring antioxidant compounds20. It is also critical to consider that fatty acid composition does not act in isolation. The oxidative stability of P.khinjuk oil is further enhanced by its rich endogenous antioxidant content, including tocopherols and phenolic compounds. These antioxidants can donate hydrogen atoms to quench lipid radicals and interrupt the chain reactions of peroxidation20.
Therefore, while the fatty acid profile provides a structural basis for stability, the synergistic interaction between a high MUFA fraction and robust antioxidant defenses produces the observed resistance to oxidative degradation under thermal stress.
Acid value (AV)
Acid value (AV), a marker of hydrolytic degradation, remained remarkably stable in oils enriched with P.khinjuk compared to the control throughout the six-month thermal storage period (Table 3). The control sample (TK0) exhibited the highest AV at all time points (0.42%), whereas the TK20 blend maintained the lowest value (0.056%) with no significant change over time (P > 0.05). Intermediate formulations (TK15, TK10, TK5) showed progressively higher AVs (0.14%, 0.26%, and 0.36%, respectively), demonstrating a clear concentration-dependent protective effect of P. khinjuk oil. Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments at each sampling point (P < 0.05) (Fig. 1).
Values are mean ± SD (n = 3). Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters indicate no statistically significant difference (P ≥ 0.05) See fig 1.
Changes in the acid value of the oil mixture resulting from the addition of varying amounts of P.Khinjuk oil during the heating process and storage duration.
Hydrolytic stability of oils enriched with P.khinjuk
Acid value reflects the formation of free fatty acids resulting from triglyceride hydrolysis, a reaction accelerated by heat and trace moisture2. The markedly lower AV in P. khinjuk-enriched oils indicates that incorporation of this oil effectively inhibited hydrolytic deterioration during repeated thermal exposure.
This protective effect can be attributed to two complementary mechanisms. First, the high antioxidant content of P.khinjuk oil, particularly tocopherols and phenolic compounds, may stabilize lipid radicals formed during early oxidation stages, thereby reducing secondary reactions that promote ester bond cleavage20. Oxidative and hydrolytic degradation pathways are closely interconnected; suppression of radical formation indirectly limits triglyceride breakdown19.
Second, the fatty acid profile of P.khinjuk oil, characterized by a high MUFA content (notably oleic acid), contributes to structural resistance against thermal degradation. Monounsaturated lipids are less prone to oxidative fragmentation compared to polyunsaturated fatty acids, leading to reduced formation of reactive intermediates that catalyze hydrolysis19.
The absence of significant AV increase in TK20 suggests that the antioxidant system of P. khinjuk oil provided sustained protection throughout storage, whereas the control oil, lacking this protective matrix, remained more susceptible to ester bond cleavage under thermal stress.
Peroxide value (PV)
Peroxide value (PV), an established indicator of primary lipid oxidation, increased progressively in all oil formulations over the six-month storage period under thermal treatment (Table 4; Fig. 2). In the control (TK0), PV rose from 3.40 ± 0.00 meq O₂/kg at month 1 to 7.60 ± 0.11 meq O₂/kg at month 6, reflecting continuous oxidative deterioration under repeated high-temperature exposure. Conversely, blends enriched with P.khinjuk oil exhibited significantly lower PV values throughout the study. The TK20 formulation (20% P.khinjuk oil) maintained the lowest PV, increasing from 0.70 ± 0.03 to 5.30 ± 0.05 meq O₂/kg over six months, indicating a substantial retardation of primary oxidation relative to the control. Intermediate blends (TK15, TK10, TK5) demonstrated graded protection, with final PVs of 5.70 ± 0.01, 6.50 ± 0.08, and 7.00 ± 0.06 meq O₂/kg, respectively, consistent with a concentration-dependent antioxidant effect.
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments at each sampling point (P < 0.05). Correlation analysis demonstrated a strong negative relationship between P. khinjuk oil concentration and PV progression over time (r = − 0.87, P < 0.01), supporting a dose-dependent suppression of primary oxidation by the plant-derived oil (Fig. 2).
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), whereas different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05).
Changes in the peroxide value (meq kg⁻¹) of the oil mixture resulting from the addition of varying amounts of P.Khinjuk oil during the heating process and storage duration.
Mechanistic interpretation of peroxide formation
Peroxide value quantifies the accumulation of lipid hydroperoxides, the first detectable products in lipid oxidation initiated by radical chain reactions2. Under thermal stress, hydrogen abstraction from unsaturated fatty acids generates carbon-centered radicals that react with molecular oxygen to form peroxyl radicals and subsequently hydroperoxides19. Thus, elevated PV reflects active free radical propagation and is widely used to monitor early oxidation in edible oils2.
The marked increase in PV observed in the control group (TK0) over time is consistent with this mechanism, as continuous heating at elevated temperatures accelerates radical formation and hydroperoxide accumulation in the absence of sufficient antioxidant defenses. Similar patterns have been documented in studies of thermally stressed vegetable oils, where PV increases sharply during the initial oxidation phase before secondary decomposition products dominate27.
Protective role of P.khinjuk oil
The significantly lower PV values in P.khinjuk-enriched blends indicate effective inhibition of primary oxidation. Natural antioxidants present in P.khinjuk oil — notably tocopherols (α and γ) and phenolic compounds — can donate hydrogen atoms to lipid peroxyl radicals, forming more stable products and interrupting the propagation sequence of lipid oxidation20,28,29. This chain-breaking antioxidant activity reduces the formation rate and accumulation of hydroperoxides, leading to lower PV accumulation in blends with higher P.khinjuk oil content20.
In addition to radical scavenging, the fatty acid composition of P.khinjuk oil contributes to oxidative resistance. A high content of oleic acid (monounsaturated) confers intrinsic stability against oxidation relative to polyunsaturated fatty acids, which possess multiple bis-allylic sites prone to hydrogen abstraction30,31. Although P.khinjuk oil contains a relevant fraction of polyunsaturated fatty acids, the predominance of monounsaturated moieties, supported by an effective antioxidant matrix, results in synergistic protection.
Concentration-dependent antioxidant effect
The concentration-dependent suppression of PV (TK20 < TK15 < TK10 < TK5 < TK0) observed in this study aligns with previous investigations showing enhanced oxidative stability with increasing levels of antioxidant enrichments in oil blends. Higher proportions of P.khinjuk oil likely supply greater quantities of phenolic and tocopherol antioxidants, effectively extending the induction time of lipid peroxidation and lowering the net accumulation of hydroperoxides20,2.
Anisidine value (AnV)
Anisidine value (AnV), an established indicator of secondary oxidation products including α,β-unsaturated aldehydes, exhibited a clear progression over the six-month thermal storage period (Table 5; Fig. 3). The control (TK0) showed a consistent rise from 2.04 ± 0.02 at month 1 to 4.50 ± 0.23 at month 6, reflecting substantial accumulation of aldehydic oxidative products. In contrast, the TK20 blend (20% P.khinjuk oil) maintained the highest AnV values across all sampling points, increasing from 3.46 ± 0.06 to 5.60 ± 0.02 over six months.
Intermediate blends (TK15, TK10, TK5) exhibited graded increases, with final values of 5.28 ± 0.09, 5.17 ± 0.00 and 4.96 ± 0.05, respectively, indicating a concentration-dependent change in secondary oxidation behavior among the enriched samples. Although the percent increase in AnV for TK20 (≈ 62.2%) appears numerically comparable to that of the control (≈ 119.6%), the overall interpretation of secondary oxidation in this study relies primarily on the absolute AnV values rather than percentage changes.
It should be noted that the percentage increase in AnV may appear higher in samples with initially low values, even though their absolute AnV levels remain lower than those of samples exhibiting more advanced secondary oxidation. Therefore, interpretation of AnV trends in this study prioritizes absolute values, while percentage changes are used only to illustrate the rate of increase relative to the baseline.
Although TK20 contained a higher endogenous antioxidant content, its AnV remained higher than that of the control during storage. This observation is consistent with the fact that AnV is an indicator of secondary oxidation products, including α,β-unsaturated aldehydes, whereas the antioxidant system in TK20, although effective as chain-breaking antioxidants, mainly suppresses radical propagation and primary oxidation. In addition, the relatively high unsaturated fatty acid content, particularly oleic acid, may have increased susceptibility to secondary oxidation pathways.
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among all enriched samples and the control at corresponding time points (P < 0.05), with distinct lowercase superscripts within columns and uppercase superscripts within rows denoting inter-treatment and temporal differences, respectively (Fig. 3).
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), whereas different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05).
Changes in the anisidine index of the oil mixture resulting from the addition of varying amounts of Kunjuje oil during the heating process and storage duration.
Secondary oxidation and anisidine value
Anisidine value quantifies aldehydic secondary oxidation products — primarily 2-alkenals and 2,4-dienals — formed during propagation and breakdown of hydroperoxides32,33. Elevated AnV indicates extensive degradation of primary oxidation products and reflects accumulation of low-molecular-weight, potentially cytotoxic carbonyl compounds. These aldehydic species are of particular interest because they contribute to off-flavors and may possess greater health risk than hydroperoxides alone2,34.
Total oxidation value (TOTOX)
The TOTOX index, which integrates primary (peroxide value) and secondary (anisidine value) oxidation products, is considered a comprehensive indicator of the overall oxidative status of edible oils. As shown in Fig. 4, TOTOX values increased progressively during storage in all treatments, reflecting the cumulative nature of lipid oxidation under repeated thermal exposure. However, oils enriched with P.khinjuk oil exhibited a significantly slower increase in TOTOX compared with the control (TK0). By the sixth month, the control sample reached the highest TOTOX value (≈ 19.7), whereas the oil containing 20% P.khinjuk (TK20) showed the lowest value (≈ 16.2). This reduction of nearly 18% in total oxidation demonstrates the protective effect of P.khinjuk oil against both hydroperoxide formation and their decomposition into aldehydic compounds.
The inhibitory effect can be attributed to the presence of tocopherols and phenolic antioxidants in P.khinjuk oil, which interrupt the lipid oxidation chain reaction by donating hydrogen atoms to lipid peroxyl radicals and stabilizing them into less reactive species20. Similar reductions in TOTOX values have been reported when antioxidant-rich oils were blended with conventional frying oils, confirming that natural phenolics can effectively delay both initiation and propagation phases of lipid oxidation27 See table 6.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), and different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05).
Changes in the total oxidation value (TOTOX = 2PV + AnV) of frying oil blends containing different concentrations of P.khinjuk oil (0–20%) during six months of storage under repeated thermal treatment (170 °C for 48 min each month). Values are presented as mean ± SD (n = 3).
Integrated oxidative status via TOTOX
The TOTOX index is widely accepted as a comprehensive measure of oxidative deterioration in edible oils, combining the contributions of hydroperoxides (PV) and aldehydic secondary oxidation products (AnV) to present a holistic picture of lipid oxidation. While PV reflects early oxidative events, TOTOX captures the entire course of oxidation, including decomposition pathways that lead to potentially toxic by-products24,27.
Effect of P.khinjuk oil on TOTOX
The significantly lower TOTOX values in P.khinjuk-enriched blends align with the established antioxidant roles of endogenous phenolics and tocopherols, which confer multi-stage protection against lipid oxidation. These compounds can quench free radicals, interrupt propagation reactions, and stabilize hydroperoxides, thereby reducing the cumulative oxidative burden captured by TOTOX20.
Mechanistic interpretation
Under thermal stress, lipid radicals propagate oxidation chain reactions, forming hydroperoxides that can either accumulate or decompose into aldehydes and ketones. The TOTOX index, by integrating PV and AnV, captures this shift from primary to secondary oxidation. Addition of natural antioxidants from P.khinjuk oil appears to slow both the formation of primary peroxides and their subsequent decomposition, resulting in a reduced TOTOX trajectory over time.
Oils with higher levels of tocopherols and phenolic compounds have previously demonstrated lower TOTOX values under similar conditions, corroborating the dual role of these bioactives in counteracting both initiation and propagation phases of lipid oxidation2,35.
Integrated oxidation index (INTOX)
The Integrated Oxidation Index (INTOX) increased progressively in all treatments throughout the six-month storage period, confirming the cumulative nature of lipid oxidation under repeated thermal exposure. However, the magnitude of increase differed significantly among formulations (Table 7).
The control sample (TK0) showed the highest INTOX values at all storage times, reaching 13.00 at month 6. In contrast, oils enriched with P.khinjuk exhibited consistently lower values, with the TK20 formulation displaying the lowest final INTOX (12.02). Intermediate blends (TK5, TK10, and TK15) showed values between these extremes, demonstrating a clear concentration-dependent protective effect (Fig. 6).
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), with P.khinjuk-enriched samples exhibiting lower integrated oxidation levels than the control during later storage stages.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), and different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05 ).
Changes in Intox of oil blends during six months of thermal storage. Oils containing P.khinjuk oil exhibited slower accumulation of polar degradation products compared with the control
The consistently lower INTOX values in P.khinjuk-enriched oils confirm that P.khinjuk oil mitigates overall oxidative deterioration by modulating both primary peroxide formation and secondary aldehydic breakdown during prolonged thermal storage (See fig 5).
INTOX represents the combined burden of primary hydroperoxides and their transformation into secondary carbonyl compounds, providing an integrated reflection of oxidative deterioration27. The significantly lower INTOX values observed in TK15 and TK20 indicate that P.khinjuk oil not only slows hydroperoxide formation but also moderates their subsequent decomposition into reactive aldehydes24.
This dual protection can be attributed to the synergistic antioxidant system of P.khinjuk oil:
-
1.
Tocopherols act as chain-breaking antioxidants, donating hydrogen atoms to lipid peroxyl radicals and interrupting propagation reactions20.
-
2.
Phenolic compounds further stabilize radical intermediates and may chelate pro-oxidant metal ions, reducing catalytic decomposition of hydroperoxides28.
Because INTOX weights both oxidation stages, the reduced values in enriched blends confirm that the protective action of P.khinjuk oil extends beyond initial peroxide suppression and influences the overall oxidative pathway2. The dose-dependent decline in INTOX strongly supports its role as a multifunctional natural stabilizer in thermally stressed oil systems35.
Iodine value (IV)
The iodine value (IV), an indicator of the degree of unsaturation in oils, declined progressively in all treatments during the six-month storage period, confirming oxidative consumption of double bonds under repeated thermal exposure (Table 8; Fig. 6).
The control oil (TK0) exhibited the most pronounced reduction, decreasing from 123.0 to 87.0 g I₂/100 g, reflecting extensive degradation of unsaturated fatty acids. In contrast, P.khinjuk-enriched oils retained higher IV values throughout storage. The TK20 formulation showed the greatest preservation of unsaturation, with IV decreasing from 102.0 to 88.0 g I₂/100 g, indicating improved resistance of double bonds to oxidative attack.
Intermediate treatments (TK5, TK10, TK15) displayed moderate declines, demonstrating a concentration-dependent protective effect of P.khinjuk oil. Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments and storage times (P < 0.05), highlighting the stabilizing influence of P.khinjuk oil on fatty acid integrity.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments at the same storage time (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant changes over storage time within the same treatment (P < 0.05).
Changes in iodine value of oil blends during six months of thermal storage. Oils containing P.khinjuk oil exhibited slower accumulation of polar degradation products compared with the control.
The decrease in iodine value during storage reflects the oxidative depletion of carbon–carbon double bonds, primarily in polyunsaturated fatty acids, which are highly susceptible to radical-mediated peroxidation2. The sharper decline observed in the control oil indicates accelerated lipid oxidation and structural breakdown of unsaturated fatty acids under thermal stress.
The improved IV retention in P.khinjuk-enriched oils can be explained by the antioxidant composition of P.khinjuk oil. Tocopherols act as chain-breaking antioxidants, terminating lipid peroxyl radicals before they propagate oxidation at double-bond sites20. Phenolic compounds further contribute by stabilizing radical intermediates and reducing the formation of reactive oxygen species28. By limiting radical attack on unsaturated acyl chains, these compounds help preserve the structural integrity of fatty acids, which is reflected in the higher residual IV values.
The concentration-dependent trend supports the hypothesis that P.khinjuk oil enhances oxidative resistance not only by reducing peroxide formation but also by protecting the underlying unsaturated lipid matrix35. Similar preservation of iodine value has been reported when antioxidant-rich oils or extracts were incorporated into thermally stressed vegetable oils, where phenolic antioxidants slowed the depletion of double bonds during storage and heating27.
The better retention of iodine value in P.khinjuk-enriched oils confirms that P.khinjuk oil protects unsaturated fatty acids from oxidative degradation, thereby contributing to improved structural and oxidative stability during prolonged thermal storage.
Polar compounds
The percentage of polar compounds, a critical indicator of oil degradation, increased progressively in all oil blends during the six-month storage period (Table 13; Fig. 7). The control sample (TK0) exceeded the commonly accepted safety threshold of 10% after six months (10.2%), indicating significant oxidative and thermal degradation. In contrast, the TK20 blend (20% P.khinjuk oil) demonstrated the lowest accumulation of polar materials, remaining well below the safety limit at 9.2%. Intermediate formulations (TK15, TK10, TK5) exhibited moderate increases, with final values of 9.8%, indicating delayed formation of polar degradation products.
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments over time (P < 0.05). The slower formation of polar compounds in P.khinjuk-enriched oils suggests effective mitigation of oxidative and polymerization pathways responsible for the formation of high-molecular-weight degradation products.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments at the same storage time (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant changes over storage time within the same treatment (P < 0.05).
Changes in polar compounds (%) of oil blends during six months of thermal storage. Oils containing P.khinjuk oil exhibited slower accumulation of polar degradation products compared with the control.
Polar compounds are complex products arising from lipid oxidation, thermal polymerization, and hydrolysis reactions. Their formation reflects the breakdown and recombination of fatty acid chains into more polar species, including oxidized monomers, dimers, oligomers, and cyclic compounds, which collectively diminish oil quality and safety24,36. Regulatory limits for polar compounds (often ~ 10%) are established because elevated levels correlate with off-flavors, nutritional loss, and potential toxic effects.
The significantly lower polar content in P.khinjuk-enriched blends can be attributed to the synergistic antioxidant architecture of P.khinjuk oil:
Mechanistic Insights.
-
1.
Radical scavenging
Tocopherols and phenolic compounds intercept lipid radicals, inhibiting propagation and reducing the formation of oxidized monomers that lead to polar compounds20,28.
-
2.
Prevention of polymerization
By stabilizing peroxyl and alkoxyl intermediates, antioxidants limit cross-linking reactions that form high-molecular-weight polar oligomers36.
-
3.
Structural protection
The fatty acid profile of P.khinjuk oil — particularly its relatively high monounsaturated fraction — is inherently less susceptible to radical attack than polyunsaturated fatty acids, further slowing degradation pathways that produce polar materials30.
Moisture content
Moisture content showed a slight but consistent increase during the six-month storage period in all oil formulations (Table 14; Fig. 8). The control sample (TK0) exhibited the highest moisture level throughout storage, reaching 0.0416% at month 6. In contrast, oils containing P.khinjuk oil retained significantly lower moisture levels, with TK20 showing the lowest final value (0.0247%). Intermediate blends (TK15, TK10, TK5) displayed gradual increases proportional to the reduction in P.khinjuk oil content.
Statistical analysis indicated significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), with enriched oils consistently maintaining lower moisture than the control at corresponding storage times.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments at the same storage time (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant changes over storage time within the same treatment (P < 0.05).
Changes in the moisture content (%) of the oil mixture resulting from the addition of varying amounts of P.Khinjuk oil during the heating process and storage duration.
Although the absolute moisture values remained low (< 0.05%), even trace amounts of water can markedly influence lipid stability. Water acts as a catalyst in hydrolytic reactions, promoting the cleavage of ester bonds in triacylglycerols and leading to the formation of free fatty acids, which in turn accelerate oxidative deterioration2,24,38.
The significantly lower moisture levels observed in P.khinjuk-enriched oils suggest improved resistance to water uptake or retention during repeated thermal exposure. Several mechanisms may explain this protective effect:
Hydrophobic matrix effect
P.Khinjuk oil contains a high proportion of non-polar lipophilic components, including tocopherols and sterol derivatives, which may enhance the hydrophobic character of the oil matrix and reduce water solubility and dispersion within the lipid phase. Reduced water availability limits hydrolytic cleavage of triglycerides, thereby indirectly slowing oxidative degradation20,39.
Antioxidant–moisture interaction
Phenolic antioxidants can stabilize interfacial regions where water and lipids interact, decreasing the formation of pro-oxidant conditions typically promoted by water-mediated metal ion activity40. By limiting pro-oxidant interactions, P.khinjuk oil may reduce both moisture-induced hydrolysis and secondary oxidation processes.
Correlation with acid value
The moisture trend aligns closely with the acid value results, where TK20 also showed the lowest increase in free fatty acids. This supports the established relationship between moisture, hydrolysis, and acidity development in thermally stressed oils41.
Even minor increases in moisture can accelerate hydrolytic and oxidative deterioration in edible oils; therefore, the lower moisture retention observed in P.khinjuk-enriched blends likely contributed to their reduced free fatty acid formation and improved oxidative stability during prolonged thermal exposure20,42.
Density
Density of the oil blends decreased gradually during the six-month storage period across all treatments (Table 15; Fig. 9). Initially, no significant differences were observed between formulations, with values closely clustered around 0.910–0.923 g/cm³. However, by month 6, the control sample (TK0) exhibited the lowest density (0.903 ± 0.003 g/cm³), whereas the TK20 formulation (20% P.khinjuk oil) retained the highest density (0.920 ± 0.003 g/cm³). Intermediate blends (TK15, TK10, TK5) displayed values between these extremes, with TK15 remaining relatively stable at ~ 0.920 g/cm³ and TK10 showing consistent densities near 0.916 g/cm³ throughout storage.
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences at month 6 between enriched treatments and the control (P < 0.05), indicating that P.khinjuk oil concentration influenced the extent of density reduction during thermal storage.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05).
Changes in the density (g/cm³) of the oil mixture resulting from the addition of varying amounts of P.khinjuk oil during the heating process and storage duration.
Density as a quality indicator
Density of edible oils is a sensitive indicator of molecular changes induced by oxidation and thermal degradation. Lipid oxidation, hydrolysis, and polymerization reactions alter the molecular weight distribution of triglycerides and their derivatives, leading to the formation of smaller fragments (e.g., volatile compounds) and larger polar or polymeric species. These transformations often reduce the average density of oil due to the increasing proportion of low-density oxidation products and volatile fractions2,24,43.
Effect of thermal oxidation
The gradual decrease in density observed in all treatments reflects these cumulative chemical changes. The control (TK0) underwent the most pronounced decline, consistent with its higher peroxide, anisidine, and polar compound values, indicating extensive molecular breakdown and formation of lower-density oxidation by-products24.
Protective role of P.khinjuk oil
Oils enriched with P.khinjuk oil, particularly TK20, showed attenuated density decreases, suggesting better structural preservation under thermal stress. Several mechanisms likely contribute to this effect:
Antioxidant protection
Natural antioxidants in P.khinjuk oil (tocopherols and phenolics) inhibit radical chain reactions, reducing the formation of low-density volatile products and limiting extensive molecular fragmentation.
Reduced hydrolytic degradation
Lower moisture levels and antioxidant protection correlate with reduced triglyceride hydrolysis, minimizing the generation of free fatty acids and other low-molecular-weight species that lower density.
Limited polymerization
Inhibition of oxidative polymerization reduces the formation of large high-molecular-weight compounds that can also alter density patterns, maintaining a more stable molecular distribution.
Previous studies have demonstrated that density changes in thermally oxidized oils are associated with oxidation severity and can be mitigated by antioxidants. Oils enriched with natural antioxidants generally retain higher densities compared to controls under identical thermal stress, reflecting lower extents of degradation20,44.
Oxidative stability (Induction period)
The induction period (IP), determined by the Rancimat method, increased markedly with rising P.khinjuk oil concentration (Table 16; Fig. 10). At the beginning of storage, TK20 exhibited the longest induction period (18.52 ± 0.01 h), which remained remarkably stable throughout the six-month period (18.39 ± 0.00 h at month 6).
In contrast, the control sample (TK0) showed the shortest oxidative stability, with values close to 14 h and only minimal fluctuations during storage. Intermediate blends (TK5, TK10, TK15) displayed induction periods proportional to P.khinjuk oil concentration, with TK15 maintaining ~ 15.1 h and TK10 ~ 15.0 h across the study.
Statistical analysis confirmed significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), with TK20 showing consistently higher induction periods than all other formulations. Temporal changes within each treatment were minimal, indicating that antioxidant protection persisted despite repeated thermal exposure.
Different lowercase letters within each column indicate significant differences among treatments (P < 0.05), while different uppercase letters within each row indicate significant differences over storage time (P < 0.05). Identical letters denote no significant difference (P ≥ 0.05).
Changes in oxidative stability (Rancimat induction period) of oil samples containing different levels of P.khinjuk oil during six months of storage. Values are expressed as mean ± SD.
Induction period as an oxidative stability marker
The Rancimat induction period reflects the resistance of oils to rapid oxidation under accelerated conditions. A longer IP indicates a longer lag phase before exponential formation of volatile secondary oxidation products, and therefore greater oxidative stability2,27.
Effect of P.khinjuk oil
The substantial increase in induction period observed in TK20 demonstrates that P.khinjuk oil provides strong oxidative protection. The nearly unchanged IP over six months suggests that the antioxidant system in this oil remains active even after repeated heating cycles.
This stability is attributed to:
-
High γ-tocopherol content — effective chain-breaking antioxidant that scavenges lipid peroxyl radicals45.
-
Phenolic compounds — donate hydrogen atoms and regenerate tocopherols46.
-
Synergistic antioxidant interactions — delay the transition from the initiation to propagation phase of lipid oxidation20.
Dose-dependent protection
The progressive increase in IP from TK5 → TK10 → TK15 → TK20 confirms a concentration-dependent stabilization effect. This behavior supports the concept that natural antioxidant-rich oils can enhance the oxidative resistance of refined frying oils when used as blending components20.
Thermal stability of the antioxidant system
Unlike many natural antioxidants that degrade rapidly under heat, the antioxidants in P.khinjuk oil appear relatively heat-stable, as indicated by the minimal decline in IP over time. Similar stability has been reported for oils rich in γ-tocopherol and phenolic constituents under accelerated oxidation conditions20,47.
The sustained high induction period of P.khinjuk-enriched oils, particularly TK20, demonstrates that P.khinjuk oil functions as a thermally resilient natural antioxidant system capable of significantly extending the oxidative shelf life of frying oils.
Saponification number
The saponification number did not show significant changes among treatments or during the storage period (P ≥ 0.05). This indicates that the average molecular weight of fatty acids and the glyceride structure of the oils remained largely unaffected by thermal treatment and storage48. Since saponification value reflects the ester bond integrity of triglycerides, the stability observed suggests that hydrolytic cleavage of glycerides was minimal under the applied experimental conditions2.
The absence of significant changes in the saponification number (SN) across treatments and storage time indicates that the fundamental triglyceride structure of the oils remained intact under the applied thermal oxidation conditions24. The saponification value primarily reflects the average molecular weight of fatty acids esterified to glycerol; therefore, any substantial hydrolytic cleavage of ester bonds would have resulted in detectable alterations in SN49.
Lipid oxidation during thermal processing predominantly targets double bonds in unsaturated fatty acids, leading to the formation of hydroperoxides, aldehydes, ketones, and polymerized products rather than direct scission of the glycerol–fatty acid ester linkage27. Consequently, while oxidation indices such as peroxide value (PV), anisidine value (AnV), and total polar compounds increased during storage, the ester backbone of triglycerides remained largely unaffected50.
The stability of SN suggests that hydrolytic degradation was minimal, likely due to the low moisture content and the absence of food matrix interactions, which are major drivers of hydrolysis in real frying systems50. This observation aligns with previous reports indicating that thermal oxidation under low-moisture conditions primarily induces oxidative, rather than hydrolytic, deterioration of lipids24.
Furthermore, the incorporation of P.khinjuk oil, rich in tocopherols and phenolic antioxidants, may have indirectly contributed to preserving triglyceride integrity by limiting radical propagation reactions that could otherwise accelerate secondary breakdown processes20. Similar findings have been reported in antioxidant-enriched oil systems, where oxidative stability improved without significant changes in saponification value44.
来源:Nature 健康护理主题 · nature.com