Neiman研究所评论质疑美国影像使用下降及放射科人力充足的说法
New commentary challenges outdated claims about imaging use and the radiologist workforce
美国Harvey L. Neiman卫生政策研究所发表评论,质疑JAMA Health Forum一篇2026年文章所称影像使用下降使美国无需增加放射科医生即可满足需求的说法。
A new commentary from the Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute challenges a recent claim that declining imaging use has allowed the United States to meet imaging demand without increasing the number of radiologists. The institute argues that the claim—made in a 2026 JAMA Health Forum article—relies on outdated utilization data and overlooks a growing body of evidence showing increasing imaging volume and complexity, rising radiologist workload and worsening capacity constraints.
The first author of the JAMA article was David Cutler, Ph.D., a Harvard economist and dean and former White House economic adviser.
"In health care policy, influential observations can quickly become accepted wisdom, making it critically important to ensure they are grounded in the best available evidence," said Elizabeth Rula, Ph.D., executive director of the Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute.
"The Neiman Institute and its collaborators have published much of the recent research on imaging utilization, workforce trends, reimbursement and patient access. Collectively, that evidence paints a very different picture from one of declining demand and adequate workforce capacity."
The commentary notes the JAMA article relied heavily on a study examining imaging utilization from 2003 through 2016. While that study documented a slowdown in imaging growth during part of that period, it did not examine recent utilization patterns or radiologist workload. It also coincided with Medicare coding changes that affected how imaging services were counted.
"Our study provided an important historical perspective on Medicare imaging claims through 2016, but health care delivery and imaging practice have evolved substantially since then," said Vijay Rao, M.D., emeritus endowed David C. Levin professor and chair at Thomas Jefferson University and co-author of the primary study cited in the JAMA article.
"Findings from that time period should not be interpreted as evidence that imaging demand or radiologist workload is declining today, particularly when more recent data show continued growth in advanced imaging and examination complexity."
The commentary highlights several recent studies that show imaging demand remains strong. Research projects imaging utilization will continue to grow in the coming decades, driven largely by population growth and aging. Medicare data also show substantial increases in CT and MRI use since 2016.
Meanwhile, radiologist workload, measured using relative value units that account for exam complexity, increased over time and reached historic highs in recent years.
Additional indicators suggest growing strain on the imaging system. Recent research by the institute found that imaging turnaround time—between imaging acquisition and interpretation—increased dramatically during the past decade, with most of the increase occurring in the last several years. Other studies documented rising radiologist turnover associated with workload pressures.
"Accurate workforce planning depends on accurately understanding demand," said co-author Richard Duszak Jr., M.D., professor of radiology at the University of Central Florida College of Medicine and chair emeritus of the University of Mississippi School of Medicine's department of radiology.
"If policymakers or health care leaders are led to believe that imaging demand is shrinking or that radiology capacity is sufficient, they may underestimate emerging access challenges and the need for evidence-based workforce planning. At the same time, we must continue efforts to reduce truly inappropriate imaging and ensure patients receive the right examination at the right time."
Commentary authors emphasize their concern is not simply academic. Policy decisions about reimbursement, workforce development and imaging utilization directly affect patient access to care.
The commentary notes that inflation-adjusted Medicare reimbursement for radiologists has fallen substantially over the past two decades even as workload has increased, and recent research has linked reimbursement pressures to widening access disparities in underserved communities.
"Radiology plays an increasingly important role across nearly every area of modern medicine," added Rula. "As policymakers evaluate strategies to improve health care value, it is essential that decisions reflect current evidence rather than outdated assumptions. Failing to recognize growing workload and capacity pressures risks compromising timely access to imaging services for the patients who need them most."
Publication details
David M. Cutler et al., Scanning the Health Care System in the US, JAMA Health Forum (2026). DOI: 10.1001/jamahealthforum.2026.1235
Journal information: Journal of the American Medical Association , JAMA Health Forum
Clinical categories
Who's behind this story?
Sadie Harley
BSc Life Sciences & Ecology. Microbiology lab background with pharmaceutical news experience in oil, gas, and renewable industries. Full profile →
Andrew Zinin
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
Citation: New commentary challenges outdated claims about imaging use and the radiologist workforce (2026, October 14) retrieved 14 October 2026 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2026-10-commentary-outdated-imaging-radiologist-workforce.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
来源:Medical Xpress · medicalxpress.com